Readers Discuss Schley Court Findings and Porter's Court-Martial
A letter to the editor discusses the Schley Court of Inquiry and the Porter court martial's injustice. It recalls Porter’s Civil War actions at Fair Oaks Malvern Hill and Gaines Mills and urges a congressional probe into the Bureau of Navigation amid accusations of persecution and bias.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Schley Court of Inquiry
Fitz John Porter
Porter
McClellan
Richmond
Fair Oaks
Malvern Hill
Gaines Mills
War Department
Pope
Gen. Grant
Grant
Schley
Department
Peltroon
Congress
Bureau of Navigation
Denmark
New York
Wyares
Schley praised for sinking fleet amid un-American criticism
T Kruger from New York argues that Admiral Schley fulfilled his mission by destroying the Spanish fleet and should receive praise, while he condemns the Schley controversy as disgusting and un-American. He states success should be valued regardless of method, and criticizes irrelevant questions raised about Schley.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Schley
Schiey
Faniced Security Under The Flying Fleet
J Stubart Dotten of Brooklyn writes to The Times criticizing naval command during the Spanish American War. He argues Cervera’s fleet exploited gaps while Schley’s Flying Squadron touted security. He contrasts Dewey at Manila with Cervera at Santiago and questions naval leadership.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
R. W. Barkley
TiMes
Schrey
Cervera
Schley
Atlantic
Tor
Manila
Santiago
Dewey
Ke J. Stubart
Brooklyn
Dewey's Verdict The People's Verdict
A letter from Brooklyn dated December 16 1901 asserts the American people endorse Admiral Dewey's verdict on Schley. It credits Schley with courage and victory, notes history records achievements, and expresses pride in American judgment and posterity. The writer stresses results over contingencies.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Schley
Admiral Schley
Admiral Dewey
S. BE. M
Brooklyn
Meaning of Schley court acts in light of inquiry claims
The writer argues that the Schley court of inquiry reveals the real intent of Judge Advocate remarks and questions the Navy Department’s handling of accusations of Schley’s cowardice at Santiago. The piece notes the long incubation of the Schley matter and suggests the precept left the charge unresolved.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Schley Court of Inquiry
Schley
Capt. Lemly
Hanna
Navy Department
Santiago
Debate over Sampson and the Santiago Victory
George E. Bissell argues the New York should not have been withdrawn from the squadron before the battle, praising Brooklyn and Oregon for preventing a catastrophic outcome. He credits Admiral Dewey with clarifying who won and condemns criticism of Sampson while defending Schley’s conduct and the overall victory.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Today
Schley
Tub Times
Sampson
New York
Hobson
Napoleon
Brooklyn
Oregon
Shafter
Gloucester
Admiral Schleys Excep tions editorial praise
A reader thanks The New York Times for an editorial praising Admiral Schley and opposing a French-backed wrongdoing. The letter asserts public support for the paper’s stance and cites past efforts against abuses. Dated December 20, 190%.
Time Estimates in Critical Moments in Naval Court
In Maldonado Bay 1884 a cutter transfer during arm practice capsized, cadet and marine rescued by a whaleboat. Discrepancies in perceived time caused contention among the senior, cadet, and boatswain, with estimates ranging from under a minute to fifteen minutes. The boatswain’s mate settled the dispute, but the senior withdrew to his cabin.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Schley Court
Maldonado Bay
Uruguay
Lobos Island
Ensign D
Fitzgerald
Schley Controversy and Victory’s Impact on Alleged Charges
The article argues that if Admiral Sampson had won at Santiago de Cuba the charges against Admiral Schley would not have been heard, suggesting the pride of that day would have settled the matter and erased the court’s condemnation.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Cervera
Schley
Wii Aley York
The
New York Times
Sampson
Santiago
Admiral Schley
Public letter praises New York paper for fairness
A Dec 20 1901 letter from G B N commends a New York newspaper for upholding justice in the Schley case, noting it stands up for fairness despite odds.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Schley
New York
G. B.N
Facts SUSTAIN ADMIRAL DEWEY in Naval Command Debate
A defender outlines command law and practice in the Dewey controversy. He argues that senior officers automatically assume control when the Commander in Chief is absent, cites signals and sightings to support Schley’s de facto leadership, and references Rear Admiral Evans’s account of fleet actions to reinforce the normal chain of command and the allocation of responsibility. The piece also notes the Navy Department's stance on Schley's promotion and related records.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Admiral Dewey
New York
Siboney
Sears
Brooklyn
Schley
Sampson
Santiago
Dewey
Robley D. Evans
Havana
D'Sregard
Morro Castle
Pedro
Key West
Evats
Evans
Admiral Schley
Texas
Indiana
Navy Department
Admiral Ley
Senate
Secretary of the Navy
Commodore Seniey
