The Times Debate on City Churches and Church Power
Readers respond to a New York Times editorial arguing churches must be entertaining to attract worshippers. They defend traditional preaching over vaudeville models, praising pastorates and large congregations while warning against secularizing worship. The letters also discuss biblical scholarship, higher criticism, and the role of religion in modern society.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
New York
Smvikiwer
Glc
Chicagoaptist Ministers’ Association
Chicago
Yimees J
Song
Parkhurst
Jr. Burrell
MacArthur
Christ
Times
Jesus Christ
B.Q. Denhanm
Abraham
Moses
Babylonia
Egypt
Ingersoll
Niigara
Europe
Orient
China
India
Jacob
Esau
Jerusalem
Israel
Jesus of Nazareth
Jesus
Warwick
N. Y
Causes of Church Apathy Amid Higher Criticism
The Times discusses church apathy amid the rise of higher criticism tracing its roots to Origen and Alexandria. It argues that symbolism replaced literal prophecy, weakening traditional exegesis and challenging pulpit defenses against modern biblical critique. Analyzing aims to show how historic shifts diminished literal scripture to preserve doctrinal authority.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Times
Origen
Alexandria
Rome
Constantinople
Israel
Christ
David
Paine
Ingersoll
Pulpit's Power Questioned by Schenectady Letter
PRANK H. IRVING of Schenectady N Y argues in a dated appeal that church indifference stems from pulpit rigidity. He urges preachers adapt to modern thought, embrace secular ideas, and connect with urban life to renew social and spiritual uplift. December 18, 1900.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Prank H. Irving
Schenectady, N.Y
High Hats in Churches Criticised Letter to the Editor
A New York letter to the editor from December 16, 1900 urges abolition of ladies high hats in churches. It condemns large feathered headgear blocking views, notes theatres ban hats, and proposes attending hatless, removing hats, or staying home as remedies. The writer signs MISOGYNIST and places blame on self centered fashion in worship spaces.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
New York
Calvary Pastor Blames Christians for China Persecutions
The Rev Dr Robert S MacArthur says Christians bear some responsibility for late persecutions in China. He cites authorities noting French protection of Catholic hierarchy while Protestant missionaries are less culpable, urging admission of these facts and shared blame.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Robert S. MacArthur
Calvary Baptist Church
China
Critique of the Woman's Christian Temperance Union
James A. Harvey denounces the WCTU and the canteen debate, arguing the group dethroned Christ’s methods in favor of man made laws. He asserts the organization seeks political power, harms temperance efforts, and collaborates with saloon interests to push canteen abolition for profit.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
W. B. Conklin
Woman's Christian Temperance Union
Individua
Cleveland
Ohio
Woman's Political Temperance Union
Christian Organization
Geld
Times
Congress
Senate
Joseph Miller
Washington
House
James A. Harvey
Hamden
Appeal for pure beer and arsenical poisoning in Britain
An article warns that genuine beer cannot be made from substitutes and cites a London report of 3 009 people poisoned by adulterated beer near Manchester and Liverpool. It notes English reliance on beer and worries that arsenic-tainted brews could reach London.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Gambrinus
Great Britain
Manchester
Liverpool
England
London
Prohibition Drift Urged On Beer Substitutes In Brewing
SMMET WELLS argues in New York on December 20, 1900 that beer adulteration with arsenic and other chemicals endangers public health. He cites The Lancet and calls for strict federal or state legislation to ban substitutes for malt and hops, praising German law as a model and urging penalties for brewers who use adulterants.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Lancet
England
Manchester
State Society of Hop Growers
Rochester
N. Y
Germany
United States
Smmet Wells
New York
Anthracite Industry Faces Costly Waste and Consolidation Call
A long analysis of the Pennsylvania coal sector argues that the anthracite trade suffers from wasteful competition, duplicated rail movement, and poor data. It urges consolidation among major producers to cut costs, boost profits, and share gains with workers and the public, while noting potential wage and price effects.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Pennsylvania Coal Company
United States
Pennsylvania
Tidewater
Plans for Uniting Interests For Public Good
A 1900 letter from Thomas L. Greene of New York argues that as plans to unify interests advance the public will accept developments with equanimity. He contends that perfected, fully carried out plans will benefit consumers, capitalists, and mine operatives alike.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Homas L. Greene
New York
Infants and Justice in the Stewart Case Debated
A critique of Judge Furman sentencing a fourteen year old for manslaughter, arguing the law treats youth unfairly and calls for reform. The writer recalls English and historical cases to urge discretion in juvenile punishment and warns against inciting literature. William Cauldwell notes on past theater prices and calls for affordable, quality entertainment funded by philanthropy.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Furman
