Heresy trial for Rev. Heber Newton sparks debate
The piece discusses Rev. Heber Newton of New York facing a heresy trial and contrasts historical penalties with modern public reaction. It notes Newton’s defense, asserts he attacked no creed, and reflects on shifts in societal tolerance, religious fellowship, and the broader implications for church unity and individual standing.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
John Quincy Adams
New England
New York Times
John Adams
Cambridge
Boston
Back Bay
Cohasset
New York
Wilkinson
Massachusetts Superior Court
Rockwell
Heber Newton
Inquisition
Newton
Gentleman
Scoffers
Washington
Bayard
New York Herald
Mr. Bayard
Nicaragua
Bismark
John Bull
New Orleans
Lowell
Chicago Almshouse
Chicago
New York Graphic
Brooklyn Times
Philadelphia
Philadelphia News
Zola
Philadelphia Call
N. T
Pat
Casabianca
Jimmy
Chicago Herald
Newark News
Nantucket
Jefferson
Madison
Harvard University
Nasby
Toledo
Confederate X Roads
Kentucky
Halstead
Commercial Gazette
Cleveland
Dana
Cincinnati Enquirer
Yseult Dudley
Detroit Free Press
Yseult
Pinckneyville
Ill
Carter Harrison
United States Senate
New York Sun
Sun
New Jersey
Maine
Portland
Hawks
Preble
San Francisco
Cape Elizabeth
Longfellow
George M. Stearns
Springfield
Jim Piggott
Connecticut
House of Representatives
Jim
Bowdoin Orient
Bowdoin
Gillett
Carter
Buffalo
R. P. Lee
Lee
Brother Lee
Buckalew
Pennsylvania
Gov. Ritner
Centre County
Australia
Louisiana and Texas Railroad and Steamship Company
Star and Crescent
Sunset
North River
Mississippi River
Mobile
Texas
Arizona
New and Old Mexico
California
Galveston
E. E. Carriek
N. E
Washington Street
E. Hawley
General Eastern
Broadway
Commonwealth OF Massachusetts
State House
William H. Duncan
Catholic Church of
Thomas F. Hendricken
Providence
Massachusetts
Elijah Harr
T. Corwin Watkins
Methodist Preachers
Thomas Power
P. T. O'Reilly
Jno
J. Power
Worcester
William Byrne
R. Perry Bush
Universalist Ministers
Institutions of Learning
Samuel O. Ingalls
Also Mentioned on This Page
Boston Post
Congress
Green Room
Mr. Newton
Mr. Bayard and
Terrapin
Gen
Gordon
el Mahdi
O’donovan Rossa
Tossa
Col
Robert G. Ingersoll
Satan
Bob
E. c
Washington Monument
Richmond
Dalton
Georgia
Illinois
Crisp
Edith
Yonker
Statesman
la Nature
Garabit Bridge
France
Kansas
Jones
Smith
Boston Courier
Richardson
Bomhbay
Lewis
Cape
Brunswick
Julia Futch
Mary Stacy
Thomas & CO
Mile Street
Handel & Hayon Society
Handel
Boston Music Hall
Miedora Henson
Emily Winant
W.J. Winch
M. W. Whitney
Listemann
B. J. Lang
Car
Zerrahn
E. B. Hagar
Elansons
Voyace EN Suisse
Switzerland
Hansons
Rigi Kulm
Henry Irving
Ellen Terry
Globe Theatre
the Lyceum Company
G. Willis
Eugene Akan
Eugene Aram
Henry Irving Buth Meadows
Menchant OF
Venice
W.G. Willis
Charles I
Cassimir Delavigne
Louis XI
Grand Union Billiard Hall
Sudbury St
Mass
Wm. FP
Marshall
Kane
Barnard
Throckway
Gilman
Little
O' Neil
Banard
Brockway
O'Neil
Mtuth
Boston Theatre
Margaret Mather
Juliana
J. M. Hill
Macbeth
Lawrence Barrett
Boston Museum
Fantine
Iolan the
BIJOU
McCaull Opera Comique Co
John A. McCaull
Pirates of Penzance
Gettysburg
Paul Philippoteaux
Tremont Street
Berkeley
Clarendon Streets
B. Y. M. AG. Association
Will Carleton
Golden Horse
Woodworth
M. R. Deming
Howard Atheneum
Kernell
Hickeringy
United States
Chickering & Sons
Bernicat and Messager
B. E. Woolf
B. M
Herbert and
Elsa
Cts
Eugene Es
Christoforus
Shcenger
Ileroes
Trowbridge and Cobb
E. A. Emerson
G.swayne
Scould
Emma Pitt
Oliver Ditson & CO
New Haven, Conn
Geo. Wm. Ballou & Co
Kidder, Prabody & CO
Devonshire St
Nassau St
Messes
