Try 7 days of FREE access to billions of articles

Start Free Trial

Cincinnati Commercial Tribune in Cincinnati, Ohio

We have 16,378,606 pages in Ohio

View this page and access billions of articles with a 7-day free trial.

Start Free Trial

This is just the beginning! Our collection holds over 300 years of history, including rare newspapers, obituaries, marriage records, birth records, and so much more—most of which you won’t find anywhere else!

Start Free Trial

Cancel anytime, risk free

Not what you were looking for? Search our billions of articles

Advanced Search

Articles on This Page

This newspaper page contains 45 articles. Subscribers can read the full text of each article.

Newspaper

Cincinnati Commercial Tribune

Location

Cincinnati, Ohio, United States of America

Date

Jun 01, 1918

Page

5

Winifrede Coal Company Wins $4794 Verdict in River Loss Suit

After a 27 day trial in Judge Cosgrave's court the jury awarded the Winifrede Coal Company of this city $4,794.92 against Edward T. Slider of Louisville Kentucky and nothing on his counter claim. The case grew from loss of coal barge loads and boats during the July 1916 river rise.

Cosgrave Winifrede Coal Company Edward T. Slider Louisville Winifrede Company Slider

Juror Death Triggers Mistrial in Short Will Case

J J Glassmeyer retired builder living on Hopkins street died Thursday causing a halt in the trial contesting the late M F Short will. The defense refused to proceed with eleven jurors, Judge Caldwell declared a mistrial and a new jury will hear the case. Dwight H Short son of the testator contests the will leaving 2000 of a 15000 estate. Short suicide followed the death of his second wife and the will favored a relative of hers.

J. J. Glassmeyer Hopkins Street M. F. Short Hyde Park Glassmeyer Caldwell Dwight H. Short Testator Short

Judge excuses Mehling from grand jury duty. Nedderman appointed

Judge Geoghegan excused George Mehling from further grand jury service due to business engagements and named Fred Nedderman of 333 East Twelfth Street as his replacement. Previously reported indictments included William Ellison alias Smith for grand larceny William Marshall for pocket picking James Patterson for carrying concealed weapons. The false check charge against Arthur R. Reynolds was ignored.

Geoghegan George Mehling Fred Nedderman East Twelfth Street William Ellison Smith William Marshall James Patterson Arthur R. Reynolds

Dayton man charged with manslaughter in Dr Sanders death

Otto Keller of Dayton Ohio, an auto salesman, was charged with manslaughter for running down and killing Dr A O Sanders. He pleaded not guilty through his attorneys Littleford Ballard. Paul Angelo, who pleaded guilty to manslaughter in a saloon fight, received a suspended sentence to the penitentiary by Judge Geoghegan. Herman Cassidy, a black man, convicted of shooting at Edward Woefel, was refused a new trial and sentenced to the reformatory by Judge Wade Cushing.

Otto Keller Dayton, O A. O. Sanders Friday Littleford & Ballard Paul Angelo Thea Penitentiary Geoghegan Herman Cassidy Edward Woefel Camp Sherman Reformatory Wade Cushing

Mrs Abba Smysor Sues For Custody Of Daughter

Mrs Abba Smysor of West Eighth Street wife of Mon Smysor an embalmer filed habeas corpus in the Insolvency Court seeking possession and custody of their sixteen year old daughter Lucille Smysor through attorney M C Lykins alleging he illegally withholds her from communication. Judge Kelley set the hearing for 10 o clock Saturday morning.

Abba Smysor West Eighth Street Mon Smysor Lucille Smysor M. C. Lykins Kelley

Margare t Hoffner seeks divorce alleging cruelty and threats

Margaret Hoffner wife of farmer Frederick Hoffner on Reading pike sues for divorce and alimony claiming she is kept in one room, forced to work on his parents farm for board and lodging, and threatened with being shot. Attorney W W Bellew represents her. In a separate filing Mamie Hearn sues David F Hearn for divorce and alimony alleging a May 25 beating at their Norwood home and fear of threats to shoot, leading her to sleep on the floor with children. They married in May 1902 and own a house in Silverton. Attorney H J Englehardt represents her.

