Constitutional limits on annexation and tariffs in Porto Rico case
The argument centers on whether Porto Rico remained a foreign country under the 1897 tariff act and if duties levied on goods from Porto Rico violate the constitutional provision that duties be uniform across the United States. Goetze and Brown present four points about constitutional bounds, treaty interpretation, and the status of Porto Rico post Treaty of Paris, with case references and anticipated arguments in related suits. The proceedings also reference extradition issues under the Blaine Treaty and recent court rulings on tariff classifications and state constitutions.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Porto Rico
United States
Firet
Paris
Brown
Goetze
Ontario
Can
Chicago
Trude
Illinois
E. A. Morrison & Son
H. Wolf & Co
Circuit Court
Southern District of
New York
Circuit Court of Appeals
William B. Tyler
Court of Registration
Supreme Court of Massachusetts
Justice Brown
Tyler
Harlan, Brewer
Shiras
Supreme Court considers bail in Rice Rulledge Jones extradition case
In Washington on December 17 the Supreme Court heard two counter motions in the habeas corpus case of Frederick Lee Rice Frank Rulledge and Thomas Jones tied to the 1889 extradition treaty with Britain. An unusual bail motion was filed by S H Trude representing petitioners while Leyden Evans urged dismissal or fast hearing. The Illinois Circuit Court decision is on appeal and the matter raises several legal questions after the petitioners were accused of a bank robbery.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Washington
United States Supreme Court
Frederick Lee Rice
Frank Rulledge
Thomas Jones
United States
Great Britain
Blaine
Julian Pauncefote
H. Trude
Chicago
Leyden Evans
Supreme Court
Circuit Court
District of
Illinois
House Passes Bills on Districts and Pensions in Diverse Actions
The House, under suspension, approved measures to split Kentucky and West Virginia into two judicial districts, create another Ohio district judge, and refer Texas’ Greer County public works reimbursements to the Interior Secretary for review. A proposed veterans preference bill failed amid fears it would bar civilians for years. One hundred two private pension bills were enacted. A tribute to Representative Charles A. Boutelle of Maine preceded a unanimous-consent request to retire him as a Navy captain, which passed after open acknowledgment of his health.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Washington
House
Kentucky
West Virginia
Ohio
Secretary of the Interior
Texas
Greer
Supreme Court
Oklahoma
Spain
Philippines
Charles A. Boutelle
Maine
Congress
Littlefield
Kentucky Leaves Smyrna for Port Said on Way to Manila
Washington reports from Smyrna say the battleship Kentucky departed for Port Said en route to Manila. Officials fear Britain pressing Turkey over American claims could derail talks and hinder aid to missionaries. The Turkish government cites the burden of European claims as an obstacle to paying American claims. Porto Rico’s claim against Cuba.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Washington
Chester
Navy Department
Smyrna
Kentucky
Port Said
Manila
State Department
Great Britain
Turkey
United States declines to intervene in Porto Rico Cuba claim
Washington reports the State Department says the U S government cannot aid Porto Rico in its $2 500 000 claim against Cuba. Sanctioning collection could invite many larger claims exhausting Puerto Rico resources and reopening Paris Treaty disputes. Claimants still expect pursuit by foreign governments after American control ends.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Washington
State Department
United States
Porto Rico
Cuba
Paris
Indorsing Notes Triggers Bankrupt Petition in City Firm
Louis Hess filed in U S District Court for Otto B Shulhof & Co a bankruptcy petition. Liabilities exceed assets by 11 000 in notes endorsing Bowlby Klein Becker formerly at 5 Broadway. The firm hopes to continue business despite the bankruptcy filing and 15000 assets against liabilities.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
United States District Court
Louis Hess
Broadway
Otto B. Shulhof & Co
Bowlby, Klein & Becker
Shulhof & Co
Nominations by the President for Army Navy Posts
The President sent nominations to the Senate. John G Clague is named assistant commissary general with rank of colonel. William L Alexander promoted to lieutenant colonel as assistant commissary general. George B Pavis becomes commissary with rank of major. Ralph W Jones to second lieutenant. Navy: George H Barber to surgeon, Samuel Sayre Rodman to assistant surgeon, John Mosley Brister to assistant surgeon.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Army
John G. Clague
William L. Alexander
George B. Pavis
Ralph W. Jones
44Th
United States Volunteer Infantry
Navy
George H. Barber
Samuel Sayre Rodman
Kentucky
John Mosley Brister
Pennsylvents
President to witness Ohio launching in San Francisco
Washington December 17 President Scott of the Union Tron Works San Francisco builders of the battleship Ohio saw the President and received assurance that barring an unforeseen event he would attend the ship launching in San Francisco next May. The exact date was not fixed.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Washington
Scott
Union Tron Works
San Francisco
Ohio
House Census Reapportionment Sparks Clash Over New House Size
Washington action on the Hopkins and Burleigh reapportionment bills triggers fierce debate as lawmakers weigh a reduced House size. Ohio and New York shift gains and losses in proposed member totals, with states lobbying to protect influence in the Electoral College.