Baring Brothers & CO
Europe
Franklin S. Phelps
Merchants Exchange
State St
John Jeffries & Sons
Devonshire Street
Virginia
Carolinae
Mast
Atlantic Coast Line
Seaboard Air Line
Boston and Norfolk Steamship Co
Central Wharf
Piedmont AI Line
B. B
Ak A. Pearor
N. Mag
Baltimore, Norfolk and Washington Steamship Line
Norfolk
Baltimore
Frei
Begabia
Louisiar
O. J
Atlant
Wienington Street
B. Co. Feru
Alexandria
Carolinas
Alabama
Raed
Tennessee
Florida
Mississippi
Arkansas
Washington Run Street
Seaboard
Ward A. Pearce
Ning
Washington Strees
Solomon Howes
Tien
Central
Wash & Cushing
Milk Street
Texas & Florida
Galveston & Key
State of Texas
Seth Sprague
G. BE. A
Old State House
C. H. Mallory & CO
Boston & Philadelphia Steamship Line
Norman
Long Whart
Spartan
Charleston
Savannah
Wilmington
Rother Yerall
KE. B.sampson
Long Wharf
C&m.d
Ted
ST. Croix
Jamaica
M. Doherty & CO
Kneeland St
Endicott Gesect
M. Doherty
Oc. F. Doherty
Great Southern
Sonal Wien
Savannar
H. Ring
Nickerson
Y. Sampson
New YO
N.Y
South Carolina
Fianarae
Sampson
Washington St
Hostome
Cunard Steamship Company Limited
Liverpool
Queenstown
Cork Harbor
Samaria
Catalonia
Cephalonia
Pavontia
Great Britain and Ireland
State Street
Apitf P
Glasgow
Siberian
Gr&cian
Britain
Verpool
Halifax
N.S
Lontonvderry
Charles V. Casey
Broad Street
Spat H.& A. Allan
Warren & CO
Borderer
Palestine
Norseman
Post Office Square
Leyland Line Steamships
Virginian
Shaver & Lincoln
Texett
Prince Edward Island
S. S
Jesse H. Freeman
Nickeson
N.S.S
W. H. King
A. Dew. Sampson
Azores
Sarah
Hale
OC. L. Bartlett & Co
Annapolis
Nova Scotia
S.S
S.35. Co
Yarmouth
Dominion
F. L. Clements
Lewis Wharf
Hava
Mexico
Havana
Mexican
Vera Cruz
F. Alexandre & Sons
N. Y
Furness Line
London
Parhem City Servico
Boston City
Gothenburg City
York City
Co. Furness
Red Star Line
Antwerp
A. Adams & CO
C. L Bartlet & Co
Cor
White Star Line
C. L
India Wharf
Lion Lines
TmRxovem
Tanowen Buia Oy
BW. M. Whitney
Metropolitan
Morgan
Orleans
Cromwell
Linth
Steamship
Louisiana
E. V. Gager
Taturday
Hudson
H. B. Freeman
Pier 9
New Mexico
Red Rivers
Cal
Samuel H. Seaman
New , Or
J. M. Magna
Augustine H. Read
Committee On
Committee On Labor
Blue Room
James F. Stratton
Jas. F. Stratton
Railroads
Fall River Line
Id Colony
Fall Hiver
Bristol
Brooklyn
Jersey City
Washington and
State Streets
L. H. Palmer
J.B. Kendrick
Boston & Lowell Railroad
Causeway Street
Tilton
Laconia
Sage Village
Weirs
Meredith
Ashland
Plymouth
Franklin
Lebanon
White River Junction
Montpelier
Essex Junction
Johnsbury
Montreal
Burlington
St. Albans
Warren
Haverhill
Woodsville
Newport
Sherbrooke
Quebec
Ogdensburg
Claremont
Powts
Peteboro
White Mountains
Pullman
Central Vemont &. K
Pascumpsie
KR. R
Manchester
Concord
N. H
Keene
Peterboro
Teenafield
Hillsboro
Het
Wilton
Milford
Weehua
Miéacnery
Billerica
Walinut Hill
Stoneham
Woburn
Winchester
West Medfornd
Her
Somerville
Winter Hill
Bedford
Lexington
Arlington
Lowell and Way
Peer
Nashua
Northern
Essar
C.S. Mellen
Lucius Tuttle
Sun’t
Montreal & West
Welnie
Vermont
Fitchburg
Western Division
Bangor
Mt. Desert
St. John
Eastport
Joan
Calais
Nwn
N. Bee
Hochland
Maine Central
Trank Railways
Lewiston and
Augusta
Forere Bay
Rochester
Een Bartsb
S Sa
M. H
Worth
Hennebunk
Biddeford
Saco
Iddeford
Great Falls
Dover
Exeter
Merrimac
Etown
Jor Lawrenos
North Lawrence
South Ramee
Wakefield
Upper Depot
Centre Depot
Danvers
Newburyport
Melrose
Maiden
Medford
Lawrences
Dower
Theat Falls
Portiana
Lewiston
Lawrence
Reading
South Lawrence
New York and
R. Kk
Philadelphe
NEW England Limited
Hartford
Willimantic
Waterbury
Danbury
Brewster's
Fishkill
Wewbure
New Britain
