Letters From Readers on Timely Copies
A reader letter from Workingman of Brooklyn argues religious duty and social justice Juxtaposing Catholic and Protestant views with a call for working people to engage with church and politics. The author critiques modern churchianity while praising figures like Muhlenberg Brooks and McGlynn, and condemns executive overreach and Senate resistance to executive-dominated diplomacy.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Cutter
Cutting
Dr. Cuyter
Muhlenberg
St. Luke’s Hospital
Diew
Morndangside Heights
St. Lukes
Main
Phillips Brooks
Edward McGlynn
The
Peoples Tribune
Workingman
Herkimer Street
Brooklyn
N. Y
Dee
Canal Treaty editorial debate on powers of the U S government
A letter to the editor questions the New York Times editorial on the Hay Pauncefote amendments and who participates in treaty making. The writer argues the Senate and other agencies share responsibility beyond the executive and warns of wide open canal implications.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Senate
John Hay
Congress
White House
Siuperior
Executive Department
Sglana Ek
New York
New York Times
Inter-Oceanic Canal
Senator Lodge
Mr. Hay
State Department
Nicaragua
Panama
Nicaragua Canal economic viability questioned by reader
The letter argues the Nicaragua Canal would cost over 206 thousand and attract about 140 thousand tons annually, likely failing commercially. It notes Suez as a superior route with coaling stations and argues Panama trade shares would be too small to justify the canal, with multiple transcontinental rail rivals and sailing trade factors.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Nac York Tones
Nicaragua Canal
Bureau of Statistics
Panama
Suez Canal
Calcutta
Hongkong
Melbourne
Yokoshima Soc
British Isles
Suez
Chile
Pacific
Colono
Nicaragua
Armstrong
New York
Yuletide Observances and a Cat Swapping Tale
The letter discusses Christmas Catholic worship and New Year reflections, praising midnight Mass and the Adeste. It contrasts sacred observance with secular public celebration and comments on gift giving and a family tale about swapping cats amid holiday cheer in Roxbury, Massachusetts.
Christmas Church Music In New York Churches Praised
A letter to the editor argues that in Christmastide worship, St Francis Xavier and St Bernard's offer superior sacred music to St Patrick's and Trinity. It praises the organs and choirs, notably Dr James Peck at St Bernard's, for performances of Catholic mass by Gounod and other contrapuntal works.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
St. Patrick's Cathedral
Trinity Church
St. Francis Xavier
West Sixteenth Street
St. Bernard's
Eighth and
Ninth Avenues
West Fourteenth Street
la Capella
Europe
St. Bernard’s
James Peck
Gounod Masses Praised in Jersey City Churches
In Jersey City on Christmas Day 1900 the Mass Solennette of Gounod at St Francis Xavier was directed by Mr. Dethis, pupil of Guilmant. At St Bernard’s a complete Mass of the Sacred Heart, likely first in the country, was performed by the church choir, which showed fine tone color and religious drama. VERITAS notes the performances deserve public approval.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Gounod
Dethis
M. Guilmant
St. Francis Xavier's
St. .Bernard’s
League of the Sacred Heart of Jesus
St. Bernard’s Church
New York Times
Veritas
Christmas Eve Dolly Stocking Surprise
Mrs. John Goodwin recalls a Christmas Eve memory from 1900 in which her five year old Myrtle hung a stocking for a doll, worried Santa would not come, and awoke to find a penny and candy inside the next morning. The tale ends with a warm parental reflection.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Myrtle
Dolly
Santa Claus
John Goodwin
West One Hundred and Thirty-ninth Street
New York
The Times on Public Schools And City Budget
The Times rebukes repeal of the Davis law cited by the Charter Revision Commission and praises teachers for advocating practical schooling policy. It notes public misrepresentation of the law and criticizes city extravagance including public baths as driving the nine eighty million dollar budget pressures and scapegoating Davis law.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
the Times
Charter Revision Commission
The Davis Law and School Salaries Debate
George H. Chatfield argues in New York on December 27, 1900 that the Davis law has cost too little or too much, contending teachers are not overpaid and stressing the need for fair salaries to attract capable educators. He compares teacher pay with private sector wages and warns that funding cuts will harm education and tenure.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Third Ward Property Owners’ Association
Davis
Board of Estimate
Board of Education
Society For the
George H. Chatfield
New York
A Plea for Democratic Leadership in 1900 Politics