Senate Holds Brief Open Session In December Washington
The Senate met in open session for one hour in Washington on December 17, with the remainder in executive session over the Hay Pauncefote treaty. Senator Chandler attempted to revive a resolution on the Stottana Be Senatorship, but was unsuccessful. No legislative business beyond routine matters was completed.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Washington
Senate
Chandler
Stottana
Charges Against Alaska Court Spark Senate Probe
Senator Carter of Montana introduced a resolution directing the Judiciary Committee to investigate the Alaska District Court at St Michael's and Judge Noyes. The inquiry will cover alleged improper actions or illegal conduct in litigation, names of involved parties, and related receivers or officers, with powers to subpoena and fund the probe.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Washington
United States District Court of
Alaska
Cape Nome
Carter
Montana
Senate
Committee On
District Court of
St. Michael's
Noyes
The Threat of Typhoid and a New Disinfectant
An article extols nascent oxygen disinfectant Hydrozone as a safe, effective remedy for typhoid and a preventive for drinking water and milk. It cites doctors and medical journals praising peroxide of hydrogen solutions, warns against boiling water, and urges wide use to combat disease in cities facing tainted supplies.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
F. H. Wiggin
West Thirty-sixth St
New-York Medical Record
Robert C. Kenner
Louisville
New Albany Medical Record
M A. Clark
Macon
Medical and Surgical Reporter
Philadelphia
Marchand
New York Representative Ray Pushes Train Robbery Bill
In Washington on December 17 Representative Ray introduces a bill to suppress train robbery in U S Territories and elsewhere. It would impose the death penalty for robbers who kill or cause a fatal hold up with an oath of any rider. If no death results, the penalty is hard labor twenty to forty years. A companion Senate bill was offered by Mr Hoar.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Washington
Ray
New York
United States
Senate
Hoar
Death of Justice Henry R. Beekman at Home
Justice Henry R. Beekman of the New York Supreme Court died suddenly from an apoplectic stroke at his home on West Seventeenth Street. He left his house at 9:30 AM in apparent good health, returned after a short cab ride, and collapsed on the threshold about 10 o'clock. The incident shocked many prominent New Yorkers as part of a recent wave of losses.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York
Henry R. Beekman
Supreme Court
West Seventeenth St
British Gunboat Arrives as Colombia Raises Armed Force
The gunboat Pheasant reached Colon, Panama, on Saturday while the steamer Taboga is sailed out with another armed Colombian contingent. A disturbance at Chepo is expected to tilt toward a quick victory, as Chepo sits near the isthmus’ narrowest point for traffic with local Indians.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Colon
Galveston
Pheasant
Panama
Taboga
Chepo
Monsignor Keane Named Bishop in Dubuque Diocese
Rome December 17. In a secret Consistory the Pope appointed several bishops including Monsignor Keane formerly rector of the Catholic University at Washington to the Diocese of Dubuque. The Pontiff lamented loss of Papal temporal power while affirming the Holy Year and the inviolable rights of the Papacy amid tensions between Italy and the Church.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Rome
Monsignor Keane
Catholic University At
Washington
Dubuque
Italy
Obituary of Colonel William Dunphy from Peekskill
Dispatch from Denver reports the death of Colonel William Dunphy at the Elk Hotel in Colorado Springs. A Peekskill native, he served in the Confederate Army, later built a liquor business, held local offices, and owned Colorado mining interests. He leaves a widow, two sons, a daughter, and was executor of Charles Butler’s estate.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Denver
Col
Elk Hotel
Colorado Springs
William Dunphy
Peekskill
Dunphy
Gettysburg
Hquor
Colorado
Benevolent Protective Order of Elks
Charles Butler
Beekman Justice Dies of Sudden Apoplexy