Stewart
Georgia
New York Central
Sutherland
Hawkins
Matthew Hale
Pike
Abingdon
England
Great Blackstone
Marshal H. Bright
Tarrytown-on-Hudson
Books Wanted for Bronx Library to Start Public Collection
In 1900 community leaders call for a free Bronx Public Library to serve a borough of about 250000. One thousand books have arrived and will be catalogued for opening on January 5, with gifts sent to The Bronx Public Library care of Washington Avenue and One Hundred Seventy Sixth Street, New York City. F B Makepeace as pastor-coordinator asks for donations of bright, wholesome works across history science art fiction and poetry to build a strong start and curb vice through education.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
The
Bronx
Westchester
Riverdale
Harlem
Manhattan
Tremont
Free Public Library
Bronx Public Library
Washington Avenue
New York City
F. B. Makepeace
Trinity Congregational Church
New York
Prices of Seats in Theatres An Early Look at Costs
In a December note the editor laments rising theatre prices. Comparisons to prewar rates show 19th century prices varied from 25 to 50 cents, to $1.50 and up. Mentions Ilavuna Opera at Astor Place and Castle Garden, Max Maretzek at Astor Place, and Burton's Theatre with diverse shows and price differences.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Burton
Brougham
C. W. Clarke
Mitchell
Nickinson
Bland
Walcot
Mrs. Isherwood
Mary Taylor
J. W. Wallack, Jr
the Bowery
Flying Dutchman
John A Scott
Bothain
Shoerhaker
Toulouse
Don Cesar de Bazan
Peter Cooper
Temple of Fame
William Cauldwell
New York
The
New York Times
Ilavuna Opera Company
Ignazio Marini
Lorenzo Sabri
Cesare Badiate
Signora Tedisco
Astor Place
Castle Garden
Max Maretzek
Astor Place Opera House
Ike Signorina Perodi
Brooklyn Museum
Booth
Richard III
Julia Turnbull
Lisette
Parquet
Platt and Reform Tactics Debate City Purification
Heinrich F. Charles argues reform groups err by courting Senator Platt and political harmony. He urges eight months of public education to compel Platt toward harmony, preventing a repeat of 1897 tactics and ensuring a cleaner Greater New York government. He recalls Lexow's impact and urges focused education over partisan maneuvering.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Tammany Hall
Platt
Croker
Tiega
Senator Platt
Strong
Lexow Committee
Nolens Volens
Reform
Pratt
Tracy
Seth Low
Fors
Greater
New York
Heinrich F. Charles
Desperate Appeal to Restore Bensonia Cemetery to Park Use
An New York City resident urges the press to pressure authorities to convert the derelict Bensonia Cemetery on St Ann s Avenue near 156th Street into a public park and playground. He cites repeated official inaction, neglect by Health and Street Cleaning departments, and vandalism including tree losses and use as a dumping ground.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
St. Ann’s Avenue
One Hundred and
Fifty-sixth Street
Bensonia Cemetery
Board of Aldermen
Department of Health
City of
New York
North Side Board of Trade
Taxpayers’ Alliance
Ee Rh Oe
Bronx
Party Danger in Ship Subsidy Debated in Senate
The New York Times editor notes the Senate committee delaying the Five B’l ship subsidy bill until after holidays. It criticizes the committee for bias, urges dispassionate congressional debate, and warns Republicans against making the bill a party measure while stressing future party integrity.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Senate
Congress
Frye
Hanna
Republican Party
United States Treasury
United States
Wild political attack on Republican principles
A fragment cites G. Weaver Loper dated December 21 1900 arguing against an unspecified bold but uneconomic transaction. The piece frames the proposal as a test of Republican principles, implying political contention surrounding the issue and its political repercussions.
Inquiry on Savings Banks Rate Changes and Depositor Transparency
An observer letter questions Bowery Savings Bank 4 percent rate rises and asks why banks cannot show semi annual profits and asset earnings. It urges banks to publish clear statements of gross income running expenses and net profits to prove or challenge proposed rate reductions. Brooklyn December 21 1900.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Bowery Savings Bank
Brooklyn
N. Y
Savings Banks Earnings Promise Prudence and Public Trust
Rank Moore Jeffery argues Bowery Savings Bank and others should return fair yields to depositors, criticizes surplus buildup and costly bank edifices, and urges conservative, transparent management of public savings under law. He calls for government by the people to apply to financial trusts and to protect the people's money.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Bowery Savings Bank
Rank Moore Jeffery
New York
Water Bottles Can Start Fires Warns Dentist Storeroom Fire Hazard
A New York dentist warns that sunlight through bottles and flasks can concentrate heat and ignite materials in storerooms. In a 1900 letter, H. Faber describes a fire sparked by a water bottle acting as a burning glass, urging caution for dentists and apothecaries.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
New York
Faber
Also Mentioned on This Page
Confucius
McKinley
Politics
Temperance
Young Stewart
Prin
Ciples
G. Weaver Loper