Judge upholds Thibodeau conviction in 1994 Heidi Allen case
Oswego County Court Judge Daniel King rejected Gary Thibodeau’s bid for a new trial after a 14 month hearing. The 64 page decision denied claims prosecutors botched the Allen investigation and that three other men might have influenced the kidnapping and possible death of Heidi Allen, last seen at the D W Convenience Store in New Haven on April 3, 1994.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Oswego
Gary Thibodeau
Heidi Allen
Oswego County
Daniel King
Thibodeau
Allen
D&w Convenience Store
New Haven
Lisa Peebles
Sheriff Todd says case proves initial belief was right
Oswego County Sheriff Reuel Todd defended the 1995 kidnapping conviction of Gary Thibodeau, saying he never wavered. A judge denied Thibodeau’s bid to overturn the conviction, citing unreliable new evidence from witnesses who claimed to hear incriminating statements about Heidi Allen’s disappearance. Todd recalled leading the 1994 probe and insisted law enforcement did a good job despite defense criticism.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Oswego
Reuel Todd
Gary Thibodeau
Thibodeau
Daniel R. King
Heidi Allen
Todd
Allen
James Steen
Roger Breckenridge
Michael Bohrer
Lisa Peebles
Sheriff's Office
Thibodeau brother loses bid to overturn 1995 kidnapping conviction
Richard Thibodeau calls the ruling unbelievable as Judge Daniel R. King rejects Gary Thibodeau’s request to vacate his 1995 kidnapping conviction for Heidi Allen. The judge finds new witnesses unreliable and finds no prosecutorial violations. Gary Thibodeau remains incarcerated for 20 years to life.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Gary Thibodeau
Daniel King
Heidi Allen
Thibodeau
Plan
Richard Thibodeau
Gary
Oswego
Daniel R. King
Judge Finds No Fraud in 1995 Heidi Allen Case Conviction
Oswego County Judge Daniel King ruled that prosecutors did not commit fraud or misrepresentations in the 1995 kidnapping conviction of Gary Thibodeau for the Heidi Allen case. Allen, last seen April 3, 1994 at a New Haven D and W Convenience Store, remains missing as Thibodeau serves 25 to life.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Gary Thibodeau
Oswego
Heidi Allen
Thibodeau
Allen
Also Mentioned on This Page
Oakes
By Benjamin Kail
Msan
Palitimes.com
Ridge
Rona
Bohrer
Ning
Sheriff Todd
By Seth Wallace
District Attorney's Office
Convic
Entertainment Tvient
Fahey
Onondaga County Court
King
This is just the beginning! Our collection holds over 300 years of history, including rare newspapers, obituaries, marriage records, birth records, and so much more—most of which you won’t find anywhere else!