Margaret Hoffner Frederick Hoffner Reading Pike Toll Gate W. W. Bellew David F. Hearn Globe-Wernicke Norwood Mamie Hearn Main Avenue Silverton H. J. Englehardt

Woman seeks divorce from John Romans with abuse claims

Eliza Romans of 407 West Seventh Street sues for divorce from John Romans, married March 1917, citing repeated cruelty and threats including an attempted throat cut on March 18, seeks restoration to Eliza Smith and lists Keller Cornette & Cornette as her attorneys. Raymond Lucas of 624 Blanche Avenue, Arlington Heights, is named for habitual late nights.

John Romans West Seventh Street Eliza Smith Eliza Romans Romans Keller, Cornette & Cornette Raymond Lucas Blanche Avenue Arlington Heights

Multiple Divorces Sought Amid Alimony and Custody Claims

Mary E. Lucas alleges mistreatment and seeks divorce alimony and child custody with attorney W. C. Mardorf. Lula Mae Petry faces divorce due to her husband Norman Earl Petry's claims of temper and neglect. John H. Albert seeks divorce from Elsie Albert amid abandonment and alleged infidelity after she adopted her maiden name. Minnie Barnes sues Eugene Barnes for divorce over mistreatment and support failure. Other petitions allege cruelty or neglect with various spouses and dates of marriage including July 1910s to 1916s and addresses in Avondale and Newport. A. L. Dalton and John Oliver’s spouses are named in related suits. Ruth Kennel is cited in a case involving Hattie Casper and Harry Casper over business ties and alleged improper relations. August Wode Jr. seeks divorce from Loraine Wode citing absence from home. Jennie Henderson sues Richard Henderson for divorce over coercion and cohabitation issues since 1910. George T. Poor notes debts and assets in a separate action. Paul V. Connolly is named as trustee for Auto Antiskid Brake Company with a $4,000 bond.

Mary E. Lucas W. C. Mardorf Norman Earl Petry Lula Mae Petry Armory Avenue John H. Albert Elsie Albert Biles Barnet Avenue Avondale Albert John G. Bamnerlin Minnie Barnes Eugene Barnes Johnstown A. L. Dalton John Oliver East Front Street Rolland L. Kraw Harry Casper Vinestreet Hattie Casper Bower Avenue Newport Ruth Kennel Charles Spicer C. F. Dolle Loraine Wode Harper’s Place August W. Wode, Jr Robert Franken Friday Jennie Henderson Richard T. Henderson Glendale George T. Poor Richard A Henderson Charles F. Meier John Lehr John Nichols Charles F. Rockhill Anna Floyd Simeon M. Johnson August W. Wade, Jr Loraine Wade Robert Franken Raymond Lucas W. Cc. Mardorf Norman E. Petry Lula W. Petry W. C. ‘Mardorf Spicer & Dolle Eliza Romans John Romans Keller, Cornette & Cornette Ck OC Railway Co Procter & Gamble Co Waite Schindel Senate L. & B. Co Charles J. Meyers John BE. Fitzpartick Mamie Hearn David Hearn H. EB. Engelhardt Lucille Smyser

Divorces Granted for Cruelty and Neglect in Local Court

Helen Selbert and Walter Selbert divorced on cruelty. Anha Stevens received a divorce from George Stevens for gross neglect and cruelty. Florence Kitchkowsky won a divorce from Stephen Kitchkowsky for gross neglect. William Orendorf granted divorce from May Orendorf for willful absence. he is a soldier at Camp Lewis and spent over two years on the Mexican border. wife left him after marriage.

Helen Selbert Walter Selbert Anha Stevens George Stevens Florence Kitchkowsky Stephen Kitchkowsky William Orendorf May Orendorf Orendorf Camp Lewis Wash Sven

Hoffheimer Bros Disputes Whisky Contract Transfer

United States courts record the Hoffheimer Bros Company filing an answer to Atlas Wine and Liquor Company seeking damages over whisky supply. Hoffheimer argues the contract with Southern Wine and Liquor was nontransferable or canceled by mutual consent before any attempted assignment to Atlas, and asks for dismissal with costs.

Hoffheimer Bros. Company Atlas Wine and Liquor Company Southern Wine and Liquor Southern Company Atlas Company

First certificates granted to new citizens on Friday

The ceremony granted citizenship to Jacob Hollander of 645 Enright Street a Dutch born mechanical engineer Henry Pocras of 44 McMillan Street a student from England Nicholas Laboner of 1506 Race Street a worker from Hungary and Samuel Barach of 740 Richmond Street a Russian national.