The writer argues that the National Democracy’s plight stems from lax organization and weak leadership during Cleveland’s second administration. He warns that without a decisive leader who can unite the rank and file, the party risks dissolution and the rank and file face an uncertain political future.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Cleveland
Mr. Bryan
Bryant
Cleveland Democrats
Santa Claus
Diogenes
Moses
Cromwell
Napoleon
Washington
New York
Be wary of Beveridge and Bryan style claims in 1900
A reader caricatures Senator Beveridge and William Jennings Bryan, noting similar rhetoric and superficial arguments. The piece questions political sophistry, cites their backgrounds from Western colleges, and mocks grandiose plans such as canal projects and annexation schemes. A December 23, 1900 Dateline from Diogenes.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Bryan
Beveridge
United States
New England Society
Gulf of Mexico
Pacific Ocean
Gulf Stream
Central America
Mexico
Canada
England
New York
Diogenes
Editorial questions on party formation and primaries
The reader asks about fear of wasting votes hindering new party growth and prolonging old parties. They compare the two party primaries to a public preliminary election and question outcomes if the two organizations had been...
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Principles of true Democracy and party campaigns
J. Dir L. Ver Planck of Fishkill on December 26, 1900, argues that fear of losing votes keeps old issues alive as tools in preliminary elections and questions where true democratic principles reside and how often parties have pursued them as their chief aim.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Dir L. Ver Planck
Fishkill-on-Hudson
N. Y
Fixing the Responsibility and the Van Wyck Record
A reader rebuts a prior editorial arguing New York City knew of Robert A. Van Wyck before his mayoralty. The letter recalls his minor court behavior and a notorious arrest for disorderly conduct at a French ball, noting police blotter notoriety and the influence of a powerful boss. The author asserts the public’s past knowledge justified skepticism.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
New York City
Robert A. van Wyck
Tammany
Schmittberger
New York
Gardiner and Wise Removals Critique of Governor Action
Letter writer questions the haste of the Governor in removing Gardiner and Wise, arguing executive power should not be used for emergency measures over minor issues. The piece defends nonpartisan, principle driven appointments and removals, urging restraint and fairness in government.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Wise
Gardiner
EOE
Ice Plant
Ice Trust
Peor
FFP
WSWN
New York
Governor Roosevelt’s Removal Stance Praised by Brooklyn Letter
A Brooklyn reader defends the governor’s authority to remove an accused official after due process. The writer asserts the official’s three-year corrupt conduct and praises Roosevelt for facing malignant forces, urging all good men to support the act. The letter labels prior coverage as unjust and credits the governor with duty done.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Roosevelt
Brooklyn
Cure for tipping evil letter to the editor
A Times letter argues against tipping and proposes a substitute where guests donate tips to a box at hotels and restaurants. Proponents say proprietors would distribute funds to employees, improving civility and efficiency while avoiding personal gifts and biases. Opposition notes practical and public cooperation hurdles.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
LL. W
Tipping Abuses Discussed as Remedy Proposed by Stowell
In Brooklyn on December 27, 1900, Stowell disputes the efficiency of tipping and argues for a method to abolish its abuses by managers of establishments where tipping prevails. The note presents a cautious debate on reform and the feasibility of a standardized system.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Stowell
Brooklyn
Tipping Nuisance Seen As Status Blackmail Across Society
A Montclair, N. J., letter from December 25 1900 argues tipping is a permanent, corrosive habit rooted in class arrogance. The writer calls tipping a sham that enforces a servile view and moral cowardice, noting only a minority can afford it and most resent paying it yet submit to the practice.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Montclair
N. J
Peripatetic Pupil Seeks City Dog Ban
Letter from a New York citizen dated December 2 1900 urging action against dogs in the city. He recalls past bans on roaming livestock and proposes measures to curb sidewalk litter and filth, even suggesting a total ban if feasible.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Times
New York
Readers urge action on dog nuisance and filthy sidewalks
A letter to the editor applauds attention to dog nuisance, cites women leading dogs each morning, and condemns filthy sidewalks as a health and decency issue urging immediate stop to the practice.
