Judge Harper's view on sovereignty in the U S Constitution
Judge Harper argues that sovereignty rests with the people and the states, not a single national sovereign. He explains that the amendment process shows state sovereignty, compares confederacies, and cites German and Swiss examples to support a preserved state role within a federal framework. He questions a consolidated sovereignty and warns that three fourths approval still binds a state by its own act.
Limitations of State Sovereignty in a Federal Republic
A historical examination argues that a state could not be forced to accept a new constitution by a convention or external force, since the United States rests on a federal union with republican guarantees. Treason remains an offense against the United States, not merely a state, and sovereignty lies in the union, not individual states.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Savannah
Sovereignty and allegiance in secession era debate
A legal argument on state sovereignty vs federal authority in secession. The speaker challenges the idea that states retain full sovereignty after joining the union, discusses allegiance of citizens to state and federal governments, and cautions that a convention’s authority derives from the people not the body itself. The text probes constitutional limits and implications for obedience to federal laws during purported state disaffection.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Virginia
New York
Courts of Justice
United States
Confederacy
Union
Sam
Columbia
Also Mentioned on This Page
The
Columbia Telescope
Harper’s
Howe
Itas
Appenzil
Congress of the
Europe
Maria Theresa
England
France
Spain
States of Holland
District of Columbia
Congress
United Stats
B. Clarke
Dr. Wrays
Wotice
Clarkson & Barrerr
L. Hui
E. H. Bari
Ine
Nacoochee Valley
Habersham County
BENJ
Cleveland
Bank of Chattahoochee
C. Squire
Rogers
Broad -Street
Athens
Clarkesville
Madison Springs
Carnesville
Naucoochee
Helicon Springs
Thomas King
Augusta
Free Trade
Basil Lamar
G. B. Lamar
Barnwell
S.C
Betsey
H. Par
Janis
Inferior Court
Columbia County
Campbellton
Campbell County
Coweta
James H. Sirs
R. HW. Woolfolk
Guardian
Paris
Charleston
E S.C
John C. Holcoy
Frazer & Co's
South Carolin
William 8
Dewar
Messrs
McKenzie & Bennoch
Paul Fitzsimone
Thomas McGraw
Prescott & B
Blodget
Fleming
Merry
T.A. H. Gregoria
Allens & Paddoc
Wan
T. H. H. Greg
Charleston Fire Marine Insurance Pany
G. H
Votice
Theflice
Grance M. Waxken
Jacob C. Bugg
City of
Intosh Street
Broad Street
Hs Care
James Tanal
Richmond Ce
Clarksville
Edward Harden
Thos
Jefferson Rus
Louisville
Jefferson County
Alfre
Robert Garvin
Ashley Philips
Burke County
Dee