Readers defend Schley and critique Roosevelt in national debate
A letter to the Times argues the Schley controversy remains unsettled, citing court testimony for and against him, praises Dewey and Miles, and warns against political coercion in military matters. The writer appeals to reform, criticizes Roosevelt's handling, and urges justice and independence for officers amid national scrutiny.
Editor laments处理 Schley Sampson controversy results
The writer criticizes the authorities for their handling of the Schley Sampson controversy, stating that both sides have suffered from the mishandling and the public remains misinformed.
Benham and Ramsay Naval Heroes Foreseeable Light on Pioneering Admirals
Readers seek a concise history of Rear Admirals A E K Benham and Francis M Ramsay. The letter outlines Benham’s service from 1847 with the Plymouth and Dolphin, actions at Port Royal, Texas blockade, and Rio de Janeiro mission. Ramsay’s career covers the Civil War battles on the Lower Mississippi, Fort Fisher, Haines Bluff engagement of the Choctaw, and later posts at the Naval Academy and Navy Yard.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
A. E. K. Benham
New York
Plymouth
Dolphin
Macao
China
Port Royal
Penobscot
Texas
Rio de Janeiro
Brazil
Francis M. Ramsay
Washington, D. C
Naval Academy
St. Lawrence
Lower
Mississippi
South Atlantic
Fort Fisher
Haines Bluffs
Liverpool Landing
Milliken’s Bend
Yazoo River
Fort Anderson
Cape Fear River
Richmond
Washington Navy Yard
New York No Yard
Irrigation Bureau
Ventidius Lesson for Schley in 1901 Commentary
J. W. Canfield discusses Shakespearean reflections on Admiral Schley and the drive for glory in war. The piece quotes Ventidius and Silius to argue that officers gain more from serving their captain than by pursuing personal fame, cautioning action that could offend the commander and harm a career. The letter is dated December 26, 1901, from Middletown, N. J.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Ventidius
Silius
Caesar
Antony
Lassius
Syria
Lesghan
Antonius
J. W. Canfield
Middletown
Maclay as scapegoat in naval discipline debate
In a New York letter of December 27 1901 Park Benjamin questions whether Edgar Stanton Maclay was unfairly targeted to satisfy discipline aims. He notes Maclay claims letters from naval officers justified his charges against Admiral Schley and asks if the Navy Department pressed for those letters or offered Maclay a chance to explain before removing him.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Admiral Schley
Santiago
Schley
Cook
Schroeder
Evans
Cotton
Chadwick
Dhirt
Dewey
Congress
Dreyfus
Court of Arbitration
Manila
Guam
Times
Battlle
Sampson
George Dewey
Cienfuegos
Addley
Nelson
Key West
Bern
Decatur
Perry
Farragut
Amer
Evgenf Klapp
United States Volunteer Engineers
New York
Gen
Miles
Maclay
Navy
Bryan
Roosevelt
White House
United States Navy
Theodore Roosevelt
Mr. Roosevelt
Navy Department
Long
Alger
Admiral Sampson
Napoleon
E. W. Benedict
The
Edgar Stanton Maclay
Spain
Park Benjamin
Marine Court
Chambers Street
Poerfess
McAdam
Johnson
Bar
J. George Flamaier
Admiral Schley Cause Roars Across Nation
The article reflects public agitation over Admiral Schley's fate and the nation's resistance to autocratic measures, describing the issue as unprecedented in tone and significance. It emphasizes the American people's resolve and civic engagement surrounding the controversy.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Admiral Schley
Schley Verdict Debate Echoes Public Sentiment
Edward P. Thompson argues the world backs Schley, faulting only a few judges and minor actions. He urges judging great deeds by outcomes, praising Schley as a hero and endorsing Dewey’s view over two alleged inferiors in the naval command during the 1901 controversy.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Schley
Dreyfus
Marconi
Bell
Edison
Westinghouse
Roentgen
Newfoundland
Nova Scotia
Anglo-American Telegraph Company
Pupin
Admiral Dewey
Sehleyv
England
Dewey
Hobson
Edward P. Thompson
W York
Public Opinion and Free Expression in Government
The piece argues against stifling public opinion following the Schley decision and a cited French case. It contends arbitrary measures undermine democracy, risk undermining liberty, and threatens the government’s foundation which rests on free speech. It calls for safeguarding open discussion of official matters.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Schley
France
Silent public debate and distrust of silence in government
A letter defending free expression against administration efforts to suppress discussion of public questions. It cites President Roosevelt and General Miles, argues that fear of controversy harms civic judgment, and praises Dewey for discipline amid insubordination during the Santiago siege. Signed by R.F. Stevens Jr of Newark and a Constant Reader in New York.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Court of Inquiry
Roosevelt
Gen
Miles
Washington
R.F. Stevens, Jr
Newark
N. J
Dewey
Santiago
New York
Public protest over Schley controversy in Times letter
H. Hodges of Jersey City denounces what he calls clamor around Schley. He argues Schley lacked vigor at Santiago, retreated from the enemy, and followed a different battle course than Sampson’s plan, urging fair treatment of naval officers.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
the Times
Schley
Cienfuegos
Santiago
Sampson
Capes
Sehrey
Brooklyn
Navy
Navy Department
Cat Ge H. Hodges
Jersey City
Censure of General Miles Draws Public Fire
William Cowper Conant in New York denounces Roosevelt’s broad suppression of dissent over the Miles affair. He condemns the Administration for scapegoating Maclay and harming navy discipline and public trust, warning the President’s rigid rule could ruin his career and enlarge opposition.
