Thaw Trial Focus on Paranoia and Lunacy Commission
Washington Post special report on New York Thaw trial shows Dr Evans under cross examination as District Attorney Jerome pushes for admission of paranoia and a possible lunacy commission. The judge critiques the length and pace while Thaw’s actions and Evalyn Nesbit shift attention.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Washington Post
New York
Britton D. Evana
Jerome
Evana
Thaw
Stanford White
Madison Square Root Garden
Dr. Evans
Bvana
Thaw’s courtroom drill and letter test in Jerome case
Thaw performed a five minute drill in his cell then returned to court claiming he was compelled to exercise. He read nine letters with Dr Evans noting varying mental instability and possible insanity, while Jerome pressed questions about the defendant’s mental state and delusions in relation to the letters.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Thaw
Dr. Evang
Jerome
Allest
Mr. Jerome
Dr. Evans
Tonks
Mr Jerome
Mr. Jerome Namea
Anthony Comstock
Stanford White
Satness
Evans
Jetter
Thaw Mental State Questioned After New Letters
In court opening, District Attorney Jerome revealed a second batch of letters from J D Lyon, former custodian of Thaw's will, written during Thaw’s Tombs confinement and dated after June 25 last. Dr Britten Evans was recalled as Jerome continued cross examination of the alienist.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Jerome
J.D. Lyon
Pittsburg
Thaw
Lyon
Britten D Evans
Mr Jerome
Delmas
Mania and Memory during the Thaw letters trial
The dialogue questions whether the writer of letters in 1903 suffered acute mania or melancholia and whether such madness affected sanity. Dr. remarks on transient insanity linked to strain and adolescence during Thaw’s marriage in 1905, noting memory gaps and uncertain duration of inanity.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Mr. Jerome
Jerome
Witness Dr Evans Testifies on Adolescent Insanity in White Case
In a cross examination the doctor testified that the killer showed explosive adolescent insanity with acute outbreaks. He stated possible lucid intervals, and noted three definite outbreaks tied to 1903 letters and the 1906 tragedy, with a chance of additional episodes.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Mr. Jerome
Fasme
Stanford White
Dr. Venn
Evans
Jerome
Hvans Isald
Dr. Evans
Branford White
Thaw Mental Explosions Under Probe by District Attorney
Dr. Evans testified that Thaw exhibited varying mental episodes including melancholy and an explosive rooftop outburst at Madison Square Garden. The expert said the events did not prove paranoia and showed different forms of insanity rather than a single condition.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Jerome
Evans
Highife
Madison Square Roof Garden
Excht
Fitzgerald
Branford White
Pittsburg
Stanford White
Mr. Jerome
Thaw insanity testimony focuses on brain storm concept
Dr. Evans and Mr. Jerome clash over Thaw mental state and the brain storm theory. They discuss paranoia versus adolescent insanity, the will, and whether Thaw understood the lethality of a revolver, with doctors noting possible delusion and moments of calm during agitation.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Dr. Bryans
Mr. Jerome
Detmas
Dr. Evans
Hugo
Mr Jerome
Stanford White
Evang
Paranoia and expert testimony in a courtroom crossfire
Jerome questions witnesses about brain storms and paranoia defeatism. The judge blocks outside authorities while references to Hamilton and Preusser echo in a tense exchange. The session adjourns to Monday at 10:30.
Evelyn Nesbit Thaw Cross Examination Stirs Debate
New York dispatch covers Evelyn Nesbit Thaw’s cross examination in the Stanford White case. Public view split on whether DA Jerome is probing truthfulness or undermining Nesbit’s credibility and sanity. The trial centers on Thaw’s sanity at the time of the shooting, with both sides arguing insanity or sanity and Nesbit’s testimony under intense pressure.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Mennen
New York
Philadelphia Press
Jerome
Evelyn Nesbit Thaw
Evelyn Thaw
Stanford White
Evelyn Nesbit
Trias
Thaw
Tme
White
Than
Also Mentioned on This Page
Allan McLane Hamilton
Hamilton
Morris Plains
N. J
Harry Thaw
Miz. Jerome Als
Justice Mitzgereld
Evalyn Nesbit
SPA Pri
Foeman
Hotel Belmont
Brition D. Evans
Bown
Hood
Witn
Bettie Colgate
Didier
Lansburgh & Bro
Seventh Street
Washington
Peter Grogan
Hani I
Danjie Rickids
McFarland-Richardson
Hanson
McFarland
Sickles
Deknas
Grant
Hyans
Justice Fitzgerald
Macdonald
Mabon
Prousser
Preusser
Evelyn
Fe Defense
Mr. Jeroma
Evelyn Nesbittel
March
Columbia Phonograph Co
F Street
Philadelphia
ST. Louis
Mooory Noraes American Security and Trust Company
Mostawest Cornea
1ENTH
Pernetevana Avenue
Washington, B. C
Masgruder’s Conn. Ave
K Si. Wholesale Ox? Retail
Randle Highlands
U.S
Serene
Randie Highlands
Capitol
Dupont Circle
Lgts
Villa Alies
Realty Company
Ul 7Th St
Ave & Paave
Firemen’s Insurance Building
West End
Pa. Ave. N. W
Yarme
Dalry, Co
Burchell’s
Christian Xander
St. Phong
This is just the beginning! Our collection holds over 300 years of history, including rare newspapers, obituaries, marriage records, birth records, and so much more—most of which you won’t find anywhere else!