Justice Beekman collapsed in a vestibule and died instantly from apoplexy. Eyewitnesses and Dr. Daniel M. Stimson confirm the sudden death. He was 55, leaves a widow and four children, with funeral plans to be held at Calvary Church and services at the courthouse expected to adjourn.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Justice Beekman
Scott
Beekman
William F
Henry R. Jr
Josephine L
Mary E
Calvary Church
Fourth-ave
Twentieth-st
St. George’s Church
Sixteenth-st
Richard Jones Timpson Dies in Brooklyn at 59
Richard Jones Timpson of Tiffany & Co. Brooklyn dies Saturday aged fifty nine. Born April 1 1841 in Wexford Ireland he came to America in 1863 and joined Tiffany in 1868 remaining thirty two years in the diamond jewelry department. He leaves three daughters and a son. funeral held at home 1% Penn street Brooklyn last evening.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Richard Jones Timpson
Brooklyn
Wexford
Ireland
Tiffany & Co
Timopson
Penn-st
Baron Blantyre Dies, Scotch Peer Charles Stuart
London report says Charles Stuart Baron Blantyre the Scotch Representative Peer from 1880 to 1892 has died. Born in 1818, he served in Parliament and held peerage. The notice notes his death on December 17.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
London
Charles Stuart
Baron Blantyre
General Edward F Bullard Dies at Brooklyn Home
General Edward Fitch Bullard, born February 7, 1821 in Schuylerville, died at his Brooklyn residence 397 Macon Street on Sunday. A lawyer admitted in 1843, he practiced in the U S Supreme Court after 1850 and was a brigadier in the New York militia in 1845. A Democrat early, he helped spark the Republican movement in 1854 and, though offered a brigadier general’s seat in the Civil War, chose pen and platform to aid the Union amid 1863 draft riots.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Edward Fitch Bullard
Macon St
Brooklyn
Schuylerville
Saratoga County
Benjamin Bullard
Watertown
Mass
Bullard
Chesselden Ellis
Waterford
N. Y
John K. Porter
Henry Ward Beecher
American Bar Association
Association
Empire State Society of the Sons of the American Revolution
Union
Sketch of Justice Beekman Life and Career
Justice Beekman, born in 1845 in this city, rose from Columbia College to a long law career and 1896 Supreme Court tenure. He served as Park Commissioner, Alderman President, and Union-backed judge, with peers praising his real estate expertise, conscientious work ethic, and civic contributions including courthouse reforms. Two foreclosure suits filed as he died, involving property tied to his will and later noted predecessor Justice Smyth.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Justice Beekman
Columbia College
Grace
Department of Parks
Board of Aldermen
Hewitt
Grant
Hill
United States
Beekman
Superior Court of
City of New York
Union
Mayor Strong
Supreme Court
William N. Cohen
Baramet
St. Nicholas Society
University Club
Justice O'Gorman
Charles H. Neilson
Hannah M. Halpin
Philbin, Beekman & Menken
Frederick Smyt
Halpin
Smyth
Death of long-time West Unitarian pastor Cyrus Bartol
In Boston on December 17 the Rev Dr Cyrus Augustus Bartol died after a two week illness from bronchitis. He served nearly twenty three years as pastor of the West Unitarian Church and was a former assistant to Rev Dr Charles Lowell. Bartol was eighty seven, Bowdoin and Harvard Divinity School graduate, ordained 1837, led as pastor after 1881, and earned Harvard’s Doctor of Divinity in 1859. He was a prolific writer of sermons and essays.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Boston
Cyrus Augustus Bartol
West Unitarian Church
Charles Lowell
Bartel
Bowdoin College
Harvard Divinity School
West Church
Lowell
Harvard University
Pr. Bartel
Samuel Burrell Hard Dies At Fazlewood New Jersey
Samuel Burrell Hard died Saturday at his home in Fazlewood New Jersey. Born in Albion New York in 1838 he graduated from Union College at seventeen. He taught Greek read law with his father and practiced in Buffalo where Millard Fillmore Solomon Haven and Aaron H Patchin aided his career. In 1860s he moved to New York organized the Open Board of Brokers and the Mining Board serving as first president of both and helped draft the Constitution of the Consolidated Exchange.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Samuel Burrell Hard
Fazlewood
N. J
Albion
N. Y
Union College
Buffalo
Millard Fillmore
Solomon Haven
Aaron H. Patchin
Hard
New York
Open Board of Brokers
Mining Board