Street decency debate over public nuisances in New York
A 1900 New York letter complains that public behavior on streets shows a woman with a dog on a leash inverts decency and health. It calls for enforcement or enactment of laws regulating such conduct and for teaching decency vigorously as a public nuisance. The writer labels some passers as quadrupeds and urges action to curb perceived abuses.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
New York
Lexington Avenue
Forty-third Street
Upper East-Side
Society For the Prevention of Cruelty To Animals
Health Board
TIMES
Police to arrest dog nuisance makers under NYC ordinances
A letter from Tselin New Jersey argues NYC dog nuisance laws justify arrest and fines for owners. The writer calls for 500 men to hire an officer to arrest nuisance dog owners to abate the problem.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Times
New York City
Tselin
N. J
Rat-Infested House Case Defended as Landlord Fault
Howard R. Bayne writes from New York rebutting a newspaper account of the rent suit by Bird M. Robinson as receiver against Richard S. Lee. Bayne argues Lee paid rent after vacating, offered more to settle, and acted on counsel's advice, noting the rodent infestation as a key lease-abandonment issue and asserting the defense was misrepresented.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Bird M. Robinson
Richard S. Lee
Lee
Mr. Lee
Readers praise and critique of American transport service
Letter to the editor discusses editorials on China and the Army Bill and quotes Machinations about transport quality. It cites Millard in Scribner and Whigham correspondence and a Sun letter praising American transport in China. The writer agrees events of recent years reveal that the service is superior in some aspects.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
China
Claude MacDonald
Peking
Sery
Barnacles Suffered By Ice Says Fair Play Editor
In a brief comment from Weemington the piece notes that ice damage has slowed transport but land routes may fare better than suggested by Mr Millard. The author calls for fair play in evaluating the situation and transport prospects.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Weemington
Indorsement of Pure Beer Highlights Public Hygiene
Henry F. Gillig of the Lotos Club, New York, supports Emmet Wells’s plea for pure beer and calls for government regulation of stimulants. He notes European trends toward lighter beers reducing drunkenness, cites experiences in London Paris and Carlsbad, and urges brewers to back laws favoring quality over quantity to protect public health and the industry.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Emmet Wells
London
Strand
Paris
Gare du Nord
Europe
England
Carlsbad
Mr. Wells
Germany
Great Britain
Wells
Uie
Interdiction of Amusements Denounced as Harmful
A letter from New York in December 1900 argues against censoring theatre and reads Shakespeare without moral alarm. It cites Potter and MacArthur defending mirth and leisure, warns that ostracizing performers harms culture, and urges open social contact rather than Pharisaic exclusion.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Bishop Potter
MacArthur
Knickerbocker
New York
Should Jews Form Separate Regiment
A letter from New York dated December 21, 1900, argues against creating a Jew-only military regiment. The writer fears religious segregation would provoke ridicule and hinder unity, urging Jews to prove patriotism by joining existing mixed regiments alongside Catholics and Protestants.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Free America
R. M. de Leeuw
New York
West Point excuses for failures defend hazing denial
A court of inquiry at West Point examines reasons for cadet discharge with claims that mental deficiency or hazing were not factors. The piece cites Breth Booz and others discharged for mathematical deficiency, notes frequent avoidance of admitting mental incapacity, and recounts anecdotes of classmates denying West Point familiarity to dodge interviews. It reflects on lingering excuses and a perceived improvement yet ongoing evasions.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
West Point
Breth
Booz
Military Academy
San Francisco
Wast Point
New York
Also Mentioned on This Page
Pikes
Pnuw Oper Awhite Ds
Organized Wealth
Culiply Hudson Educational Pnstiidtbaisdund
Eniiegos
Psmisse
Thoms
Maniy
Learherts
Bether- Mwaydt
Dee Detten
Bob
Marie
Aic
Christ
Henry
Cynthia
Cinty
Mandy
Roxbury
Mass
Sayine
Scudder Factory
Sartin Thar
Merritt
Merritts
Pete
LDH
DEL
Jersey City
Principles of True Democracy
MR. van Wyck
Gardiner and Wise
L. W
American Transport Service
Henry F. Gillig
Lotos Club