Rockville
Conn
Norwich
R. Southbridge and Webster
Putnam
Dudley St
Bird St
Mt. Bow
Dein
Harvard St
Dorchester
Pu. Mattapan
River Street
Hyde Park
Readvile
Oakdale
Elmwood
Islington
Ellis
Norwood
Norwood Central
Winslows
Tiltons
Walpole
Highland Lake
Blackstone
Woonsocket Division
Needham and Way
VW Oonsocket
Summer St
THE
AIR Line
Washington Express
Charlestn
Jacksonville
Fla
Steamboat Express
New London
Point Judith
Summer Street
W. H. Turner
A. C. Ndall
Gen. Pass
OLD Colony Railroad
Fall River
Taunton
Bridgewater
Een
New Bedford
Central Station
Dean St
North Easton
Stoughton
Randolph
Sea
Middleboro
Brockton
Abington
Duxbury
South
Aingham
Hasset
Hingham
Braintree
Quincy
Neponset
Harrison Square
Cottage City
Cape Cod
Province Town
Hyannis
Barnstable
Sandwich
Bourne
South Braintree Anaway
South Braintree
Hingram
the Weymouths
Opiy
J. B. Kendrick
Beet
Friend Street
Eetreet
Ban
Gor
Provinces
Au Rauj
Thurs
Mit
Desert
Bar Harbor
Air
Millbridge
Peta Pai de Mia
Chiasport
Mt. Ferry
Waterville
Skowhegan
Farmington
Hockland
Orth Conway
Wolfboro
Portsmouth
Hampton
Beach
North Hiampton
Hye Beach
Amesbury
Upswich
Wenham
Met
Rockport
Gloucester
Beverly
Arm
Middletom
Peabody and Danvers
Salem
Marblehead and
Wamopscott Branch
Stet
Marblehead
Agen
Ufm
Lyi
Hevere
Chelsea
Everett
W.everett
Maiden and Saugus Branch
Het. West Everett
Saugus
Jas Tf
Furber
Fitchbore Railroad
Hoosac Tunnel
St. Louis
W.S. and
B. Railroad
Troy
West
Gardner
Baldwinville
Athol Orange Miller’s Falls
Greenfield
Shelburne Falls
North Adams
Iston
Erving
Wachusett
Otter River
Wendell
Eastfield
Montague
Westminsteran
Peerfield
Bucksend
Zoar
Barnvwells
Charlemont
Hooeac
Turner’s Falls
Brattlebore
Winchendon
Bellows Falls
Ina
Cheshire
Keene and
Hochester Ralilroad
Groton
Framingham and
South Framingham
Fitchle
Rpu
Leominster
South Acton
Concord Junction
Shirley
Ayer Junction
Greenwich and Townsend Centre
Pam
Marlboro
Hudson and Maynard
Waltham
Belmont and Waverley
Waverley
Suzu
Watertown
Union Market
Auburn
Atertown
Wareiver B.B
Patriot
Supiz
Rebrentano
Guieoa Squiere
New York City
Stonington Line
HON
Boston & Provid
Sun — Mosor
Bound Brook
Kew York
Trenton
Phila EL
Bis
York
Lavertyne
Philade
Ninth & Oe Sts
Tee & Berks Sts
GLAND
P. Baldwin
Hancock
Wootten
Lake
Boston Air Line
Passymousie & South Eastern Railroads
Plymouth, N
R.B
Bradford
Welle Wells
Lake Memphremagor
Bradford E
Pells River
Penny St
Lyndonville
A.M
Erbrooke JF
Coxon
Boston Montreal
Wmit
Raymond
Bostom
Shore Line
Pawtucket
Dodgeville
Wicbronville
Heturn
Attleboro
Bee Turn
North Attleboro
Mansfield
Astloxboro Ek
Turm
Sharon
Hyde
de Readville
Mt. Trove
Clarendo
Tee
Jax
Eave Ay
Keywlston
Canton
Xbury
Ami
King Street
West Hoxbury
A. Polsom
Baileroad Road
B. Ana L
Qucncord
Grape
B. and
Chamberlir
Gent
Winter ST
A. Stowell & CO
L&t
Peart St
Cor. Franklin
J. Winnett
Kilby Street
Bath Street
Moses Williams
Postoffice Sq
Wm. Co. Opman &J.G. Freeman
Peart Street
Chester Square
Tne
Hove Alexandra
South End
J. M. Wade
LLEWV
Chester
Shawmut Avenue
J.M. Wade
Ee Eouse
Brookline
Park Street
James H. Beals
Post Building
Medford Hillside
Neponset Station
Depot
Themont
John Brooks Meee
Portand
Grand Trunk
Ortland & Ogdensburg
Knox & Limecols
Lian Wheel
Boston & Bangor S. S. CO
Foster’s
Rockland
Anobscot
William H. Hill, Jr
Dom Tastisac
Mather
desstuwySma
Addrass Rostre
Masel
Rye Steamship Mansas
Plee
Grand Junction
Wabred & CO
Feag
This is just the beginning! Our collection holds over 300 years of history, including rare newspapers, obituaries, marriage records, birth records, and so much more—most of which you won’t find anywhere else!