Consolidated Exchange
Reverend Barrows Dies in Orange New Jersey Home
The Rev Charles D Barrows a Presbyterian minister died suddenly at the home of Fred Cook in Orange New Jersey on Saturday morning He was born in Clinton New Jersey May 6 1848 and graduated Hamilton College in 1869 He also earned a degree from Columbia Law School before practicing law then entering the ministry He served in James town and Oswego New York later turning to teaching and tutoring in the Orange area He leaves a widow and one son.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Charles D. Barrows
Presbyterian Church
Fred Cook
Orange
N. J
Mr. Barrows
Clinton
Hamilton College
Law School of Columbia
Jamestown
Oswego
N. Y
Wren
To Retire Generals Wilson and Lee
Senator Daniel of Virginia introduced a bill to permit the President to select two brigadier-generals from volunteers to be made brigadier-generals in the Regular Army and placed on the retired list. The measure targets Generals James H. Wilson and Fitzhugh Lee.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Washington
Daniel
Virginia
Day
James H. Wilson
Fitzhugh Lee
Queen Helena to Become a Mother
Rome reports the King of Italy Victor Emmanuel told Premier Saraco that Queen Helena will become a mother about six months hence. The couple wed in October 18 and have no children. The prince ascended after Humbert’s death when Bresci assassinated the king at Monza near Milan.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Helena
Rome
Italy
Victor Emmanuel
Signor Saraco
Savoy
Naples
Montenegro
Solr
Humbert
Bresci
Monga
Milan
Browned Legs of Colorado Ex-Lt Governor Nichols Dies at Home
Boulder Colorado dated December 17 reports the death at his home near Boulder of David H Nichols former Lieutenant Governor of Colorado 1893 to 1895 born 1826 in Hardwick Vermont Mexican War veteran who settled in Colorado in 1859 also noted death of Henry Vaughan Upham aged 53 Boston lumber tradesman longtime manager for John W Leatherbee and Captain T L Churchill insurance figure surveyor for New England Bureau of United Inspection both deceased in Boston with brief biographical notes
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Boulder
Col
David H. Nichols
Colorado
Hardwick
Boston
Henry Vaughan Upham
John W. Leatherbee
Upham
T. L. Churchill
New England Bureau of United Inspection
Senate backs Africa liquor control convention
Washington December 17 Senate in executive session agreed to back a convention regulating the transportation of intoxicating liquors into designated regions of Africa.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Washington
Senate
Africa
Dowie Sued by a Clergyman in London Court
London reports the Rev. William De Ronden Pas has filed a lawsuit against Jebu Alexander, alleging grounds for legal action. The clergy figure seeks redress in connection with alleged conduct or statements. Further details in forthcoming court disclosures.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
London
William de Ronden Pas
Jebu Alexander
NY Electors Summoned to Cast State's Electoral Vote
Secretary of State John T. McDonough notified New York’s presidential electors to assemble at the Albany Capitol on January 14 at noon to cast the state's electoral vote. Any elector who neglects to act forfeits the seat, allowing the remaining electors to appoint a substitute.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York
John T. McDonough
Albany
Also Mentioned on This Page
Appellant
Mr. Perkins
Perkins
New Territories
Harlan
Fuller
de Lima
Carlisle
Dooley, Smith & Co
St. Paul
Minneapolis
Des Moines
St. Co
Kansas City
Brossway
H. Lord
Chicago Great Western Railway
Boutelle
England
Indorsing Notes
Hopkins
Committee ON Census
STY
Tribune
House of Representatives
Select Committee On
Representative Babcock
Representative Burleigh
Nebraska
Pennsylvania
Minnesota
New Jersey
Arkansas
California
Connecticut
Florida
Louisiana
Massachusetts
Mississippi
Missouri
North Carolina
North Dakota
Wisconsin
Ill
Babcock
Wis
Acheson
Penn
Brownlow
Tenn
Indiana
Kansas
MR. Chandler
H.R. Beekman
Henry BR. Beekman
The
Cyrus A Bartol
Wilson
Lee
Assor
Wweth Jackson
Union Square
17Th Street
Best &Co
Tian BA
Cartwright & Warners
West
STECK
East
Bartens & Rice Co
5Th Avenue
Waldorf-Astoria
Musical Publications
Musical Instruments
Charles H. Ditson & CO
15Th St
Dowie
Pos
Wie