Letter writer faces McCarthy era attack on ideas
The author describes a reader who opens with accusations of subversion and a bid for an inquisition, then tackles the argument poorly. The piece argues such tactics reveal the critic’s limitations and that intelligent readers see beyond ad hominem attacks.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
McCarthy
U.S
Principle over personal attack in political debate
A writer defends judging arguments by logic not identity or appearances. They argue that exposing weak points matters more than ad hominem blasts. Even if seen as conservative or liberal, proving the right principle is the goal, not status or hue.
Also Mentioned on This Page
Roblin Review
Publishel
1St Avenue
Roblin
Manitoba
D. H. Oliphant
Ah I.lependent
Post Office Department
Ty T.4
Canada
Shannon
Gestetner
P.O
Man
Lawrence Milner
Bins
Lawrence iMumer
Social Credit
Dauphin
Doreen
Wellington Crescent
Lawrence
Regina
Swan River
Massey Fergusn Ce AW
Winnipeg
An Welley-Dauphin
Roblin Pecnie
Volkswagen
Massey-Ferguson
Es “Uda
Carsusingssman’s Association of Canada
Dauphin Chamber of Commerce
Dauphin Toastmaster’s Sad
Dauphin Baptist Church
Roblin Memorial Hall
Martin Kelln
Social Credit Association of Canada
The
Social Credit Party of Manitoba
Memoriam
Staple
Isabella
Novether Sth
Albert
Dorothy
Reg
Dorothy Anne
Jim Neville
Makaroff
Larry and
Meryl Guymer
Roblin Hospital
Dr. Dorran
U.C.W. League
Evangeline Rebekah Lodge
Rose Gerega
San Clara Legion Hall
San Clara
St. Michael’s Parish
W.A
St. Michael’s Church
Ladies’ Auxiliary
Royal Canadian Legion
Memorial Hall
Thomas Watson
Zelmar
Yakimishyn
Smigelsky
Shell River
W.I
Kopelchuk
Heming’s Jewellery
Ladies’ Auxiliary of the
Merridale
Marshall Wells
UC W.L
White Elephant & Parcel
White Elephant and Parcel
Deepdale Ladies’ Aid
Deepdale United Church
Scamp Walton
Poodle
Toronto
Spadina
Pup
Scamp
W.A. of
Marshall Wells Limited
Ellice Avenue
J. C. Schick
John Craig
Phone 365
Inglis
Sandy Korbut
Paul Filewich
Zelena
Parkhill Construction
Beatty
J. Martin and Son
Chestenfield & Chair
Conquest
Parkland
Keystone Bailey
Rodney Oats
Ray Switzer
Tom Aitken
R.C.M.P
Jessie Hicklin
Alex Hawryluk
5Th Avenue
Ross
Gaber
Massey
Alex Smigelsky
Deepdale
E. Andres
N.W
R. W. Jakeman
Sidney
B.C
P. N. Hanson
Wm. Tkachuk
Calder, Sask
Peter Horbay
Grandview
Gilbert Plains
Saskatchewan
G. S. Kissuk
Federated Cooperatives Limited
Bond Penrose & CO
Chartered Accountants
162Nd Ave
N.E
Burke
Garnety Optometrist
Russell
V. J. Rosnoski
Russell Clinic
Gordon Dixon
Sec
Treas. — Reg Mortemore
Roblin Truck Service Ltd
Roblin and
District General Freight & Livestock
Demkiw & Szewczyk Barristers & Solicitors
Ind Ave
Marshall-Wells
Spigleman & Lichter
Sidney Shreiber
Chartered Accountant
Hilton Motor Hotel
Portage Ave
Russell Cattle Breeders
Russell H. Glen Cruikshank
Montana
Sam Lebedovich
Robert Shepherd
Jakeman Insurance Agency
Black & Armstrong Ltd
Hartford Fire Insurance Co
Manitoba Medical Services Plan
C. M. Bingham
Optometrist
Scott's Hardware Dauphin
Bob
COWAN
Avawarigsa
F. A. Newton
Portage
Wilson
al Allanson
Bob Farmer
McClocklin
11Th Street
Brandon
Electrohome
T.V
2Nd Ave. E
Roblin, Man
Charles Filewich
Hawryluk
Christ Church
Doore
Lorrayne Florists
Robertson’s Groceteria
Robiin
Top Mat Florists
Robln Memorial Chapel Ltd
Roblin — Phone
C.N.A
A.F.D.S
M.F.S Association
Sneath-Strilchuk Funeral Services Ltd
Ste. Rose Memorial Chapel Ltd
Ste. Rose
K. R. McBain
2Nd Avenue
China
Congoleum
Stephens Paints
Perth
Roblin Stockyards
Wm. Pouna
Wm. Shiner
Shell River Co-op Livestock Ass
Steve Kurchak
Roblin Truck Service Depot
F. H. Wilson
Nyte
Togo
Sask
Red Seal” Motors
Lincoln Electric
Davis Electric - Dauphin
Radio & T.V. Sales and Service
Westinghouse
Philco
Findley
Spartan