Prayers Efficacy Debate Sparks Reader Letters
The Boston Post invites readers to share experiences on whether prayers are answered. A Aug. 22, 1919 letter requests brief, specific communications to Prayer Editor, with optional anonymity, urging diverse religious perspectives on prayer and its outcomes.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Boston Post
New England
Post
Prayer as a daily discipline links will to the divine
In West Roxbury, the Rev. Howard S. Wilkinson argues prayer transcends requests and should be a steady habit. He says prayer aligns the will with God, yields spiritual power, and reveals the divine through daily life, with even faltering efforts answered in God’s way.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Howard S. Wilkinson
Emmanuel Episcopal Church
West Roxbury
Wilkinson
First Motor Corps
Kingdom of Heaven
Earth
Heaven
The Child's Prayer
A mother tells of Bobby who asks for a drum at Christmas despite poverty. After promising God answers prayers, an expressman delivers a large box containing a book and a letter from an old friend who had lost four children, illustrating a miracle of Christmas generosity.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
the Post
Bobby
Faith and a Drum Bring Joy to a Lonely Child
A fragment recalls a child’s joy as a drum is opened from wrapped gifts. The note speaks of faith and hope despite loneliness and grief, ending with the sentiment Have faith even as a little child and it shall be unto you.
Prayer Editor Letter Advocates Personal Scriptural Interpretation
S Adams of Lakeport New Hampshire argues prayers and their answers depend on divine revelation beyond human intellect. He offers to discuss specific passages and invites readers to send a self addressed stamped envelope for correspondence.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
S. Adams
Union Avenue
Lakeport
N. H
The Case Against Miracle Faith by George J. Burns
George J. Burns argues that miracles require suspending natural law, which he says is impossible and unjust. He states everyday outcomes arise from natural laws and subconscious processes, and that belief in prayer aligns with natural phenomena rather than supernatural intervention.
Three Requisites To the Prayer Editor of the Past
The letter argues three elements desire faith and work are needed for prayer to be answered. It asserts God provides daily bread when people act, and urges support for the League of Nations as a first step toward world peace, calling for action, prayer, and faith. C. M. Scovell signs the piece.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
League of Nations
C. M. Scovell
Whole-Hearted Belief In The Efficacy Of Prayer
George T. Chavitt of Montpelier Vermont shares a personal belief in prayer’s power. He recounts praying for a true friend after losing a college chum and writes that his prayers were answered years later with a companion who fit his needs. He cites biblical and literary examples and urges steadfast faith that persistent prayer yields results.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
University of Vermont
Middle West
Pacific Coast
Canada
Mexico
England
France
Belgium
Germany
Switzerland
Italy
Chum
Russell P. Conwell
David
Jonathan
Tennyson
Arthur Hallam
George T. Chavitt
State Street
Montpelier
Cured After 63 Doctors Gave Her Up
Minna A. Bradbury writes of a near miraculous recovery after eight years of illness. She credits prayer and faith, not Christian Science, for renewed health and strength. The note, dated September 10, 1919, urges others to trust in prayer on life’s difficult path.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Lfe
Minna A. Bradbury
Prayers and Prosperity in Wartime Satire
In a letter from Peabody dated Sept 9, James Walsh mocks prayer as an economic force while arguing for practical work. He contrasts prayer’s limits with farming duties and questions a ritualized, commercialized approach to petitions.