Jacob Hollander Enright Street Netherlands Henryk Pocras McMillan Street England Nicholas Laboner Race Street Hungary Samuel Barach Richmond Street Russia

Taxi Driver Meyer Thaller Arraigned in Immorality Case

Meyer Thaller, a taxi driver, implicated in arrests at the Munro Hotel for alleged military regulation violations against morality, was arraigned before Commissioner Adler on Friday, pleaded not guilty, and was held for the grand jury after posting bail. Walter Wright, charged with abstracting cigars from a freight car at Sharon, was sent to jail in default of bail.

Meyer Thaller Munro Hotel Adler Walter Wright Sharon

Final Bankruptcy Filing for Michael J. Burns

Final returns for the bankruptcy of Michael J. Burns are announced, detailing the conclusion of proceedings for the individual debtor formerly in the business or personal affairs under Chapter proceeding. The notice confirms discharge actions and court docket references reflecting the closure of the case.

Michael J. Burns

Miami Cycle Company Appeals Over Patent Verdict Amount

The Miami Cycle and Manufacturing Company of Middletown filed an appeal in the Circuit Court of Appeals challenging a lower court judgment requiring payment of 10,648 dollars to Herbert Allen, holder of a patent for coaster brakes.

Miami Cycle and Manufacturing Company of Middletown Circuit Court of Appeals Herbert Allen

Common Pleas Court Divorce and Other Civil Actions

A list of cases from Common Pleas Court numbers 168,307 to 168,322 includes multiple divorce actions such as Jennie Henderson versus Richard Henderson and Minnie Barnes versus Eugene Barnes, plus several for alimony, liens for small sums, and foreclosures. Also noted is Court of Insolvency case No. 9,205 seeking a writ of habeas corpus for Lucille Smyser.

Patrolmen Transfers Announced By City Police Chief

Chief of Police William Copelan Friday announced patrolman transfers among districts and stations in Carthage. Officers Joseph Hooman Louis Candenberger Sebastian Dehner and Charles Beckman move to Special Station 8 Carthage. Others Thomas J. Hurst Enoch Robbins Louis Monke Clinton Noe shift between Special Station 8 Carthage and Districts 1 4 5 and 7 respectively. Robert Donnersperg moved from District 10 to foot, Stanley P. Grouse from foot to mounted in District 10, Walter B. Stewart from District 7 to District 2 mounted to foot, Albert Wolsefer from District 2 to District 7 foot to mounted, Harry Kline from District 2 to patrol service, H L Jones from District 8 to District 2.

William Copelan Joseph Hooman Louis Candenberger Sebastian Dehner Charles Beckman Carthage Thomas J. Hurst Enoch Robbins Louis Monke Clinton Noe Robert Donnersperg Stanley P. Grouse Foot Walter B. Stewart Mounted Albert Wolsefer Harry Kline H. L. Jones

Improvement bids for Eastern avenue blocked again

Service Director Charles I. Hornberger reported bids for Eastern avenue improvement were higher than estimates. This marks the second rejection in six months due to freight-rate driven cost increases, Councilman Kellog noted the prior rejection stemmed from a 17 cent per foot rise.

Eastern Avenue Charles I. Hornberger Kellog

County Board Takes Step to End Red Bank Crossing

The county commissioners passed a resolution urging the County Surveyor to submit cost estimates for removing the Red Bank crossing. The Prosecuting Attorney advised an opinion was unnecessary, noting work would likely proceed by agreement among the railroad city and county.

Red Bank Crossing Board of County Commissioners

Retrenchment hits City Departments with layoffs

The retrenchment effort cut jobs at the Department of Public Property on Friday. Superintendent Jacop F. Eyrich laid off six workers including market masters William Dentner and Hyman Phillips, janitresses Kate Eggleston and Mary Deeds, City Hall janitor Michael Glenn, and elevator operator Archie Harden, aiming to save 2700 for the rest of the year. Clerk C. E. Woods of Water Works was moved from distribution to administration with pay rising from 80 to 90 dollars monthly.

