Academic Freedom Question in College Debate
A BULLETIN column prints four Barnard and Columbia faculty responses to President Millicent C. McIntosh on academic freedom amid concerns about Communists in colleges. John Smertenko argues for tolerance and open inquiry, contending democracy and logic defeat extremism. he asserts competent Communist teachers can be endured and refuted through teaching. He warns against witch hunts and censorship.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Bulletin
Millicent C. McIntosh
Barnard and
Columbia
McIntosh
Komarovsky on Academic Freedom and Communist Party
Mirra Komarovsky argues against firing professors solely for party membership while noting the impossibility of perfect screening. She cites complex motives, Fifth Amendment refusals, and warns about congressional investigations yet sees hopeful signs from college faculties managing risks.
The Sole Criterion for College Teaching Quality
A discussion concludes that the main danger of Communism in education is not sufficient to threaten academic freedom. Competence remains the sole criterion for who may teach, judged by school administrations based on dedication to scholarship, subject mastery, and belief in knowledge. Outside affiliations matter only if they affect performance and vary by institution.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Communist Party
Rutgers University
Sargent discusses academic freedom and Fifth Amendment issue
Associate Professor S Stansfeld Sargent of Barnard comments on Mrs McIntosh reply and argues questions should focus on whether a college faculty member can be fired for invoking the Fifth Amendment and refusing to answer about Communist Party membership.
College faculty questions on party membership and the Fifth Amendment
The note records three questions about whether college faculty should be compelled to reveal party membership and whether the Fifth Amendment justifies refusing to answer. The items explore compliance with potential inquiries into political associations.
Hanna Epiorts Note on Academic Freedom and Communists
John Hanna of Columbia University argues that McIntosh's replies to academic freedom are sound and support integrity. He opposes congressional investigations into alleged university communism as unnecessary while praising the dignity of current inquiries. He contends Communist discipline threats justify limiting Communist faculty on campuses.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
McIntosh
Bulletin
Congress
Also Mentioned on This Page
Academic
Smertenko
America
Spinoza
Russia
Komarovsky
Mirra Komarovsky
Barnard
Chafee
United Front
Rutgers
Lewis Webster Jones
Academic Freedom
Civc Responsibility
Jones
Sargent
S. Stansfeld Sargent
Ephor
Hanna
Epiot
John Hanna
Columbia University