ANSWERED IN WAR for It To the Prayer Editor
The author argues prayers were answered in the recent war, citing Christ's sacrifice, Belgium's faith, and leaders’ statements. He notes German defeats followed President Wilson's day of prayer, claiming mothers and nations saw prayer rewarded and praises ongoing for belief in a prayer hearing. ANOTHER BELIEVER IN PRAYER.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Sir
Mother
Asu
Christ
Belgium
Germany
Hegium
Europe
Wilson
Prayer as a path to divine aid and action
A Northampton woman urges faith and persistent prayer, noting “Ask and you shall receive.” She explains God may answer through miracles or by guiding others, cites healing of Garfield and McKinley as possible outcomes, and emphasizes praying in Jesus name for effectiveness.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Garfield
McKinley
Question Authority and Faith in Prayers Argument
A reader argues that belief in the Bible lacks basis and questions its authority. She questions prayer efficacy during war, cites wireless invention aiding seafaring, and suggests that prayerful people should live by faith to clear their minds.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Mrs, Allston
Prayers and Proofs Across Faith and Reason
A reader defends prayer and belief in God against Ingersoll style skeptics. Citing Daniel Webster and prophecies, the writer argues for faith aided by personal experience, warns against paying for prayers for the dead, and quotes Longfellow while urging Scriptural study for light. BH. L. GLADDING acknowledges the discussion.
Father Reform Meant Prayer Revised Husband’s Life
A mother recalls how her 10 year old son prayed for his father’s drinking to end. The next day two ministers’ sons visited the couple’s store and invited the husband to a reform home. He went and returned reformed and converted, shaping the family’s faith in prayer.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
the Post
M. B
Answered Prayer Through Spirit Not Form, Belfast Letter
A Belfast reader argues that prayer cannot be answered by a personal God who would be corporeal. He asserts God is spirit, explains true prayer requires spiritual alignment, and urges renouncing carnal knowledge to attain real prayer and divine response.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
God
Christ
Harold
Webb
More Money For Veterans Bill Advances In House
The House pension committee favored a bill to grant a minimum monthly pension of 50 dollars to Civil War veterans. Widows would receive 30 dollars, children under 16 six dollars, and nurses 30 dollars. The measure would add 65 million to the pension roll in its first year. The bill also proposes 73 dollars for totally disabled veterans and 90 dollars for those disabled in service.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Washington
House Pension Committee
Moonshiner Indicted Faces Death by Own Action
Myron Chesler of Auburn, indicted today by a federal grand jury in Portland for operating an unlawful distillery, killed himself at his Lewiston home after learning of the charge. He had been blind from birth.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Lewiston
Myron Chesler
Auburn
Portland
Duty Call Takes Rival Candidates
John C. Brimblecom and Reuben Forknall, Newton Republicans vying for the 4th Middlesex seat, were drafted into the State Guard in Boston amid a police strike. The duty threatens their campaigns as 450 Newton GOP votes could shift the result, leaving both men unable to vote for themselves while they watch each other closely. COL James C. Whith commands Newton constabulary.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
John C. Brimblecom
Reuben Forknall
Newton
State Guard
Boston
Board of Aldermen of
Ember
Board of Aldermen
Newton Constabulary
Massachusetts House of Representatives
Middlesex
Leland Powers
Coolidge
Reuben Forkwall
Constabulary
Company A
1Lth Regiment
The
Does not slip away and get to work on the sly
A terse note asserts someone stays on task openly rather than secretly. It implies scrutiny or public accountability without detailing actions or identities. The line hints at integrity or exposure risk but provides no concrete names, dates, or places.
Subscriptions Opened for Irish Republican Loan
Dublin September 19 subscriptions for the Irish republican loan of 1 250 000 were opened with no reliable response data yet. Prospectuses were sent to Sinn Fein agencies for hand distribution and many were mailed via the British post. There is speculation whether mailed copies will be delivered or confiscated as illegal matter.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Dublin
Sinn Fein
Also Mentioned on This Page
Doubter
Durance
George J. Burns
Chandler & Co
Serge
Jersey
Peabody
Flanders
James
John
Patrick
Michael
James Walsh
Fulton Street
Northampton
Colonel Ingersoll
Moses
Ingersoll
Daniel Webster
Daniel
Longfellows
Gladding
Father
Horlick
Infante and & Wits
Belfast
James C. Whith
Massachusetts National Guard
How
Irish Republican Loan
Paine
Paine Furniture Company
Arlington Street
Boylston Street