Readers Debate Critics In A frank New York Times exchange
Ellen Burns Sherman defends reviewers who fairly assess other writers while denouncing a few who dodge issues or imitate others. She argues authors have right to critique critics, cites responses to When Steel Strikes Punk, and praises most reviewers for fairness while condemning a few with weak conscience.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Mmy
Bernard Shaw
Tima
Mark Twain
Hawthorne
Henry James
Kingdom of Heaven
Ellen. Burns Sherman
Boston
Poe letter thanks William Poe for $50 aid to Mrs Clemm
Richmond April 12 16 Edgar A Poe writes gratitude for $50 to Mrs Clemm and notes hopes for Augusta visit. He mentions sending funds to Washington Poe Macon and subscribership to the Messenger. Maria Clemm echoes thanks and asks Poe to convey regards.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Richmond
Clemm
Washington Poe
Macon
Augusta
Virginia
Maria Clenmmm
Meredith the Poet in New York Times Review of Books
A Saturday Books review discusses Meredith the poet beside the novelist and Arnold, noting scarce poetic mentions last week. It praises his vigorous earthiness and intellectual ardor, arguing his blend of life love and order reveals a strong lyric force beneath obscurity.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times Saturday Review of Books
New York Times
Meredith
Arnold
Whitman
Poetical Power in Language and Legacy
Alice Van Vliet of Brooklyn argues that even if the world of George Meredith’s novels were lost, poems like The Daughter of Hades and The Thrush in February would still show the lasting power of a great poet. She contemplates the value of a Birthday Number in recognizing literary achievement.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Browning
George Meredith
Alice van Vliet
Brooklyn
N. Y
February 10 Letter Praises Review of Books and Reader Delight
Ninian Beall Remick from Rose Mountain farm Ulster County New Jersey expresses thanks and compliments to the editor for the February issue praising the Review of Books. He quotes Ellen Burns Sherman on varied themes preventing reader boredom and endorses the publication’s rich selections and thoughtful commentary.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times Saturday Review of Books
Saterpay Review of Books
Ellen Burns Sherman
Ninian Beall Remick
Rose Mountain Farm
Ulster County
N. J
George Borrow Style Noted in Reader Letter
A letter from A.R. in New York discusses George Borrow and his writings. The writer compares Borrow to Defoe and De Quincy noting the philologist’s style and wanderings while contrasting poetic depth. Dated February 10.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times Saturday Review of Books
E D. Wynne
George Borrow
de Yoe
de Quincy
A.R
New York
The Cry of the Children Review Note
A reader cites Mrs Van Vorst book The Cry of the Children revealing child labor in cotton mills with children aged four to six working all night. The writer laments the disparity between costly abolition of slavery and suffering of child workers. Brooklyn, February 12.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Brooklyn
Lesson in Heraldry and Bar Sinister Comment
Readers debate heraldry terms after an article on William de Moorgon titled Somehow Good. A correspondent cites bar sinister as an illegitimacy sign and urges consulting an English dictionary. Saratoga Springs, February.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times Saturday Review of Books
Wiliam de Moergan
Eaton
P. Hopkins
Saratoga Springs
Kent described in Jerrold volume of Highways and Byways series
Walter Jerrold’s Kent volume in Macmillan’s Highways and Byways series blends brisk text with detailed black and white illustrations by Hugh Thompson. The author celebrates people, places, and historic lore across Kent with lively prose and vivid scene suggestion akin to Pennell, enriching any southeast England visit.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Macmillan & Co
County of
Kent
Walter Jerrold
Hugh Thompson
Jerrold
England
Joseph Pennell
Study of the Crusades in the East overview
A. Study of the Crusades reviews a new history titled The Crusaders in the East, covering the twelfth and thirteenth centuries in Syria. Published in New York by Putnam and London by Cambridge University Press at $22. Stevenson argues the book emphasizes the eastern perspective and cites its justification for a fresh Crusades study.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
East
Syria
New York
G. P. Putnam's Sona
London
Cambridge University Press
W. 5B
Stevenson
Chronology of the Crusades through Muslim States
A reviewer notes Stevenson's work frames Crusades history as a chronicle of Muslim realms. The volume centers on political relations among Crusader states and their Muslim neighbors, with emphasis on Muslim perspectives and Arabic-sourced corrections of dates.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Stevenson
Nicolete Without Aucassin A Novel by Evelyn Sharp
A BrentaNo edition review praises Nicolete Damer as a wholesome youth growing to marriage. Austen Damer is an eccentric but loving painter father. the family names echo literary figures. Nicolete is portrayed with sweetness and honesty, not precocity, and London society scenes are skillfully depicted. The work is considered deserving of a second reading.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Nicolete Damer
Wicolete
Austen Damér
Tiome
Aucassin
Nicolete
Arthur
Geoffrey
Sandra
Siegfried
Malory
Gawain
London
Reeding
Jefferson Davis biography praised for insight and balance
Prof Dodd's American Crisis Biographies volume on Jefferson Davis receives high praise for its thorough life study and balanced perspective. The biography is described as a scholarly, engaging work that aids understanding of the South and national spirit, published by George W. Jacobs & Co in Philadelphia.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Jefferson Davis
William E. Dodd
South
Dodd
George W. Jacobs & Co
Philadelphia
The Black Bag by Louis Joseph Vance in London
A fast paced adventure tale follows an American hero stranded in London after a San Francisco disaster. The story moves from West End to slums, sea, and the Continent with a daring hero, a genuine villain, and an adventurous heroine, ending in an unexpected climax.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Louis Joseph Vance
London
San Francisco
West End
Hmit
Also Mentioned on This Page
Poe
Stra Clemm
George Dunlop
Standard
Kilmarnock
N.B
Meredith the Poet
County
Evelyn Sharp
Brentano’s
Prof
Dodd’s
Vance