Letters on the coal strike and monopoly debates in 1902
Readers argue over strikes and arbitration in the coal industry. Contributors defend worker rights, criticize monopolies, and discuss the roles of unions, railroads, and landowners in shaping wages, prices, and political power.
Letter to Editor on coal strike fairness and union legality
James L. Newman of Baltimore writes that miners seek fair pay and shorter hours, arguing the dispute centers on weights and dues rather than national wage control. He condemns operators’ groups and urges Pennsylvania authorities to suspend charters of non compliant firms. Dated August 27, 1902.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Hewitt
Pennsylvania
James L. Newman
Baltimore
Debated Labor Divide Reframed by a New Look at Mines
A letter to the editor argues the Hewitt Mitchell dispute centers on a deeper issue than union vs non union hiring. The writer urges an unprejudiced reassessment of the miners occupation, noting the smell boys at work in breakers and calling for clarity beyond petty misunderstandings.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Hewitt
Mitchell
Times
Views on the Labor Situation and Monopolies
A speaker endorses Hewitt on free labor and urges regulation of labor organization. He cites unions, monopoly practices by the New York Central, and calls for laws protecting workers, condemning poolrooms as societal curses and urging stricter penalties for crime. He contrasts immigrant and Americanized labor and critiques political pardons for labor votes.
What Are the Strike Issues A. L. S. Letter Calls Out Labor Policy
A. L. S. of New York writes Aug 29 1902 defending unions as a necessity while criticizing selective non union employment bans. He cites Abram Hewitt and Dr Lyman Abbott to argue that any effort to bar workers from earning wages is unjust and that labor organizations should include all workers rather than exclude them.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
A. S. Hewitt
M. F. Cazin
New York
Hewitt
Baer
Harlem
Lawrence Telfair
Morristown
N. J
Tidewater
Mr. Hewitt
Mr. Mitchell
Mitchell
John Hampden
Patrick Henry
Ernest H. Crosby
Rhinebeck
N. Y
Orer
Joseph H. Lewis
Abram S. Hewitt
Organization of Labor
Hac Ee
New York Central and
Hudson River Railroad
New York Central
White Plains
New York City
David B. Hill
State of
Knights of Labor
Wall Street
United Mine Workers
United Mine Workers’ Labor Organization
Lyman Abbott
Oe Ae
Workingman
A Citizen's View of the Coal Strike
A letter analyzes Mr John Mitchell's reply to Mr Abrams Hewitt on the anthracite strike. It questions union methods pickets and dues drives, cites local mine committees and wage levels, and argues miners seek living wages while political control is denied.
Mine strike politics draw in police and editors
J W C Morrison of Wilkesbarre writes from August 28 1902 noting Hewitts statements spark police attention to strike issues. He argues editors lean to miners while unions influence conventions and elections, while law enforcement and Citizens Alliance restrain unrest amid political campaigning.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Tammany
Miners' Union
Citizens’ Alliance
Mitchell
Miners’ Union
J. W. C. Morrison
Wilkesbarre, Penn
Union Pressure and Coal War in Community War
Henry C. Sheaffer of Ocean Grove argues that operators prefer direct dealings with employers while ignoring the union. He notes repeated offers to break from the union have been refused, and urges the public to understand the coal region conflict as a war between two powers. He suggests the community must exercise its authority to protect its interests.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Henry C. Sheafer
Ocean Grove
Aug
Miners urged to seek labor harmony and thrift
A morning editorial argues miners quarrel over wages while many workers throttle expenses and grow vegetables at home. It cites Crossley of Halifax and calls for better welfare by operators, noting the harsh reality of six to seven months’ pay for a year’s work.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Pennsylvania
Crossley
Halifax
England
America
Newark
N. J
A Leader's Plan for Settling Labor Disputes
Williams Brown of Brooklyn argues in 1902 that government should appoint an impartial commissioner to investigate coal strike grievances, weigh wage margins, and report findings for a lawful, well reasoned settlement. He favors arbitration and a funded federal role to prevent forced work actions.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Abram
Hewitt
John Mitchell
United States Treasury
Williams. Brown
Brooklyn
What the Miners Are Fighting For
A letter from P Averill of South Britain Connecticut argues miners seek union authority over workers not wage or hour details. He says law enforcement tolerates strikes and warns of creeping anarchic control if authorities fail to protect employers. August 26 1902.
Editorial clash over coal strike facts and remedies
A reader letters column contends with the paper’s coal strike coverage citing mine resumption, price shifts, and corporate discounts. He argues for eminent domain to secure Pennsylvania coal and criticizes the editorial stance as misinformed or malicious. Letters from William J. Roberts and others urge constitutional remedies and labor arbitration reforms.
Miners oppose pay by weight and compulsory check-off
A Hazleton reader argues against paying miners by weight in the anthracite region. He says the compulsory check-off would let companies deduct union dues, turning employers into collectors like the company store. He cites strikes and legal measures as proof, urging denial of the system.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Hazleton
Schuylkill
John J. Williams
Hazleton, Penn
Roosevelt’s Eminent Domain Trust Regulation Plan
The speaker argues against constitutional amendment for trusts and supports using eminent domain through congressional law to take private property needed for public use, asserting the Constitution already permits this approach. The message questions Roosevelt’s up-to-date stance and contemplates possible constitutional stretching.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York Times
Roosevelt
Congress
Court Opinion Applies to Anthracite Coal Mining
The Court of Appeals upholds state power to regulate elevator charges as a public necessity. Judge Andrews notes government may impose restraints for the general welfare and protect private property within the public good. The piece argues that mining and transporting anthracite coal, a vital monopoly, requires regulation beyond laissez faire. E. G. Bullard.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
United States
Pennsylvania
Congress
England
Roosevelt
Philippines
Supreme Court of the
A. S
New York
E. R. New York
New York Times
People Vs. Budd
N. Y
Court of Appeals
Andrews
E. G. Bullard
End the Strike and Return to Honest Work
A reader from Ocean Grove New Jersey argues that miners should depose John Mitchell as their leader and reclaim their right to work. The letter urges timely action to end charity dependence and achieve independence by resuming honest labor.
A Plea for Arbitration in Labor Strife
The writer discusses strikes as a central issue and urges constructive debate on workers and owners rights and duties. He proposes arbitration as a peaceful path and suggests others join the discussion to reach a final solution, warning that without a fair third party conflict could escalate.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Public Rights and Private Property and Monopolies
C H Lomax Mitchell of Ridgewood N J argues in The Times editorial that coal and rail coal operators must be publicly owned to curb monopoly. He warns private control harms liberty and urges a single tax as a just remedy to ensure fair competition and distribution of wealth.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Times
MES
Ao c
H. Lomax Mitchell
Ridgewood, N. J
Editor’s stance on coal strike urges compelled mining
Letter to The New York Times argues mine owners must mine coal as a state license obliges them. The writer contends only physical impossibility excuses non production and urges state and nation to compel mining, citing a Jamestown August 28 1902 dateline.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Jamestown
R. I
The Opportunity of the Coal Operators Editorial Note
Elias B. Goodman of New York writes Aug 29 1902 praising The New York Times editorial Do They Intend to Mine Coal. He commends the paper for timely suggestions and urges continued alignment with its guidance.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
The
New York Times
Elias B. Goodman
New York
Also Mentioned on This Page
the Times
LAW
Abrams S. Hewitt
Mitchel
Woodward
Kingston
P. Averill
South Britain
Conn
William. J. Roberts
Scranton, Penn
Ocean Grove, N. J