Readings on De Morgan and Poe Draw Reader Debate
The Saturday Review of Books defends De Morgan’s It Never Can Happen Again as a deeply interdependent tale with strong character arcs including Blind Jim and Lizeran, praising its blend of real life drama and supernatural elements and its criticism of temperance. Arthur Guiterman reflects on Poe and Motherwell, questioning plagiarism links and noting Poe’s familiarity with Father Motherwell.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times Saturday Review of Books
William de Morgan
Lizeran
Blind Jim
Nell
Joseph Vance
Alice-For- Short
Mr. de Morgan
Margaret E. Sangst
Poe Curiosities and a Poe Manuscript Controversy
Readers discuss Poe parodies and a claimed autograph manuscript. Correspondents dispute an 1909 claim that a Poe autograph exists for a poem later identified as Estelle Anna Lewis's The Forsaken, noting Poe's review and the poem’s publication history.
Who Was Sandy Gordon Is a Satirical Antiquarian Book
John F. J. of Brooklyn recalls a century old Scottish booklet titled Sandy Gordon's Itinerarium Septentrionale. He notes rapid editions across Britain and a Latin edition for continental scholars, along with debates over the author and purpose. The piece sparked renewed interest in prehistoric archaeology.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times Saturday Review of Books
Sandy Gordon
Scotland
Edinburg
British Isles
Europe
Cheetham
Manchester
England
Ireland
Cane Trong
Rondy
John F
Brooklyn
Appreciative Reader Suggests Poems Volume
Gustav C. Blessin of New York writes to praise a Saturday poem feature in the Review and urges that a volume of the poems be printed as a book. He argues the pre poems are gems and would gain wide reception.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times Saturday Review of Books
the Raven
Poe
Longfellow
Harriet
Winslow
Ganon
Brunswick
Maine
John D. Crimmins
Estélle Anna Lewis
The
Gustav C. Blessin
New York
Also Mentioned on This Page
Margaret E. Sangster
William Motherwell
Motherwell
Arthur Guiterman
Poe Curiosities
Sohn D. Cummins
E. A. Poe
Arma Lewis
J. B. Whitty
Richmond, Va
Myrtle Reed
Columbia
William Denison Lyman Large
the Independent
Herbert Quick
Isthmus
Hugh C. Invo
Panama
Madame
Arve de Barine
Madame Barine
Lewiston Journal
Alice MacGowan
Tennessee Highlands
Chicago Record-Herald
Wilfrid Ward
London Athenaeum
the Rosary
Florence L. Barclay
Guy Thorne
I. Querido
Balzac
San Celestino
John Ayscough
Peter
Fraternity
John Galsworthy
N. Y
Putnam’s Magazine
G. P. Putnam’s Sons
London
the Knickerbocker Press
Hartford Courant
George Barr McCutcheon
GRA
Dodd, Mead # Co
Arthur Rackham
Rackham
Y. Age & CO
Enor
Cortland
Waioen Dane
Doubeday
Page& CC
Huntting CO
Pringfeld
Mas