President Roosevelt and Gen Miles confrontation debated
A New York letter questions whether President Roosevelt angrily berated Gen Miles in a crowded room and demands a fair account. The writer, a lifelong Republican, compares the alleged scene to Andrew Johnson era conduct and asks if Secretary Root’s censure suffices. The letter reflects public concern over presidential behavior toward subordinates.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Roosevelt
Gen. Miles
Andrew Johnson
Gen
Miles
Root
Mississippi
United States
Fremont
Dayton
Abraham Lincoln
Times
New York
Roosevelt Censure Question Sparks Editorial Dispute
The letter questions the President's censure of General Miles and implies a similar rebuke of an unnamed admiral, highlighting concerns over consistency in military discipline and executive power. The writer urges clearer articulation of policy and fairness in wartime actions.
Rebuke to Miles Criticized by Reader Letter
A reader defends Gen. Miles against criticism from the President and Secretary of War, arguing Miles deserved the rebuke for prior conduct including a Cuba beef ration issue. The writer urges adherence to Army regulations and condemns Miles’ engagement with the press over embalmed beef. Justice.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Gen. Miles
Miles
Cuba
West Point
Tropics
Yellow Journals
United States
Criticism and the President A Loyal Legioner Letter
A Brooklyn letter argues the Miles reprimand was a routine military matter not a threat to speech. It defends military discipline as necessary and questions the legitimacy of civilian critics. The writer urges respect for elected representatives and notes Europe as a caution. December 26, 1901 Brooklyn N Y.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Miles
Dreyfus
Theodore Roosevelt
Mr. Root
Europe
Brooklyn
Col Roosevelt Round Robin and Navy Scandals Echo Criticism
In a New York editorial tone reflecting 1891 concerns, the piece defends discipline in the U S military while criticizing Col Roosevelt U S V for signing a round robin to Congress. It compares naval decisions against Admiral Schley and hints at punitive measures for insubordination.
Roosevelt's controversial round robin drew praise and praise then
The letter signed by Theodore Roosevelt and others during the Spanish American War harshly criticized War Department mismanagement. It aided soldier care, led to Alger's dismissal, and helped Roosevelt gain governorship. The writer questions current censure of Gen Miles for criticizing Admiral Schley and notes Times gratitude.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Spain
Cuba
Theodore Roosevelt
United States
Santiago
War Department
Alger
Roosevelt
Gen. Miles
Admiral Schley
Miles
McKinley
Public criticism of Schley and Sampson in 1901
In a New York dated December 24 1901 the author argues Admiral Schley deserved fair treatment for the Santiago victory while noting Sampson surrendered command before the battle and sailed away from the key theater. The piece laments aggressive vilification of both officers amid praise and condemnation in the republic.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Schley
Admiral Schley
Paul Jones
Decatur
Farragut
Santiago
Sampson
Manila
New York
Sunday Opening of Saloons and Sabbath Debate
A letter from A. E. G. responding to Rev. W. Dallmann argues for a rational Sunday observance, distinguishing moral from ceremonial laws. It cites Babylonian origins of Sabbath concepts, notes Mosaic law timing, and defends contextual scriptural interpretation as key to Sabbath practice. New York, Dec. 6, 1901.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
W. Dallmann
Saunders
Christendom
Nebé
Borsippa
Boscawen
Khammurabi
Maunders
New York
Saloon and Moral Law Debate in Hedson Letter
James Merciful argues against open saloons in New York City, contending enforced temperance is essential to curb widespread drunkenness and related evils. He warns that legalizing or softening liquor laws invites a decline in citizenship and moral standards, with repeated cycles of vice and corruption.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Time
Justice Jerome
Times
Jerome
Saloen
New York City
New York
James Menfitli
Hedson
Tims
J. Cuyler
London
Dr. Cuyler
Guibblers
W. Dallmann
Roosevelt
Colosse
Paul
New Yorker
Central Asia
HOW JUDGE McADAM BRAVED THE BLIZZARD
J. George Flamaiier recalls Judge McAdam enduring a March 12, 1888 blizzard, marching to court through the storm and earning a reputation for honesty, fairness, and diligence. The tribute notes his open home, legal aid, and relentless courtroom pace, calling him a symbol of steadfast public service.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Time
Inge McAdam
Union Square
Morton Heise
Judge McAdam
Ife
Warning Against the First Glass on the Christian Day
The author argues that the glass of beer tempts toward sin and that the first drink sets drinkers on a dangerous path. It stresses varying personal conditions and weak will, warning that indiscriminate Sunday alcohol sales would harm New York. Jean Saunders signs the note.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York
Jean Saunders
Tompkins Defends Wartime Service in Public Letter
Arthur F. Cosby of the Citizens' Union corrects an earlier campaign-era misattribution naming Gov Daniel Tompkins among defrauders. He notes Tompkins pledged his fortune to credit the state and funded early 1812 efforts, helping raise an army of 56 000. he died while the government owed him funds. December 20, 100L.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Daniel T. Tompkins
Tompkins
Aaron Burr
William M. Tweed
Citizens’ Union
Arthur F. Cosby
New York
Also Mentioned on This Page
Schley Court
Chley
Powers That Be
Benham and
Ramsay
Benham
John B. Harding
Shakespeare
Nile
Silius Noble Ventidius
Media
Mesopotamia
William Cowper Conant
Mles
Miles Indorsed
Col. Roosevelt
Secretary Long
Devil's Isle
Nawal
Gov