Letters From Sheriffs Support Local Option Over Statewide Prohibition
A collection of letters from Tennessee and Georgia sheriffs argues that local option laws were better enforced and more effective than statewide prohibition. They claim local measures reflected public will, and statewide rules reduced local compliance, arrests, and public order.
Local option dry, statewide prohibition worsens Calhoun
Sheriff L H Davis of Calhoun County reports dry under local option but very wet under statewide prohibition. He notes higher drunkenness, especially among youths under 21, and says arrests are largely alcohol related. He argues statewide ban fails to improve conditions and is hard to enforce.
Heard County Sheriff H L Taylor Comments on Public Mood
Heard County Sheriff H L Taylor reports the public is split, with some better and some worse overall. He notes no clear shift in sentiment, saying responses are about half and half.
Sheriff Criticizes Statewide Prohibition Enforcement
Cobb County Sheriff states that statewide prohibition worsens conditions in the county and is less popular than local option. He notes enforcement is harder than local law and reports many arrests for drunkenness.
Prohibition Failure Cited by Lee County Sheriff
Lee County Sheriff S. B. Smith argues statewide prohibition worsens crime and public aid to enforce laws is lacking. He claims more homicides occur since statewide prohibition and asserts local option was better.
Local Prohibition Critique by Hancock County Sheriff
Hancock County Sheriff T. B. High Tower argues statewide prohibition worsens conditions in the county, asserting the law is unpopular and hard to enforce. he notes occasional increases in arrests though he cannot confirm overall trends.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Hancock County
T. B. High Tower
Saloons and liquor dealers in Nashville before and after Prohibition
In Nashville the number of saloons before Prohibition was 168, all outside residence districts. After Prohibition, liquor dealers rose to 580, with many operating beer dives within residence districts.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Nashville
Prisoner Counts by Year Through May 13 1911
Records show 79 cases jailed in 1902 and 89 in 1910 with 42 prisoners detained up to May 13 1911. The figures reflect ongoing incarceration totals in the yearly summaries.
County Sheriff Criticizes Statewide Prohibition
Gray County Sheriff C. E. Roberts says statewide prohibition is a failure in the county and hard to enforce, citing numerous blind tigers and unpopularity with the people.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Gray County
C. E. Roberts
Local option urged over statewide prohibition in Walker County
Sheriff A. C. Xatron argues against statewide prohibition as unenforceable and harmful. He cites bootlegging, low quality whiskey, and rising crime in Georgia and other cities, advocating local option where communities vote to tailor laws to local conditions.
Local option and high license urged to curb liquor evil
Morgan County Sheriff R B Aycock denounces alcohol crime, arguing drunkenness and murders rise where liquor is sold. He says near beer saloons and open sale in larger towns fuel crime, especially among Black residents, and urges local option or high license as a solution. He cites lack of police protection in rural areas leading to violence.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Augusta
Prohibition Criticisms Highlight Sheriff Notes
Warren County sheriff W. O. Brink Y criticizes statewide prohibition. He says whiskey is shipped into his county from Georgia despite laws. He argues prohibition is failing and not suitable for his county.
Unpopular statewide prohibition faces enforcement issues
The county notes the statewide law is not improving conditions and faces strong public opposition. It reports no drop in crimes or drunkenness since adoption, with two-thirds of arrests attributed to alcohol.
Laurens County Sheriff Criticizes Prohibition Impact
Laurens County Sheriff J. J. Flanlus argues that statewide prohibition has not reduced crime or drunkenness in Laurens County, where local option laws had been in effect for years. he says enforcement is harder and public support favors local control.
Prohibition Critique From Habersham County Sheriff
The Habersham County Sheriff argues statewide prohibition fails to improve local conditions. He says enforcement is harder, crime and drunkenness do not decline, and arrests are numerous though he cannot specify the count. He supports prohibition only when it bans liquor outright.
Local option law critique from Montgomery County sheriff
James Hester, sheriff of Montgomery County, argues the statewide prohibition law fails to improve conditions. He contends it is less popular than the local option and harder to enforce with no decline in arrests or drunkenness.
Statewide prohibition harsher than local option, says sheriff
Sheriff W. H. Ellis of Jeff Davis County notes more drunkenness and arrests under statewide prohibition than when local option was in force. He cites illegal whiskey sales at saw mills and turpentine stills and says enforcement has become harder since statewide law.
Local option law fails to curb crime says J H Ward
Crisp County official J H Ward argues statewide temperance law does not improve condition in the county. He cites persistent crimes and drunkenness and reports many arrests for whiskey related offenses, claiming local option would work better locally.
Prohibition Law Criticizes Statewide Liquor Policy
Sheriff E D Branch of Tift County argues against statewide prohibition noting millions of dollars leave the state for liquor and costs of crimes go unfunded. He says local option was better and enforcement is weak, with drunkenness rising in his county.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Georgia
Douglas County Sheriff Commentary on Prohibition Enforcement
Douglas County Sheriff David Ritksen notes two thirds of arrests relate to drinking conditions under the statewide prohibition law, stating no local option exists but current conditions are unsatisfactory and enforcement is very hard.
Drunkenness Evident Despite Whiskey Sales
The report notes that about two thirds of arrests are caused by drink and states there is just as much drunkenness now as when whiskey was sold in the area.
Prohibition Debate: Statewide Law vs Local Option
Local officials weigh the impact of statewide prohibition against local option. Officials argue whiskey sales remain high under statewide law and question its benefit to the county compared with local option. The Sheriff and McDuffie appear among those commenting on enforcement and consumption.