Navy board findings and Schley promotion history discussed
In 1899 the Navy concluded unsteadiness in purpose and failure to obey orders and 1901 court findings of vacillation. Commodore Schley was ordered before an examining board, which included Shard Matthews and Norton, to assess fitness before promotion. The board's evidence led to Schley's promotion to rear admiral, with Senate confirmation. He then commanded the South Atlantic Squadron from 1899 until retirement near 1901.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Secretary of the Navy
Seley Court
Navy Department
Schley
Naval Register
Montgomery Shard
E. O. Matthews
Charles S. Norton
Navy
United States
Commodore Schley
Senate of the
Ramsay
President
South Atlantic
South America
Admiral Sampson
Court of Claims
Sunday Saloon Opening Sparks Sabbath Debate Letter
JEAN SAUNDERS of New York protests Sunday saloon openings and defends the Sabbath as a divine institution. The letter argues that state laws reflect sacred origins of the Sabbath and human life, challenges A E G statements, and questions political use of religious authority.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Jean Saunders
New York
Sunday Rest and the Duty of the Fourth Commandment
William H. Wills argues that Sunday rest should be protected as the Lord's Day and critiques outings and Sunday travel that infringe others' rest. He contends that even with support for rest, many seek leisure by using labor and transport services on Sunday, harming communal propriety and safety.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
John J. Bealin
Coney Island
Nm ‘Ch
William H. Wills
New York
David
Mark
Christ
Philip Melanchthon
Luther
E. A. Washburn
Calvary Episcopal.Church
Church of England
Sunday open saloons spark reform party tensions
James McNeill of Hudson argues that open Sunday saloons threaten religious convictions and split reformists, warning that appeasing appetite could undermine honest government in New York City. He contends the two sides’ logic is flawed and questions the city’s integrity if religion is sacrificed for expediency.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Reform Party
Tammany Party
Reform
New York
Tammany
New York City
James McNeill
Hudson
Open Saloons on Sunday Debated by Clergy and Public
A long letter by James McNeill defends moderating Sunday saloon bans and criticizes religious zealots. Lutheran pastor William Dallmann argues for liberty and law, advocating Sunday open saloons as a civic issue.
Wedding of City Reform and Sunday Opening of Saloons
A lengthy Times article views the looming marriage of City Reform and Sunday Opening of Saloons as a matter of city and state wide interest. It cites praise and critique, notes open saloons six days, and recounts reactions to a college bred woman’s open appeal about saloon driven suffering. It ends with a birthday tribute and a quoted poem from a drunkard's daughter.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
the Times
Roger Padden Smyth
Smyth
James McNeil
Hudson
McNeill
Nathan
David
Questions About the Sunday Saloon
A reader asks why saloons may open Sunday afternoons and evenings while not open all day If workers are under factory restrictions should they not have broader Sunday access to alcohol and sustenance in public houses The letter challenges temperance limits and advocates for extended hours.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Saoon
Inquirer
Brooklyn, N.Y
New York Times
James McNeill
McNeill
Jerome
Rochester
Roger Padden Smyth
Brooklyn
Roosevelt
New York
Dee
Philbin
Policeman’s Club
New York City
William Dallmann
Lutheran Church of the Redeemer
Forty-fifth Street
Broadway
The
The Catholic Church's attitude described letter to editor
A reader defends the Catholic Church stance of noninvolvement in politics while urging influence through conscience. The church rejects active hustings engagement yet advocates moral education via schools confession pulpit and press. It argues Church action addresses morals beyond political expediency.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Times
Philbin
Tammany
Tammany Hall
Catholic Church
Caesar
Church of Christ
Albury
Church
Les the Catholi
Exac
A Mechanic’s View of the Saloon in 1901 New York
A New York letter from December 21, 1901 presents a factory worker’s blunt critique of liquor reform. The author argues abolishing saloons would ruin social life and exposes concerns about government revenue, free lunches, and the symbolic role of saloons as community hubs. He advocates removing liquor revenue as the only moderation.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Count Tolstoi
Felix Adter
Jolly Company
D&Én Cavanagh
New York
Adler and the oughtness of social reform in city life
Mrs Crane argues that Prof Adler of Ethical Culture should embody the science of human life by living among the poor and questioning Sunday saloon closures and Confucian ethics. She questions whether reformers neglect their own households while pursuing club life and stimulants.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Prof
Adler
Princeton
Mrs. Crane
Also Mentioned on This Page
Judge Advocate
Lermily
T. Kruger
Lemly
Ben
George E. Bissell
A. A. Paymaster
U. S. N. Mount Vernon
N. Y
People
France
Lutheran Church (Synodical Conference
St. Paul
Thas
L. O'Rourke
Prof. Adler