Department of Public Property Jacop F. Eyrich William Dentner Hyman Phillips Kate Eggleston Mary Deeds City Hall Michael Glenn Archie Harden C. E. Woods Water Works Department

Rev. Austin Schmidt Joins College Faculty

Rev. Austin Schmidt S. J. of St. Louis University is added to the faculty and will start duties in the summer school held in the parochial school building.

Austin Schmidt S. J St. Louis University

Real Estate Judges Presidents' Achievement Contest at St Louis

Dale Ebersole of the Cincinnati Real Estate Exchange is named judge for the Presidents' achievement contest at the National Convention of Real Estate Boards in St Louis from June 17 to 20. W W Clippinger sold a five room bungalow on Ward street Madisonville for 3000 to Carl M Beaner who will occupy it. Gordon E Small bought R J Faussett's property at 2127 Slane Avenue Norwood for 10000 and will move from Kennedy Heights.

Dale Ebersole Cincinnati Real Estate Exchange St. Louis W. W. Clippinger W. H. Settle Carl M. Beaner Ward Street Madisonville Gordon E. Small R. J. Faussett Slane Avenue Norwood Mr. Small Kennedy Heights

Police Hint Clue to Clark Murder in Cincinnati Case

Cincinnati detectives doubt Ted Clark, allied with bank robbers Mackeon and Sidler, was ever in the city. The trio claimed Clark joined the job and got 1700 dollars, fueling tensions. After the Madison bank robbery they went to Chicago, then Clark fled to St Louis where plans for revenge were formed. Clark’s body was buried at Creve Coeur, Mrs Clark denying it was her husband.

Cincinnati Ted Clark Alexander Mackeon Gus Sidler Adams Tricity Bank Madison Ill Missouri River Mackeon Sidler Clark Love Chicago Edwards Margaret Edwards Creve Coeur

Minton’s forged decree leads to workhouse sentence

Proba tion Officer Follmer exposed a forged annulment supposed from Judge Otto Wolff of Campbell County Ky. William Minton confessed paying an attorney for the bogus decree dated April 24 1918. Minton received three months in the Workhouse and a Covington grand jury indictment is expected.

Clifford W. Follmer Domestic Relations Court William Minton Minton Otto Wolff Common Pleas Court Campbell County Follmer Newport Wolff W. Scott Robinson Covington Commonwealth Stephens L. Blakely

Political Camps Join To Sell Certificates In Cincinnati

R. K. Hynicka and Thomas J. Noc tor of Cincinnati Republicans and Democrats arrange with Alfred G. Allen of the Hamilton County War Savings Stamp Committee for a Political Campaign Drive selling Thrift Stamps and War Savings Certificates starting next Monday for one week. Ward workers from both parties lead the effort. A second drive, School Sammy Million Week, will be run by school children. National War Savings Week closes the month, with June 28 designated National War Savings Day by presidential proclamation.

R. K. Hynicka Thomas J. Noctor Cincinnati Alfred G. Allen Hamilton County War Savings Stamp Committee National War Savings Week

Rush for Government Service Jobs Grows After Work or Fight Order

Civilian Personnel Section of the Ordnance Department reports over 100 inquiries on Friday. Jobs range from clerks to senior engineers and master chemists. More than 500 men have registered this week, with 600 expected by Saturday. An urgent need is a clerk-bookkeeper with some typewriting knowledge for a local Ordnance section.

Ordnance Department Chamber of Commerce Ordnance Office

Road Improvement Bid Tally for County No 43

Bids opened Friday by the County Commissioners for inter county road No 43 show Granite paving bids from Henkel and Sullivan at 80888 30, Kirchner Construction 83721 50, Warrenite Henkel and Sullivan 54963 90, Kirchner 56469 20 and asphaltic bids from Henkel and Sullivan at 55508 80.

Intercounty Road Henkel & Sullivan Kirchner Construction Company Warrenite Kirchner

Library cuts Hearst papers from files

Librarian N C D Hodges ordered on Friday that subscriptions to The New York American and Chicago Herald and Examiner be discontinued and the papers removed from library files. Both publications are Hearst owned.

N. C. D. Hodges The Public Library New York American Chicago Herald and Examiner Hearst Publications

Heatwave Grips Cincinnati Delights City as Thermometer Rises

Heat swept Cincinnati on Friday with the Weather Observatory at Clifton recording 90 degrees while downtown hit 92. Officials note it is not the all time May high, capped at 95 degrees on May 27, 1911. Forecasters expect the trend to persist through Sunday.

