Readers Respond On Philippine War Coverage And Economic Cycles
Letters critique The Times for sensational Philippine reporting and call for accountability in editorials. A Jersey City reader questions trust and a New York correspondent discusses trade cycles and Tariff politics, urging caution about economic prophecy and public rhetoric.
Editorial calls Gen Smith actions in Samar war crimes
The Times urges that Gen Jacob H. Smith be dismissed for ordering Samar to be made a wilderness and for including boys as young as ten in a brutal plan to kill natives. The piece portrays the orders as bloody beyond belief and unsupported by civilized beliefs, predicting a court martial termination of Smith's career.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Times
Jacob H. Smith
In Defense of a Cartoon Letter Responds to Times Criticism
Ida Clendenin of Brooklyn argues that Times indignation over a Hvening Journal cartoon should target the army order behind it rather than the cartoon. She contends General Smith's order would permit crimes like those depicted in the Philippines and urges scrutiny of authority.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Times
Davenport
Hvening Journal
Journa
Philippines
A Poughkeepsie View Letter to the Editor
N T Kennedy of Poughkeepsie writes angrily in May 1902 replying to a Topics of the Times column. He denounces any claim that no dozen men would kill in war, calling a hired killer a cheap assassin who takes $13 per month to shoot fellow men. The letter criticizes the editor’s stance and urges readers to see soldiers as willing killers.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Jacob Smith
Fix
Evening Journal
the Times
Philippine Islands
E. P. Buffet, Jr
Jersey City
Poughkeepsie
Times
N. T. Kennedy
Dogs as friends curb night barking in urban homes
A Brooklyn reader argues that well treated dogs sleep quietly at night and even whisper bark when needed. He urges neighbors to treat dogs as companions and keep them indoors or in kennels to reduce disturbances.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Sunday Times
Brooklyn
Cowbell Noise In Brooklyn Stir at Dawn
A New York letter from Thompson dated May 7 1902 complains about junk carts in Brooklyn and New York making loud cowbell sounds at 7 30 in the morning. He questions why bells are allowed and cites disturbing noise to invalids and nervous residents.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
New York
Brooklyn
Tuemee
Thompson
Cycles of Trade Revolutions Letter to the Editor
A reader contrasts extreme protectionist views with a Democrat's steady stance on financial disturbances. The letter references “A. B. J.” in the Times of May 4 and cites the 1873 to 1878 hard times period as a historical example.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Neo York Times
Times
Dr Strong and the Turks address critique and defense
Franklin Quinby argues against a misrepresented editorial on Americas Influence in the East. He cites Josiah Strong defending Robert College and missionary rights, notes Turkish repression, and contends imperialism linked to Philippine war policy. He questions Root and Lodge and asserts ultimate statehood or empire for the Philippines.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
America
East
Constantinople
Empire
Robert College
Yale
Princeton
Amherst
Oberlin
Haifa
Damascus
Turkey
Josiah Strong
New York
A Reply to Senator Lodge on Philippine War Acts
Findlay Sackett argues that Senator Lodge’s praise of American soldiers in the Philippines excuses acts of savagery. The piece condemns the idea that restraint by civilized soldiers justifies cruelty and calls for accountability despite the war’s hardships.
War crimes in the Philippines attack on civilians
The writer denounces actions by troops described as cruelty and torture supported by officers and says such orders to kill civilians show a collapse of civilization and condemn brutal conduct by those in command. He mocks the ethic of the army and criticizes the use of forged hospitality with the enemy.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Smith
TIMES
Sing Sing
Critique of a Cartoon on Filipino War and Race
Henry C. Carter argues the cartoon misrepresents murder of Filipino children yet reflects prevailing anger toward Filipinos. He notes past brutalities by various armies and questions racial expansion, urging white dominance and exclusion of brown, black, and yellow peoples.
Conduct of Our Soldiers in Philippine War Hailed and Questioned
Letter from E Steward of New Brunswick May 7 1902 questions Filipino cruelty claims. It recalls similar acts by US troops a year earlier and asks which side is more justifiable. The writer urges pride in defenders but condemns abuses toward weaker peoples and warns imperialists to imagine Filipino suffering.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Lodge
China
Weyler
E. Steward
New Brunswick
Pupin Critique of U S Telegraph Conservatism
Romyn Hitchcock responds to Prof. Pupin on the slow progress of American telegraph service under private management. He cites British and continental systems adopting the Stearns duplex Edison quadruplex Delany multiplex Rowland multiplex and Mercadier multiplex while Western Union offers no notable innovations. He calls the critique charitable yet pointed.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Pupin
Times
Telegraph
William Preece
England
Edison
Rowland
Germany
Mercardier
Rance
Western Union Company
Romyn Hitchcock
New York
Trusts and the earning power of steam and machinery
A letter recalls Mr. Thurber defending trusts by their earning power based on steam electricity and machinery. The writer argues natural powers cannot be owned and warns against monopolies buying exclusive use, noting high interest and questioning whether trusts have done good for the world.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Thurber
Mark
The Threat of Industry Monopolies and Public Justice
I Scanlon of Newark argues that beef and other industries gain from demand while monopolies restrict supply to raise prices. He warns that economic despots replace political tyrants as public safeguards erode, with industry leaders dubbed Captains of industry and Kings of finance.
