Readers critique on rhyming forms and limericks
A reader letters debate the form and rhyme of limericks versus sonnets, arguing about rhythm, accent, and rhyming rules. The writer cites examples from Browning and Lear and suggests humorous reworkings, noting readers’ dullness and regional voices.
Atherton Interview Sparks Debate Over American Letters
The New York Times Saturday Review of Books recounts Mrs. Atherton’s interview denouncing the Howell Magazine School and praising her own originality. She claims she stands above W. D. Howells and peers, urging readers to recognize her genius and leadership in American letters.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Atherton
New York Times Saturday Review of Books
the Times
America
Howells’s Realism in Sleep and a Forgetting Review
H McChesney of New York comments in the Saturday Review of Books that Mr Howells’s new volume A Sleep and a Forgetting proves his figures are implausible and provincial. The critic notes stilted social scenes and canary birdlike pecking at English, yet admits any Howells work is worth reading for its sake.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York
Tynes
Jiais
Dredd
Edward Lear
New York Times Saturday Review of Books
Strampers
Howells
Mr. Howells
H. McChesney
Untermeyer
J. B. Cowdin
Rhapsody on Truth. How to tell the truth at all times
The piece critiques truth telling in America, contrasting national manners with foreign examples, arguing sincerity clashes with decorum and social form, and laments moral hypocrisy while urging a symbol of protest. L. A. Elder from Merion, Penn., dated Dec 29, signs off.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times Saturday Review of Books
America
Russia
Norway
Bjirnson
England
Felix Holt
Germany
Jean Paul
Leibgeber
Leibgebers
Bishop
Hiere
L. A. Elder
Merion
Penn
The Broken Lance Critique By Mr Ilerbert
A review lauds The Broken Lance as a bold artistic attack on the Church and urges reading by both saints and sinners. It asks whether the novel serves society or unjustly harms the Church and whether the institution can, within itself, reform the depicted evils.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times Saturday Review of Books
Ilerbert. Quick
Quick
Quick’s attack on the institutional Church sparks strong response
In St Paul Minnesota on December 29 J Miller argues that Mr Quick has out-Zolned Zola by attacking the institutional Church. He says the church must respond vigorously if there is any strength in churchianity, warning silence would signify weakness.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Zola
Quick
J. Miller
St. Paul,Minn
Encouragement for Poets and Literary Values
Virginia Ayvad from New York argues for stronger appreciation of poetry amid commercialism. She praises Daniel Hugh Verder’s The Snow Bride and Other Poems as a reminder of higher ideals and urges readers to support earnest verse to uplift society.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Virginia Ayvad
New York
La Rochefoucauld and Byron Compared in Review
A New York letter to NU K argues that the review of Saturday December 21 misnames the seventeenth century author as a new La Rochefoucauld. It contrasts pessimistic self love with optimistic faith in innate good, urging the review to clarify the minds of readers with balanced critique.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
la Rochefoucauld
Henry Byron
New York Times
Saturday Review of Books
New York
Objection to New Overhaul of Mother Goose by Margherita Hamm
A reader objects to Margherita Hamm translating and shaping Mother Goose, arguing the collection belongs to Elizabeth Goose and colonial origins. The letter cites Hamm’s prior folklore work and asserts it is sacrilege to imprint political ideas on timeless nursery verses.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Mother Goose
New York Times Saturday Review of Books
Elizabeth Goose
Shakespeare
Himm
Astor
Colonies
Mother Goose socializing protest sparks Brooklyn appeal
A letter from Fanny Blyd Buller in Brooklyn urges mothers and all people to protest what she calls the socializing of Mother Goose. The note dated December 24 at St George, Clark Street, reflects a campaign sentiment on children and culture.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Mother Goose
Fanny Blyd Buller
The
St. George
Clark Street
Brooklyn
Hawthorne and the Intangible Life in Hawthorne’s Legend
Benjamin Di Casseres argues in the New York Times Saturday Review that Hawthorne embodies the Intangible Life, a meditative existence amid a haunted world. He contrasts Hawthorne and Poe with modern life, praising Hawthorne’s remote consciousness and enduring memory of a golden moment.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Hawthorne
New York Times Saturday Review of Books
THE
New York Times
Saturday Review OF Books
Brownell
Nathaniel Hawthorne
Amiel
Maurice de Guérin
Maurice Maeterlinck
Arcturus
Aldebatian
Prospero
Elsinore
Mr. Brownell
Poe
Earth
Centaurs
House of Revels
Benjamin DI Casseres
New York
A Hawthorne Admirer tribute in New York Times
A reader from New England, an American loyalist to Hawthorne, thanks the Saturday Review of Books for a splendid tribute to Hawthorne in today’s literary section. Philadelphia letter writer signs off with holiday season date.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Hawthorne
New York Times Saturday Review of Books
Salem Custom House
Tinks
Philavtephia
Dec
Mr Gilders Poetry Critique in Data Review
Florence Wilkinson mockingly reviews Richard Watson Gilders poems in the Data Review. Fritz L Schmidt Jr of New York cites Coleridge to argue literature demands talent, contrasting genuine genius with routine verse.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Florence Wilkinson
Richard Watson Gilder
Your Data Review
Coleridge
Biographia Literaria
Fritz L. Schmidt, Jr
New York
In Londons Mire Adam's Clay By Cosmo Hamilton
A brisk sensational portrait of a vampiric circle surrounding a wife and her lover aligned with London moral decay. The husband narrator tells the tale to his son as the old scandal erupts, with Betty Blundell as a central figure amid violent emotional twists.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Cosmo Hamilton
New York
Brentano & Co
Kipling
London
Ashley
Findig
Betty Blundells
Bety
Also Mentioned on This Page
Gertrude Atherton
W. D. Howells
Flussie Rog
Arizona
Ross
Mr. K
Pelican
Browning
State of
Louisiana
Pegasus
An. Ohn Ss. Zimmeraman
Chicago
H. A. Lock
Derby, Conn
Realism
Mr. Gilder