Views of Readers in The New York Times Saturday Review
Readers critique the New York Times Saturday Review of Books on impressions of political economy and machinery. A. B. Remick of Pine Hill argues the vocabulary choice matters, noting overuse of "great" in literary critique and urging precision in wording.
Miss Sherman's Course Critiqued by Portland Letter
MOL OB of Portland Maine objects to Miss Ellen Burns attack in Miss Sherman's volume Words to the Wise and Others. The reviewer says the title aims to be clever yet harms the author with scornful prose. The letter concludes clever writing needs discretion to avoid mischief and bad form. February 24 Portland.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Ste
Miss Sherman
Adjectives and Discrimination in Language Usage
A reader comments on the value of careful adjective use in prose and poetry, praising Milton’s distinctive diction and criticizing overworked or glovenly word choices in contemporary writers. The note cites Milton, Blackmore, and others, urging economical yet discriminating adjective use.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times Saturday Review of Books
John Milton
Hiram Carson
Cornell University
R. J. Blackmore
Lorna Doone
Mary Annerley
Kit
Kitty
Hypotheses and Principles in Science and Ethics
A New York Times Saturday review discusses M Poincaré on Science and Hypothesis, questioning if ethical principles are akin to hypotheses guiding conduct. It notes the lack of final objective truth and that hypotheses build on dead ones, balancing moral rules with case applicability. A. C. Pley dell cites the idea from New York, Feb 26.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Saturday Review of Booka
M.poincaré
Poincaré
A. C. Pleydell
New York
Has Trevelyan Made a Mistake in Connecticut Governance
Hartford, Conn. Feb. 26. In a letter from Hartford, readers discuss Trevelyan’s claim about Johnathan Turnbull and Connecticut’s governor. The writer argues Connecticut never submitted to an un-elected governor, never relinquished its charter, and kept local appeals, highlighting colonial tensions with New York Tories.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Trevelyan
New York Times Saturday Review of Books
Johnathan Turnbull
Connecticut
Colony of
Massachusetts
Rhode Island
New York
The Search of Belisarius praised in Review of Books
A reader of Rev. Percy S Grant's poem argues the work stands beside a recently praised author from another land. The message lauds Belisarius as a noble dramatic tale and love story with fire, pathos, singing sweetness, and reverent wonder, drawing comparisons to a celebrated contemporary.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Saturday Review of Books
Percy S. Grant
Last Saturday
Review OF Books
New York
Some- Where Mr De Morgan Got The Title For His Novel
The writer asks where Mr De Morgan sourced the title for his new novel Some. The question hints at a literary reference or classical origin but provides no further context or quotes. No definitive source is cited in the fragment.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Saturday Review of Books
Mr. de Morgan
Quaint Title At Odds With Reader Hopes
The note from New York dated February 26 discusses how a title described as quaintly but not fantastically named may leave readers without clear meaning. The comment points to subjective reception of phrasing and its impact on expectation.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York
Plea to Mr James on Midmarch and Dorothea
Albany letter discusses a literary prize puzzle from an old desk entry, praising the enchantment of mid nineteenth century novels. It mentions George Eliot The American and The Portrait of a Lady, Isabel Archer and Mrs. Touchett, and asks Mr James to reconsider the preface and keep beloved characters intact.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Déménagée
George Eliot
Harper's and Howells
James
Antic Monthly
Father
John
Alice
Jane
Bomola
Daniel Deronda
Roderick Hudson
Silas Lapham
Kealg
Marsh
Tees
Hudson
Touchett
Miss Stackpole
Mr. James
Newman
Albany
Adopters Propose Lewis Carroll Admires Circle Idea
Readers of Carrolls Alice adventures could form a yearly Mad Tea Party circle each March. A Brooklyn notice invites admirers to organize the social gathering to celebrate the author and his whimsical tales.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times Saturday Review of Books
Lewis Carroll
French teachers in America plan a St Regis fête
The Société Nationale des Professeurs Français en Amérique hosts a féte at the Hotel St Regis with speeches and a dance. Admission requires French birth and professed teaching. It lists 250 members led by Prof. Auguste George of Wakefield High School. An auction of donor books funds a pension. Donors include President Roosevelt and Ambassador Jusserand.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Société Nationale Des Professeurs Francais En Amérique
St Regis
United States
France
Auguste George
Waleigh High School
Roosevelt
Jusserand
The Crimes of Ali Pacha and Others by Dumas
A review celebrates Alexandre Dumas and his works in the Celebrated Crimes series. It praises My Memoirs translation by E M Waller, notes its six year span from 1824 to 1830, and highlights anecdotes, poems, and vivid scenes. It mentions two companion volumes with illustrations and introductions by Richard S. Garnett.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
IRS
Alexandre Dumag
B. M
Andrew Lang
New York
Macmillan Mpany
Ali Pacha
Alexandre Dunas
Richard S._ Garnett
Pany
Marquise DE
Ubrinvilliers
Alexandre Dumas
Richard S. Garrett
The
Macmillan Company
du- Tmas
Hfe
E. M. Waller
Dumas
Byron Marie
Alma
Michelet
de Vigny
Barras
Talma
Paris
South
Nisida
Marquise de Brinvilliers
Martin Guerre
Marquise de Ganges
Mary Stuart
Vaninka
Richard S. Garnett
Balzac
Also Mentioned on This Page
Bradford
John B. Clark
John van Vorst
M. R
Philadelphia
Macauley
A. B. Remick
Pine Hill
Portland
Belisarius
Isabel
Dorothea
Brooklyn
United
Atlantic Monthly
Anna A. Rogers
Rogers
Henry H. Clayton
St. Louis
New Jersey
Augustus Saint-Gaudens
Kenyon Cox
Alice Brown
Richard Watson Gilder
Edith Wharton
Irving Babbitt
Edwin D. Mead
Houghton, Mifflin & Co
Park St
Boston