Thibodeau loses again as appeals court upholds conviction
Oswego County Appeals panel rules three to one that Gary Thibodeau’s bid for a new trial based on alleged botched investigation and new testimony does not merit a retrial. Judge Centra dissented, while prosecutors say the conviction remains supported by overwhelming evidence. Heidi Allen went missing in 1994 and was never found.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Gary Thibodeau
Oswego County
New Haven
Heidi Allen
Thibodeau
Rochester
State Court of Appeals
Fourth Judicial Department
John Centra
Lisa Peebles
Gary
Allen
D&w
Richard
Greg Oakes
Dissent urged new trial in Heidi Allen kidnapping case
A dissenting judge in the New York appellate ruling urged that Gary Thibodeau deserves a new trial. Judge John Centra argued there is newly discovered evidence, including independent confessions and credible eyewitness testimony, suggesting another man may have committed the crime. Thibodeau’s lawyers welcomed the dissent, saying they are pleased with it.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Rochester
Gary Thibodeau
Thibodeau
Heidi Allen
John Centra
State Supreme Court Appellate Division
Fourth Department
Allen
Heidi
Centra
Lisa Peebles
Family still seeks Heidi Allen in 1994 disappearance
Lisa Burke says the ultimate goal remains elusive as the Thibodeau kidnapping conviction persists after more than 20 years. Oswego County officials are praised for perseverance, with Burke and Buske stressing a continued push to uncover Heidi’s whereabouts and involving the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Allen
Heidi
Mexico
Lisa Burke
New Haven
Burke
Rochester
Gary Thibodeau
Heidi Allen
Friday
Thibodeau
Buske
Oswego County
Greg Oakes
Reuel Todd
National Center For Missing and Exploited Children
Sheriff's Office
Also Mentioned on This Page
Daniel
Peebles
Ben Kail
Anita Chee
Thibodeau Casé
S.com
Lisa Buske