Notable Kipling novel faces critical Americanism claim
A New York reader laments Kipling’s novel portrayal and argues the work remains a major achievement. suggests the librarian’s broad judgment should extend to admitting its merit despite perceived American bias.
The Profession of Letters and Who May Criticize It
The article debates Edmond Gosse’s claim that only those with special knowledge in letters should critique writers. It argues a broad view of profession, cites Worcester Stormonth and Century Dictionary definitions, and notes writers’ work as affecting readers and inviting critique from many fields. It includes examples from Bacon Browne and other thinkers to show cross professional insight.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Edward Clarke
Edmond Gosse
Mr. Gosse
Worcester
England
Stormonth
Seay
Lord Bacon
Sir Thomas. Browne
Sidney Smith
Walter Bagethot
British Board of Trade
Kipling's American Language and the Lost Local Flavor
A review of Kipling's Christmas story in Collier examines his grasp of American usage. The writer faults repeated misuses like pro position and pieces while praising the tale's vigor and cosmopolitan sensibilities, noting American readers' interest and noting related wartime anachronisms.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Rudyard Kipling
Collier
Library decisions on what books to place on the shelves
An address on public library book selection faces the dilemmas of weeded titles, expurgated classics, and the influx of new fiction. Librarians weigh demand, moral concerns, and time-tested value while balancing reader taste and public expectations.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Richard Calmady
Gorky
Shakespeare
Henry Esmond
The Strenuous Life and the Union’s Literary Theft
A reader notes that The Strenuous Life’s annual book number lifts articles from The New York Times Saturday Review of Books without credit. The piece also critiques The London Academy and Literature and laments anonymous letters while denying coverage of a poorly reviewed novel.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Springfield
Mass
NEW York Times Saturday Review OF Books
Mount Pelée
E. B. Dunn
David Graham Phillips
New York Times Saturday Review
Unpublished vs Published Criticism and Gosse’s Sensitivity
The article argues that criticism differs by publication status and that publishers often demand expertise from critics. It notes published criticism rarely affects a writer’s standing or finances, which depend on readers’ opinions. It singles out Mr Gosse’s sensitivity as excessive and somewhat absurd among many in the profession.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Gosse
Spenser Love Poems Limited Edition Published
Houghton Mifflin prints Prothalmion and Epithalmion by Edmund Spenser in a 419 copy quarto edition with Blashfield illustrations. The plates are destroyed and the poems, celebrated as Elizabethan lyric, honor Spenser's wedding day and the forthcoming marriages of Lady Elizabeth and Lady Catherine Somerset to Mr. Gilford and Mr. Peters.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Spenser
Messrs. Houghton, Mifflin & Co
Edmund Spenser
Edwin H. Blashfield
Elizabeth
Catherine Somerset
Gilford
Peters
Great Painters in Miniature
The late Lucy Barnes Baxter writing as Leader Scott authors a tiny Correggio volume in Hell's Miniature Series of Painters. The companion Burne-Jones by Malcolm Bell is praised for its account of Burne Jones life and works and the plates reproduced in the diminutive volume.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Lucy Barnes Baxter
Scott
Correggio
Hell
New York
Macmillan Company
Sir Edward Burne-Jones
Malcolm Bell
Burne
Also Mentioned on This Page
the New Yook Times
Saturday Review OF Books and Art
THE
NEW York Times
the “Profession” OF Letters
Buffalo Club
Yale
Kipling
New England
Ohio
South Africa
Kafirs
Commissariat
United States Army
Public Library Problems
London Academy and Literature
United States of America
Republic
Academy
London
America
Saturday Review
Runciman
Max Beerbohm
John Morgan Richards