Readers debate meaning of exceptions prove the rule
A letter from Harold Korn questions the New York Times review of the saying Exceptions prove the rule. He cites dictionaries and Latin etymology to argue that prove means to test and that exceptions merely test a rule, not prove it, noting illogical or nonsensical implications.
The exception proves the rule Latin debate
The letter argues that the maxim exception proves the rule is medieval academic Latin. It cites E D Bewley and traditional readings, noting probare means to prove in medieval usage and cites Benvenuto da Imola as illustrating a non classical sense. The writer suggests caution in applying the phrase to classical Latin. W. & New York, March 12.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times Saturday Review of Books
E. D. Bewley
Thomas de Quincey
Benvenuto da Imola
University of Bologna
New York
Mrs Dodd's Novel Attracts Greek Life And Love
A reader defends Anna Bowman Dodd's On the Knees of the Gods against The Saturday Review verdict, praising its vivid narrative, romantic love story, and picturesque Athenian setting. The reviewer notes fresh passion in love passages and attention to Greek art, literature, and landscape.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times Saturday Review of Books
Saturday Review OF Books
Anna Bowman Dodd
Pompeii
Spero a Vermont word of playful origin explored
Henry Baldwin notes a Vermont regional term spero meaning a light lark or prank. He traces usage from Charlotte to Bristol and Manchester and asks if spero derives from English, Indian, or a Connecticut settler influence, suggesting possible links to Michigan colonies.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times Saturday Review
Charlotte
Bartlett
Spero
Peck
Columbia
New “ International
Roland H. Robinson
Vermont
Lisha
Bristol
Charles Orvis
Manchester
Connecticut
Michigan
Moonbeam Wish Book Promotes Moon Based Wishes
The Moonbeam Wish Book gathers superstitions tied to the moon. It invites readers to host friends, record their names in dedicated spaces, and believes wishes made at the new moon have higher chances of fulfillment.
Around the World With a Humorist by George L Carlisle
A New York lawyer quit the practice to travel and write About a yearlong journey Carlisle offers impressions in short stories rather than a guidebook He mixes humor with sharp observations of Greece Carlsbad Captain Cook Sandwich Islands Java Athens India Japan and the Philippines while critiquing colonial rulers and social norms The book is witty insightful and largely worthwhile despite some biased views
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
George L. Carlisle
New York
Robert Grier Cooke
Carlisle
Greece
Carlsbad
Capt. Cook
Sandwich Islands
Mr.Carlisle
Java
Athens
India
Hawaii
Japan
Disputed Poem Authorship and Noted Misattributions
A letter from R L C White in Nashville argues that many poems are misattributed due to cheap collections and urges reliance on reputable anthologies like Stedman, Archer, Bullen, Ward, Miles, and Rossiter Johnson for accuracy. He cites Emily Rebecca Page as the true author of The Old Canoe and critiques publishers promoting fake attributions.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times Saturday Review of Books
Potomac
McCreery
Bulwer
Homer Greene
Horace Greeley
Miss Gould
George D. Prentice
Prentice
Adela F. Smith
Albert Pike
Gen. Pike
Emily Rebecca Page
Vermont
Appleton
Rossiter Johnson
Stedman
Archer
Bullen
Ward
Miles
R. L. C. White
Nashville, Tenn
Somehow Good and In Memoriam Echoes in Letters
A facetious correspondent asks the meaning of Mr. De Morgan's novel title Somehow Good and notes many letters responding, signaling wide public familiarity with In Memoriam. The column comments on the cultural reach of the titles and reader receptiveness. The piece observes the exchange as a light literary note.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Mr. de Morgan
A Book for the Superstitious Is Published
The Frederick A. Stokes Company announced yesterday the release of A Book for the Superstitious. The publishers indicated the work compiles superstitions with commentary and historical context aimed at curious readers and skeptics alike.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Frederick A. Stokes Company
Publica
Modernist Movement Documents Translated For Publication
A March 1908 report notes that a translation of the Church’s modernism documents, the 1907 Syllabus and the Encyclical Letter, will be published next month by G. P. Putnam’s Sons. It mentions the Programme of Modernism pamphlet by expelled priests and the lack of English versions to date.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Congregation of the Holy Office
G. P. Putnam's Sons
None So Pretty A Story of Emotions
A Cumberland set romance from Green & Co. follows a country artist with London ambitions. The plot nests love triangles, old sweethearts, a baroness, a baronet, and a clergyman who tries to avert catastrophe while juggling hidden relationships.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Ngmans, Green & Co
Cumberland
London
Evolution of Rose mixed genre critic review
The hybrid volume The Evolution of Rose by Richard Badger defies easy classification as story journal treatise or aphorism collection. The clouded plot lacks vivid narration and the journal lacks clear individuality while the aphorisms feel inert and distant.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Rose
Richard Badger
Miss Snow
Storry
Jooes
Also Mentioned on This Page
New York’ Times
Bewley
David
Skeat
Probat
Goliath
Leverett
Anthonies
Boston
New York Times
Bohn
London Spectator
George Pierce Laker of
Marvard
Harold Korn
Columbia University
Sherwood
N. Y
Maiden Lane
John
America
Anne Douglas Seedgwick
the Century CO
Roy Norton
Shakespeare Library
L Goi
Duff DE E
Booklovers Library
East 23d St
Francis & Cole CO
East 22d St
D. Torbett
C. H. Doscher 2 Company
Fifth Av
Aaron Martin Crane
Lothrop, Lee & Shepard CO
Davis’ Bookstore
West 42d
Bryant
F. Herbert
Care Mather & Crowther, Ltd
New Bridge Street
Eng