Boston's Trimmer Controversy Recasts Fitzgerald Race
In 1907 Boston voters labeled John F. Fitzgerald a trimmer for breaking promises to gain votes. A modern renewed campaign repeats the charge as Fitzgerald seeks re election. Denis McCarthy named the voter as the real trimmer, urging readers to choose between Fitzgerald and James J. Storrow.
Has Fooled the Public Editorial Target in Boston
Nicholas Spitz from 18 Howard Street faults John F. Fitzgerald for promising a bigger and better Boston yet failing to deliver ahead of another election. Spitz questions whether Fitzgerald will keep his promises if re elected.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Boston American
John F. Fitzgerald
Boston
Nicholas Spitz
Howard Street
Real Trimmer Contest Winner Names the Voter
Denis McCarthy of Charlestown won ten dollars for the best answer to who is the real trimmer. He argues the voter who votes for a politician who breaks promises is the real trimmer, and vows not to support Fitzgerald again. McCarthy, a railroad car inspector, is married with three children and a registered voter in precinct 5, Ward 5.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Denis McCarthy
Boston & Maine Railroad
Devens Street
Charlestown
Fitzgerald
Boston American
McCarthy
Public Reaction Labels Fitzgerald the Trimmer in 1907 Letter Stretch
Readers of the Boston American respond to a November 12 1907 cartoon asking "Who Is This Trimmer" by naming Mayor John F Fitzgerald as the hand holding shears. Letters accuse him of promises broken graft double dealings and political opportunism with addresses across Dorchester Roxbury Allston and South Boston.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Fitzgerald
John F. Fitzgerald
Boston American
The
Boston
Hand With the
City Hall
Temple of Promises
Conest
John. J. Shea
Dorchester Avenue
J. W. Perry
Eaton Street
Rena M’kinney
Everett Street
Allston
Boston America
Vernon Street
Sasbark
Kent
Campagn
Johnnie Fite
John F. Grant
Stoughton Street
Dorchester
Lauriat Avenue
Cornelius J. Desmond
Cits
Fitz
George W. Harrison
Schuyler Street
Roxbury
John F. Fitz
That bigger, better, busier Boston be beaten
A local letter from South Boston attacks Mayor Fitzgerald citing broken promises and calls for action on election day to stop what the writer deems bunco style politicking. The missive mocks promises and urges voters to reject a busier Boston image.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
B’s
Boston American
Fitzgerald
Boston
Bunco
Joseph J. Bayers
Wighth Street
South
Trimmer at the polls spotlighted in Boston opinion
The letter commends the American for a prize cartoon that invites voters to express views of the mayoral candidate known as the trimmer. It urges the people to trim the trimmer at the polls, praising the paper for letting public opinion speak.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Boston American
Boston
Voice of the People
Journal Building
See the Point I Find the Scissors in Fitzgeralds Hand
A fragment notes a confrontation with the line See the point and a claim about scissors in Fitzgeralds hand. The text cites JOHN H. MEHAN of 861 Columbus Avenue as an owner or witness reference.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Boston American
Fitzgerald
John H. Mehan
Columbus Avenue
Gibs and graft in Roxbury letter to voters
A letter from George W. Harrison of Roxbury and John J. Reagan of South Boston accuses Mayor Fitzgerald of broken reform promises and graft. They urge voters to rebuke the boss at the December 12 ballot by protesting the mayor’s support roles and school committee actions.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Boston American
Fitzgerald
John J. Reagan
Baxter Street
South
Boston
Cartoon targets FitzGerald with broken promises
A letter from Samuel Rafflowich of 100 Kingston Street accuses John F. Fitzgerald of breaking promises and failing to fulfill his mayoral pledges. The note claims Fitzgerald has trimmed promises away, likening his actions to a political hand using shears and foresees a Waterloo at city elections.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Waterloo
Boston American
Boston
John F. Fitzgerald
Samuel Rafflowich
Kingston Street
Trimmer Must Step Down in Boston Town
The poem vows that the trimmer John F. Fits will resign from office as mayor of Boston town. H A Saunders of 52 Worcester Street signs the piece, claiming a failing official who betrayed voters and promised nothing, with next month’s ballots expected to end his term.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
John F. Fits
Boston Town
H. A. Saunders
Worcester Street
Trimmer accusations target Fitzgerald by Moran topic
Arnold Goldberg of Roxbury accuses John F Fitzgerald of breaking a clean administration pledge and of dishonorable conduct after an election. He questions trust in Fitzgerald and claims Moran was promised relief before and after the vote, urging scrutiny of political integrity.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Fitzgerald
Boston American
John IF. Fitzgerald
John B. Moran
Arnold Goldberg
Elbert Street
Roxbury
Voter Is the Trimmer in Boston Says Kelley
The statement declares the Boston voter as the trimmer using political promises as a gamble. It cites M. M. Kelley of 1140 Columbus Avenue Roxbury Crossing as the author of the remark railing against voters who support unkeepable pledges.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Boston American
Boston
M. M. Kelley
Columbus Avenue
Roxbury Crossing
Also Mentioned on This Page
Himself
James J. Storrow
Stone American
ST A Ie
RomisEs
Fay
Kledge
Boston Week
Devens
Mr. McCarthy
Patrick A. Cottor
Highland Street
Moran
Fitzgerald’s
Boston Amicrican
John B. Fitzgerald
Daniel F. Moore
Harvard Street
Charles Murphy
South Boston
John F._ Fitz-G
Telat Counihan
Dorrance Street
Trimmer
Storrow
Michael C. O'Neill
Franklin St. Allstein