High Court Rules Porto Rico Not Foreign for Tariff Purposes
The U S supreme court divided over insular questions, ruling Porto Rico became United States territory upon ratification of the peace treaty, ruling duties on imports from the island illegal before Foraker act but later cases allowed certain duties. The De Lima and Downes opinions shape future U S relations with territories.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Washington
United States Supreme Court
United States
Philippines
de Lima
Downes
Porto Rico
New York
Congress
Harlan
Brewer
Gray
Shiras
White
McKenna
Brown
Goetze
Crossman
Dooley and Armstrong
United
Foraker
Executive Departments
Mr. Gallatin
Fleming
Senate
Texas
Hawaii
Paris
New York Port Duty Case Upheld in Supreme Court Decision
The Supreme Court majority, led by Justice Brown, sustains a lower court ruling in the Elias Dema et al case involving $12,000 in duties on goods shipped to Puerto Rico. The decision, with Justices Kenna Shiras and White dissenting, concerns port of New York collections and the authority of foreign territory taxation.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Elias 8. Dema
R. Bidwell
Port of
New York
Supremert
Circuit Court
State of
Justice Brown
Jus Kenna
Shiras
Stetet
Porto Rico
United States
Downes v. Collector Bidwell over Porto Rico duties
Justice Brown delivers the court's opinion in Downes v Bidwell, a suit by Downes to recover 669.35 back duties paid under protest on oranges from San Juan Porto Rico to New York in November 1900. The case tests whether Porto Rico merchandise is exempt from duty after the Foraker Act despite the 15 percent levy on foreign articles. the Southern District of New York and the Supreme Court uphold the circuit court, ruling Porto Rico remains within U S revenue authority.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Woodruff
Parham
Fassett
Board of General Appraisers
Customs Administrative Act
New Orleans
New York
Porto Rico
Marshall
Justice Story
United States
Spain
Congress
Texas
California
Ak Noi
Courts of Justice
Tt Ds
Circuit Court
Southern Division
de Lima
Columbia
Territories
District of Columbia
Supreme Court
Justice Brown
Tanney
Dred Scott
Scott
Downes
Bidwell
San Juan
Rad Spe
Southern District of New York
Porto B
United Vod
Foraker
Also Mentioned on This Page
Foraker Act
Insular
Constitution
Lowell
Pollard & Ge
Bobbinettes and
Rottinghams
Vici
Dragygeoia
Palmer Street
Merrimack Street
Pollard Merrimack, Palmer and
Middle Streets
Mer
PSS
Downes Vs. Bidwell
Otaoenne
Evar
Bowler Bros
Worcester
Mass
St. Vincent's Hospital
Union Paste Company
C. B. Coburn & Co
Market Street
Order of Buffalos
P. F. Devine
Merrimack ST
P.'S
Snyder Bros
Mebrkinack Street
Boston Woven Hose & Rubber Co
Cambridgeport
J. B. Goodwin
Thorndike Street
Paul R.barty
Col. Merrimack and
Bridge Sts
Fairmount Street
The
Courier