Companion boat America to join Queen City on Ohio River

The Indiana steamboat, newly renamed America, will debut next week as the Queen City’s companion on the Ohio River. It will sail from Cincinnati to Louisville on alternate evenings starting at 5 p.m., with refurnished cabins and plans to revive river trade. Louisville reports high interest as freight from Cincinnati increases, benefiting farm and dairy shipments and boosting river towns on both sides of the river.

Indiana America Ohio River Cincinnati Louisville Queen City

Big Pythian Outing at Coney Saturday

Hamilton County Pythian Association holds its annual outing at Coney with seven temples of Pythian. Athletic judges include Frederick L. Hoffman Charles W. Schneider and Ralph F. Tingle. Committee in charge features Rolla L. Shhickner Charles W. Schneider J W Keeler Joseph H. Biecker and Louis Weiland.

Hamilton County Pythian Association Coney Seven Temples of Pythian Frederick L. Hoffman Charles W. Schneider Ralph F. Tingle Rolla l L. Shhickner J. W. Keeler Joseph H. Biecker Louis Weiland

Cincinnati Educator Called to Detroit

Dr. William B. Wherry professor of bacteriology at the University of Cincinnati accepts leadership of the Detroit School of Medicine now part of Detroit's educational system. Former Manila government pathologist, Wherry is noted for notable bacteriology work and for experiments yielding record numbers of bacteria.

William B. Wherry University of Cincinnati Detroit School

Do Your Shopping Early Is Appeal Of Retailers

Cincinnati merchants warn of help shortages once the work or fight order takes full effect. The Retail Stores Association urges early adjustment of conditions, distributing an appeal to encourage weekday and morning shopping to ease the transition.

Cincinnati Retail Stores Association of the Chamber of Commerce Order of Things

Soldiers and Sailors Club Welcomes Thousands in Cincinnati

Ten thousand members of Uncle Sam's fighting force have visited the Soldiers and Sailors' Club in the Burnet House since its opening two months ago. C. J. Peebles said troops from across the country have written praising Cincinnati hospitality. On Decoration Day the club served 500 men passing through the city and issued 250 passes for park visits.

Uncle Sam Soldiers Burnet House C. J. Peebles Cincinnati

Cottage Cheese Advocate in Cincinnati Promotes Cheaper Dairy

Jesse W. Cobb, a cheese specialist with the United States Department of Agriculture, travels to Cincinnati to urge more cottage cheese consumption. He claims skim milk waste would decrease, noting one pound of cottage cheese has as much food value as a pound of beef.

Jesse W. Cobb United States Department of Agriculture Cincinnati

Four Chester Park Outings Planned by Local Groups

The South Mt. Auburn Welfare Association and allied groups including the Hot Corn Club of the Twenty-fifth Ward Lincoln Court No 20 Guardians of Liberty and Harry C Egbert Camp No 1 United Spanish War Veterans will hold outings at Chester Park on Saturday.

South

Jobbers Told to Follow Food Administration Rules

Three flour jobbers were summoned to the Hamilton County Food Administration office on Friday and warned that noncompliance would suspend their business for ten days. The trio agreed to improve and adhere to all regulations.

Hamilton County Food Administration The Food Administration

Cincinnati street car workers to wear jumpers Saturday

Motormen and conductors on Cincinnati street cars will don new uniforms this Saturday, replacing the heavy blue cloth with jumpers. The change was scheduled weeks ago but procurement delays postponed adoption.

Cincinnati

mural decorations planned for Cincinnati courthouse history episodes

Artists and a citizen committee met at the Chamber of Commerce on Friday to submit plans for mural decorations at the new Courthouse. The planned series will depict Cincinnati history and will be submitted to the Courthouse Commissioners.

The Chamber of Commerce Cincinnati

Mayor Galvin to Seek Council Action on Fund Transfer

Anticipating a favorable Common Pleas verdict, Mayor Galvin will call a Saturday morning council meeting to pass an ordinance transferring about $200,000 from the general park and health funds to the safety fund. The money will pay police and fire salaries.

Court of Common Pleas General Galvin

Library War Fund Aid Report Details From Cincinnati Librarian

N D C Hodges of the Cincinnati Library reports the Library War Fund raised 1 700 000 by Americans has served 464 camps stations and vessels erected 36 library buildings for soldiers and sailors placed 117 librarians in the field distributed five million magazines sent 1 349 000 gift books to camps and stations 109 403 selected books overseas and purchased 300 000 largely technical books.

