Government victory marked in six month compliance ruling
Officials hailed the decision as a practical government victory while noting the term unreasonable restraint delineates permissible limits and opens new litigation pathways. The ruling underscores a shifting balance in regulatory control and future legal challenges.
Supreme Court declares Standard Oil a monopoly in unreasonable restraint
The Supreme Court rules Standard Oil Company as a conspiracy and monopolizing interstate commerce in violation of the Sherman antitrust law. The decree dissolves the trust, extends the wind-up period to six months, and applies the rule of reason to restraint of trade. Chief Justice White explains the decision, with Justice Harlan dissenting on the scope of the law.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Standard Oil Company
Harlan
Taft
Tobacco Trust
Supreme Court of the United States
White
New Jersey Corporation
Standard Oil Corporation
United States
Standard Oil Trust
Asustice Harlan
Congress
JURT DECISION WILL DISSOLVE STANDARD OIL
Attorney General Wickersham announces the Supreme Court affirming most government positions in the case. The Chief Justice writes for the court that only contracts and combinations restraining interstate trade or unduly restricting competition fall under the Sherman Act prohibition, a view with the entire court concurring.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Standard Oil
Supreme Court
Mexico Peace Talks Pivot on Cabinet and Governing Posts
Provisional President Francisco I. Madero Jr. and envoy Judge Carbajal conferred in Juarez amid hopes for swift peace. The rebels demand fourteen governors and four cabinet seats, while the government offers ten governors and one cabinet post. Diaz resignation looms as negotiations unfold with new instructions and potential concessions. Mexico City sources say Diaz may resign and De la Barra could become provisional president. Dr Inse Madris, Nicaragua’s ex-president and refugee, dies in Mexico City.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Insurrectos
Madero
Diaz
Juarez
Mexico
Francisco I. Madero, Jr
Senor Madero
Carbajal
Madero House
Francisco Madero, Jr
Rafael Hernandez
Sekit
Senor Carbajal
Mexico City
Corral
Vasquez Gomez
Senor de la Barra
Congress
House of Deputies
Inse Madris
Nicaragua
Afugee
Bailey cites statute construction curbing monopolies
Senator Bailey states the court has interpreted the law as it stands and should, preventing monopolies while allowing all lawful business to operate without undue interference. The remark emphasizes the balance between legal restraint and legitimate enterprise.
Girl dies shielding father in shotgun duel near Bixby
Ironton Mo May 5 special to The Washington Post recounts Effie Butler 19 killed when she shielded her father James Bixby 60 during a neighbor’s gun battle. Drew Pitts 48 surrendered after a long exchange. both men wounded and likely to die. Pitts described the events and motives in a confession.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Washington Post
Ironton
Effie Butler
Bixby
James Bixby
Drew Pitts
Effie, Butler
Central Labor Union Rejects Arbitration Pact With Britain
The Central Labor Union denounces the arbitration treaty with Great Britain as a British‑interests plot. Andrew Carnegie is denounced as a hypocrite and enemy of labor for supporting the accord. The group asks the Senate foreign relations committee to oppose ratification.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Central Labor Union
Great Britain
Andrew ‘Carnegie
Washington
Senate Committee On Foreign Relations
P. J. Ryan
Plate
Andrew Carnegie
Ohio Poet Piatt Hurt in Runaway Horse Mishap
John James Piatt aged 78 known as The Ohio Poet was injured near North Bend when a horse bolted and he was thrown from the vehicle fracturing his right shoulder blade His son Guy witnessed the accident Piatt has served as clerk of the Treasury librarian of Congress and U S consul at Cork and Dublin.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Washington Post
Cincinnati
John James Piatt
Ohio
North Bend
Here
Piatt
Guy
Pitt
United States
United Statea Tresaury
Ibrarian of
Congres
Cork
Dublin
Senator Culberson Opinion Described as Pure Judicial Legislation
The majority's view on the act's construction is labeled pure judicial legislation by Senator Culberson, a move he says boards trusts have sought for fifteen years to aid their combinations and conspiracies against trade.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Straint
