Editors and readers clash over magazine talent and influence
A Baltimore writer rails at editors who prefer celebrity names over merit, recounts how Blackwood and Dickens sought fresh talent, and urges rewarding essays on Ruskin and Arnold. He mocks vanity patrons, praises honest criticism, and calls for renewed focus on literary quality.
Essayists Not Dead But Discouraged
A republication argues essays remain vital as magazines launch a record for “the men who do things.” It rejects claims essays are out of fashion and urges renewed interest in belles lettres and criticism, noting a shift toward urgency in reviving serious reflective writing.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Denyim
Early New York Maps and Views in the Library of Congress
The author responds to J Lee Phillips criticism in The Saturday Review about rarity claims of maps and engravings. He notes Phillips found two of seven rare items and urges continued examination of LOC holdings to reveal more rarities such as the Duyckinck map and Burgis Prospect. He cites Fiske's Dutch and Quaker Colonies misstatement as part of the motive for his brochure on the Bradford Map.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Phillips
Fiske
Mr. Phillips
Adrien van der Donck
New York
New York Times Saturday Review
Saturday Review
J. Lee Phillips
Library of Congress
Congressional Library
Duyckinck
New York City
Bradford
John Fiske
America
James Lees
Tees
Grant Orce
James Tam
Montgomerie
Nordhoff Bindery Exhibit Showcases Royal Bindings
The Evelyn Nordhoff Bindery held its second annual exhibition of books and leatherwork at 114 East Twenty-third Street on Dec 14 and 15. Florence Foote exhibited bindings from Cobden-Sanderson inspired designs in brown pigskin and brown levant morocco on works by Morris Rossetti Browning and others with blind tooling and gold accents.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Nordhoff
Evelyn Nordhoff
East Twenty-third Street
Florence Foote
Miss Nordhoff
Miss Foote
Doves
Cobden-Sanderson
Chapin
Matthiessen
Guild of Arts and Crafts
Marie- Little
Douglas Volk
Sarah Francis
C. E. Busch
Barry Demands Truth About The Congressman's Wife
John D. Barry writes to The New York Times Saturday Review exposing edits by editor Arthur Grissom in The Smart Set January issue. He cites numerous verbal changes, some minor and others absurd, noting a Har vard graduate line altered to It looks like it's all over and asking for withdrawal that was refused.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times Saturday Review
Arthur Grissom
Harvard
Solitary Reaper attribution debate in The Saturday Review
George from New York writes to The New York Times Saturday Review arguing a quotation attributed to Wordsworth likely comes from The Solitary Reaper. He notes it is the first four lines of the third stanza of that poem.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
George
New York
New York Times
The Publishers Point of View in The World's Work
January issue date of The World's Work described with reader subscriptions and pricing. Highlights include The Monthly Review article by the Earl of Robesbury on William Pitt letters, Mrs Seton-Thompson book A Woman Tenderfoot, J L Gilder autobiography The Tom Boy, and a new edition of Our Forefathers furniture book with price and formats. Doubleday Page & Co. advertises.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
the Times
Goody Company
Monthly Review
John Murray
London
Earl of Rosebery
Wiliam Pitt
J.L. Gilder
Japan
Highland Girl and Solitary Reaper Referenced in 1803 Tour
A historical note discusses Routledge edition poems from 1889 titled Tour in Scotland 1803 and the confusion over Solitary Highland Lass Reaping and Singing versus The Highland Girl. It cites Wordsworth quotations with possible word variants such as perchance and perhaps, linking to old and unhappy far-off things and battles long ago.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Routledge
Scotland
M. H
Wordsworth
Richard Henry Stoddard
A Poem that Makes One Glad
Jane Marsh Parker of Detroit writes to The New York Times Review praising William Vaughn Moody's Gloucester Moors. She asks readers to name the December leading monthlies poem and to share their favorite line. She expresses surprise at little public mention of Moody and calls for reader input.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Jane Marsh
Parker
Detroit
Mich
New York Times Saturday Review
Gloucester Moors
Wiliam Vaughn Moody
December Pets and Animals issue features tips and illustrations
The December number of Pets and Animals offers pet keeping hints and accompanying illustrations. Bertha E. Ashby designed the attractive cover with a jingle by Minnie Francesa Brown. The issue includes a Clara B. West story The Thief Who Won the Prize and Olive Hyde Foster essay A Zoo Conducted by a Woman describing a typical New England Christmas.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Bertha E. Ashby
Minnie Francesa Brown
Clara B. West
New England
Olive Hyde Foster
Also Mentioned on This Page
Charles Dickens
George William Curtis
Charles A. Dana
William Blackwood
Frank A. Munse
Leland Stanford
Helen Gould
Burdett-Coutts
William Dean-Jiowells
Henry James
Mr. Howells
Century Magazine
James
Dicken
Thackeray
Saturday Review of London
Eugene L. Didier
Baltimore
Voleon
Dewey
Manila
Matthew Arnold
Ruskin
Prometheus
A. Z
William Bradford
George Hayward
Mr. Barry
Academy
Doubleday, Page