N. D. C. Hodges Cincinnati Library War Fund

Club bulletins close season with varied meetings

Woman's Press Club ends its season with a 2 o'clock program at Library Club rooms East Eighth street. Three Aras Club hosts a 3 p.m. reception for newly elected officers at Mrs. Albert H Morrill’s home. Surgical dressings continue at clubhouse gatherings. Saturday Literary Club wraps with an outing at Miss Elwinna Stewart’s College Hill home. Christ Child Free Day Nursery opens at upper Race street.

Woman's Press Club Library Club East Eighth Street Three Aras Club Albert H. Morrill Christ Child Free Day Nursery Upper Race Street

Norwood Art Club Plans All Day City Hall Meeting

The Norwood Art Club will hold an all day meeting at City Hall next Monday to elect officers for the coming year. The program includes entertainment features while Red Cross work proceeds. Mrs Ernst Nichols hosts, assisted by Mrs J E Thorp.

Norwood Art Club City Hall Red Cross Ernst Nichols J. E. Thorp

Richters Held for Harboring Fugitives Bond Set

Kirk Richter and his wife Clara faced charges of harboring James Lawler who evaded capture and hid at 613 Glenwood Avenue Avondale. Judge Spiegel bound them over to the grand jury with bonds of 1000 dollars each.

Kirk Richter Clara James Lawler Glenwood Avenue Avondale Spiegel

Knights of Columbus Members Depart Cincinnati for Washington

During the past week 125 members of the Knights of Columbus have left Cincinnati for Washington. Members are being rushed abroad as rapidly as possible, contingents numbering from fifteen to twenty five men being sent over on every regular steamer leaving the American ports.

Knights of Columbus Cincinnati Washington Order

Free Rides Postponed By City Council Committee

The Committee on Law Contracts and Claims Friday postponed action on the ordinance by Councilman Sheehan that would allow men in military service to ride free on street cars, delaying consideration of the measure.

Sheehan

Also Mentioned on This Page

Ilner West Sixth Street Court News Coal Company Criminal Court Notes Sues Mother Gray Paul V. Connolly Auto Antiskid Brake Company United States Courts Hearst Weather Observatory Clifton City Business Center Wurlitzer Victrola Records Victrola Joseph Achron Paderewski Ignace Ang Ag Dance Records Chopin Original McKee’s Felicia Waltz Sergeant Markels Henry Burr Campbell and Burr Charles Hart Elizabeth Spencer William J. (“Sailor”) Reilly William J. (“Sailor Reilly Wright Dietrich Peerless Massenet Lafayette Freedom Reinald Werrenrath Harry Lauder Victor Light Opera Company Rudolph Wurlitzer Co East Fourth Street Detroit Motion Picture Houses Style No Cottage Cheese Advocate Chester Park Library Fund the Kaiser Beast of Berlin Helen Ware Swanixe Nowance Cleopatra Siren of the Nile Albert Sandbrink Monmouth Street Sandbrink Mary Pickford Em 'Liss William S. Hart Constance Talmadge Orphbebum Sky Burton Holmes Harold Lloyd New York Liverpool Falmouth London Bristol Great Britain Ireland Scandinavia Italy France Portugal Spain Switzerland N. Y Chichester
Search Courier

Search the Cincinnati Commercial Tribune Today with a Free Trial

We want people to find what they are looking for at NewspaperArchive. We are confident that we have the newspapers that will increase the value of your family history or other historical research. With our 7-day free trial, you can view the documents you find for free.

Not Finding What You Were Looking for on This Page of The Cincinnati Commercial Tribune?

People find the most success using advanced search. Try plugging in keywords, names, dates, and locations, and get matched with results from the entire collection of newspapers at NewspaperArchive!

Looking Courier

Browse Newspapers

You can also successfully find newspapers by these browse options. Explore our archives on your own!

By Location

By Location

Browse by location and discover newspapers from all across the world.

Browse by Location
By Date

By Date

Browse by date and find publications for a specific day or era.

Browse by Date
By Publication

By Publication

Browse old newspaper publications to find specific newspapers.

Browse by Publication