Barnard Dorm Honor System Sparks Debate in Student Body
The Residence Halls Executive Committee proposes removing automatic penalties for dorm rule infringements, replacing them with a personal honor standard. BULLETIN supports an honor system with a formal board and self reporting, warns this plan may not achieve true accountability or a fair appeals process.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Bulletin
Barnard
Residence Halls
Residence Halls Association
Executive Committee
Court of Appeals
Plan to revise dorm penalties faces student input
Letters to the Editor discuss the Residence Halls Students Association proposal to abolish automatic penalties for infractions on a trial basis. Exec outlines steps for signed returns, explanations, and review by the committee to decide penalties, emphasizing individual responsibility and reduced punishment for persistent lateness.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Exec
Dorm Dormitory Penalty Change Sparks Student Debate
In Brooks and Hewitt Halls students will vote on a proposal to overhaul lateness penalties. The author argues against shifting from individual to jury style decisions and warns it could erode personal responsibility and predictable rules.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Brooks and Hewitt
Executive Committee
Objections to the dorm penalties system
The writer argues the proposed penalties do not advance an honor system. Rules remain. the front desk watches arrival. execs decide cases without clear procedures. They trust the committee but warn against subjectivity without known law and due process.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Exec
St. Thomas Aquinas
Also Mentioned on This Page
Barnard College
New York
N. Y
Geraldine Kirshenbaum
Mona Cowen
Judy Kaufman
Barbara Lyons
Residence Halls Students Association
The
Exec Committee
Executive Council
This is just the beginning! Our collection holds over 300 years of history, including rare newspapers, obituaries, marriage records, birth records, and so much more—most of which you won’t find anywhere else!