Army of Creation Suggested to National Defense
In Archibald Y. Comstock's May 4 letter the idea of a drilled militia as an army of creation is urged. He envisions a large standing force used for public works such as building waterways and forests, securing land, and boosting national wealth while defending the republic.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Archibald Y. Com- Steck
Republic
Rock of Gibraltar
Great Lakes
Mississippi
Hudson
Great Northwest
Lax Local Express Service Criticized by New Yorker
A New York reader laments the citys local express service after luggage delays from New London to West Medford and Harlem deliveries. He cites promises broken by uniformed agents, wins no quick remedy, and urges ongoing public ventilation of the issue to improve management and reliability. The letter is signed G H B.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
New York City
New London
Boston
South Union Station
West Medford
New York
Fall River
Express
West One Hundred and Fifty-second Street
Express Company
Harlem
New Yorker
G. H
Hard Times and Currency Standards Debate Referenced
The article quotes critics A. B. J. and Democrat disputing conclusions about blood impurity and sickness as consequences, links sound currency to business success, and cites the 1890 Congress bargain over tariffs and the McKinley tariff and Sherman Silver Purchase Act, reflecting Republican platform concerns.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Democrat
High Tariff
Tariffs, trusts and the Sherman act cited in 1902 claim
The article argues that high tariffs under McKinley and Dingley fostered trusts and that the Sherman act damaged business like tearing a building apart. It notes repeal during Cleveland administration as a step toward prosperity, with a Philadelphia dateline of May 6, 1902.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Rison
McKinley
Dingley
Cleveland
Philadelphia
Art Education Abroad versus Home Training argues for native cultivation
John Ward Stimpson argues young artists should study at home, not abroad, to avoid superficial mimicry and exploitation. He cites Japan as a model of inward development, urges national art principles built from within, and calls for guardians of native genius over elite private galleries.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Beaux Arts
New York City
Metropolitan Museum
Artist-Artisan Institute
Greece
Rome
Italy
Paris
Hokusai
Michael Angelo
Raphael
John Ward Stimson
Trenton
N. J
Plea for Clean Streets in New York and New England
A writer urges practical street cleaning, blaming ignorance and prejudice for grime. She cites need for a broom and will, rejects political excuses, and argues cleanliness reflects civic virtue.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
New York
New England
Democratic Party
Boston
Bishop Potter’s Work and Coadjutor Need in New York
Wharton Dickinson of New York urges the Dio cesan Council to consider selecting a Bishop Coadjutor for Bishop Potter. He argues the present Diocesan burdens are too heavy for one man and praises Potter’s wise policy and public service. May 8, 1902.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Diocesan Council of
New York
Provoost
Moore
Hobart
Wainwright
Potter
Fotter
Wharton Dickinson
Old Hall of Records debated for museum use in New York
Oscar Epstein of New York reports on the City Board of Aldermen approving a plan to lease the old Hall of Records for the National Historical Museum. He suggests moving the building to Fort Greene as a Wallabout memorial, with removal costs estimated at fifty thousand dollars. He recounts Austrian tariff and trade views and notes railway guards in Vienna.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Nett York Times
Board of Aldermen
City of
New York
Alderman Bridges
Clancy
Coombes
Clayton
Amos J. Cummings
Fort Greene
Old Hall of Records
Jersey
Congress
Veteran
The Ford Tragedy and Calls for Mental Health Intervention
A commentary on the Ford tragedy notes how failing to treat an increasingly disturbed family member can lead to violence. It urges prompt care for mental illness, arguing that delaying confinement due to prejudice endangers the afflicted and others. Authorities caution against assuming absence of danger without treatment.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Malcomb W. Ford
Brooklyn
Austrian Fear of America and Austrian Debates
The writer critiques Austrian efforts to boycott the United States led by Count Jabouchowski and Herr Kolischer. It argues that Jabouchowski is more a courtier than a patriot and that Kolischer, a Reichstag member and large manufacturer, overstates threats against America. The piece dismisses the notion of a coordinated European anti American campaign as overstated and oversimplified.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Austria
America
Germany
Rhine
Vienna
Arn
Jabouchowski
Herr Kolischer
Terr Kolischer
Herr Wolischer
Reichstag
Brody
Russia
Kelischer
Oscar Epstein
New York
New York Times
Count Jabouchowski
Beaureaucrat
Pesners
The Stage Irishman A critique from 1902
A letter to the New York Times traces the stage Irishman from brutal wild caricature on British stages to a more nuanced American portrayal. The writer condemns British depictions as degrading stereotypes and urges faithful, nature-mirroring performance, while noting lingering misperceptions among audiences.
Princeton Theological Graduation Note Clarifies Color Denotation
A reader from Jersey City objects to a report on Princeton Theological Seminary graduation. The class of 1896 included three members of color and a correction on degree naming clarifies that Doctor of Divinity is not awarded in course. Bachelor of Divinity is the highest degree in the 96 class era.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Princeton
New York Times
Princeton Theological Seminary
George S. Stark
A. Brown
C of
Jersey City
N. J
Also Mentioned on This Page
Benner
A. H
DR. Strong and the Turks
Republican Party
Root
Senator Lodge
Nero
Franklyn Quinby
Massachusetts
Cradle of Liberty
Lamar
Waller
Carlyle
Prate
Findlay Sackett
Wounded Knee
St. Louis
Santo Domingo
Java
Australia
Dogberry
Hawaiian
Henry C. Carter
the Telegraph and Progress
A Comstock
LAX
L. B. Starr
Bishop Potter
Ben Jonson
Shakespeare
Borneo
Knave
Ireland
Pat
Green Isle
Tirishman