Justice Harlan
Ita
Congress
Corporation
United States
Weven
Mob Riot In Grand Rapids Over Strike At Widdicomb Furniture
A mob of about 2 000 rioters including many women attacked police near the Widdicomb Furniture plant in Grand Rapids Michigan. Dozens of officers were injured and several rioters hurt as revolvers clubs stones and missiles flew. Firemen dispersed the crowd with water streams as the mob fought back.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Grand. Rapids
Mich
Widdicomb Furniture Company
Ralph Widdicomb
Furniture Company
Ellis
Diamonds in teeth betray party headed for Alaska
New York May 15 diamonds flashing in the teeth helped expose a counterfeit gang led by the Montenegrans and the Glenards. Mrs Cleo Gienard and her husband were among the prisoners as sleuths traced the operation through the gem set smiles. Suspects include Marke Pagonich Sam Pekovich and Michaelo Karakashsvich. They planned to flee to Douglas Alaska with engraving tools and printing stone.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Washington Post
New York
Cleo Gienard
New Orleans
James Glenard
Taylor
John Henry
Frank Burke
Glenard
Marke Pagonich
Sam Pekovich
Michaelo” Karakashsvich
Douglas
Alaska
Secret
Rebels Capture Pachuca and Talencingo in Hidalgo
Mexico City reports rebels seize Pachuca, capital of Hidalgo, and nearby Talencingo with no shots fired. Government buildings including the jail and governor’s palace were burned as rebels swarmed into the city, freeing prisoners and spreading terror among residents.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Mexico City
Pachuca
Hidalgo
Talencingo
Fred
the Way
Ruling Will Dissolve Oil Trust
A front page item reports a ruling aimed at breaking up the oil trust, signaling potential major antitrust action and ensuing political debate. Other notes include labor opposition to arbitration pacts and local societal and cultural mentions.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Oil Trust
Kaiser
Hammond
Washington
Standard
Taft
Society
Woman Hides to Hear Carnegie at Founders Day
Mrs Annie Moore a Carnegie Institute janitress hid under tropical plants on stage during founders day to hear Andrew Carnegie. Detected by Mrs Carnegie who identified her from a box, leading to a letter of thanks and a $10 gift from Mrs Carnegie.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Washington Post
Pittsburg
Annie Moore
Carnegie Institute
Andrew Carnegie
Car]negie
Girl Leaps From Bridge Into Anacostia River
Eighteen year old Edna Hill leaped from the Pennsylvania avenue bridge into the Anacostia River. She was rescued by boatmen George French and William Graham after sinking in the riverbed. At the hospital she said she had no reason to end her life and declined to identify herself.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Edna Hill
Sixth Street
Pennsylvania Avenue
Antacostia
Stephens
Eleventh Precinct
A. J. Kean
Casualty Hospital
George French
William Graham
Sergt. Stephens
Supreme Court Drops Labor Leaders Contempt Sentence
The Supreme Court set aside the imprisonment of Samuel Gompers John Mitchell and Frank Morrison in the Buck s Stove case ruling the lower court erred by convicting them for civil contempt. The decision leaves open the possibility of retrial on criminal contempt grounds and confirms organized labor and its officers can be targeted legally.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Samuel Gompers
John Mitchell
Frank Morrison
American Federation of Labor
Supreme Court of the United States
Buck’s Stove and Range Company
Federation
Tower Court
Supreme Court
Justice Lamar
Gempers, Mitchell, and Morrison
American Federationist
Supreme Court of the District of Columbia
Gompers
Mitchell
Morrison
District Court of Appeals
Buck's Stove and Range Company
Court of Last Resort
Lamar
Court of Appeals
Supreme Court of the District
Columbia
Also Mentioned on This Page
U. S. Supreme
Asmeviate Justics Arha
Ilegal
United States Circuit Cort
District of
Missouri
Wickersham
Frank B. Kellogg
Lourt
Capitol
Diadero
Pvisional
Gen. Diaz
Interior Department
Madriz
Bailey
Effie
CL. A
Body
England
Carnegie
Tranmaster
Hurt
Senator Culberson
Grand Rapids
Secret Service
Senator la Follette
Edna Hil
Anacostia Basin
Sades