Sheriff criticizes statewide prohibition impact on Georgia
Charlton County Sheriff W Mizell voices opposition to statewide prohibition citing loss of revenue as money flows from Georgia to Florida for whiskey, arguing the state earns nothing while liquor traffic continues.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Georgia
Florida
Union County Sheriff Race Prompts Discussion of Prohibition
In Union County McTarvey criticizes statewide prohibitions as not improving local conditions and questions popular support versus option. He weighs public opinion on the issue amid county concerns.
Liberty County Sheriff Endorses Local Option View
Liberty County Sheriff J. D. Staf Ford states prohibition is less favorable than local option in Liberty County. The comment reflects county preferences on liquor regulation.
Jail limits fail bootleggers in Randolph County era
Randolph County officials led by Sheriff W. S. Mat Tox condemn statewide prohibition as ineffective. Courts and penalties fail to curb illegal liquor sales, with bootleggers continuing operations despite fines and imprisonment in Randolph and neighboring counties.
Prohibition Law Struggles in Towns County
Sheriff Ed Wood reports no improvement under the prohibition law in Towns County and notes it is unpopular compared to the local option. He cites about fifty arrests for drunkenness in the past year.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Towns County
P. Wood
Prohibition Law Criticized In Taylor County Sheriff Report
The Taylor County sheriff condemns the statewide prohibition as hard to enforce and unchanged in crime or drunkenness. He notes arrests mainly stem from intoxication and argues the local option law is more popular locally.
Crawford County in Tough Grip of Prohibition
Conditions in Crawford County remain unchanged under the statewide prohibition law and the measure is unpopular with residents. Enforcement is difficult and drunkenness and crime have not declined since its adoption.
Prohibition Viewpoint From Talisferro County Sheriff
Ed Edwards sheriff of Talisferro County criticizes liquor laws saying statewide prohibition increases whiskey consumption locally. He notes the county was dry before the law and argues prohibition fails to prohibit with many blind tigers operating.
Local option praised by Campbell County Sheriff
Campbell County Sheriff B E Wilkerison claims statewide Prohibition fails and local option would curb crime and whiskey traffic. He cites increased drunkenness and arrests tied to whiskey, noting 75 percent of his arrests originate there and urging local option support.
Local option law praised over statewide measure
Alonzo Ferr, sheriff of Paulding County, argues that the local option law earns greater respect than the statewide prohibition. He claims the statewide law is a failure with more drinking and crowded dockets for illegal liquor sales, while locals favor local option as the better approach.
District dries forty years. sheriff laments enforcement
R L Barbaree, sheriff of Chattoog County, voices frustration as a district once dry for forty years now sees liquor sold countywide with no help from officers to enforce the law. He cites lack of cooperation and ongoing challenges in maintaining prohibition.
Memphis Sees 65 Prohibition Related Murders in 1910
The speaker notes 65 first degree murder cases in Memphis during 1910 under prohibition, the highest in city history. He cites widespread whiskey sales across the county, including “walking bars” run by both black and white sellers, and argues local option is best to enforce laws. He says officers struggle to enforce the prohibition act.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Memphis
Local Option Sways Sheriff on Prohibition Juries
Meriwether County Sheriff J B Jarrell laments statewide fraud and false swearing by grand juries. He argues for local option as public opinion pressures lighter fines and juries refuse to convict under heavy statewide prohibition.
Local option urged over statewide prohibition in Rockdale
Rockdale County Sheriff W L King argues statewide prohibition fails to curb liquor. He cites widespread whiskey sales, multiple Augusta cases dismissed as a farce, and open beer near clubs in Atlanta. He advocates local option as the remedy and criticizes enforcement and public sentiment.
Quitman County Law Enforcement Struggles Under Local Option
In Quitman County Sheriff W R Caden reports deteriorating conditions under prohibition. Both black and white residents evade enforcement, with whiskey interests funding fines and chain gang sentences. He says the situation worsens compared to local option and crimes persist.
Four Mile Law in Tennessee Counties Noted
Tennessee counties that up to statewide adoption enforced the four mile law on alcohol restrictions are identified, highlighting the local variations and the timing of how prohibition was applied prior to statewide enforcement.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Tennessee
Local option fails to curb drunkenness in Marshall County
Marshall County Sheriff W. P. Hastings reports that statewide prohibition has not improved conditions locally. He notes the law is hard to enforce, arrests for drunkenness have occurred, but exact numbers cannot be provided. Public opinion remains unfavorable to the measure.
Prohibition surge boosts Memphis saloons before law takes effect
Just before prohibition began, Memphis housed 763 saloons and by March 31, 1911 the number of whiskey and beer joints surpassed 1,300. The rise shows rapid growth in drink establishments as the law approached.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Memphis
Also Mentioned on This Page
Texas
Calhoun County
L. H. Davis
Heard County
H. L. Taylor
Cobb County
My County
Lee County
B. Smith
Walker County
Savannah
Tenn
Morgan County
R. B. Aycock
Warren County
W. O. Brinky
Richmond County
Clark
Laurens County
J. J. Flanlus
Habersham County
Grant
Montgomery County
James Hester
Jeff Davis County
W. H. Ellis
J. H. Ward
Tift County
E. D. Branch
Douglas County
David Rickston
McDuffie Et SF
H. T. Clary
Heriff
Charlton County
W. Mizell
Union County
Liberty County
J. D. Stafford
Randolph County
W. S. Mattox
Taylor County
Crawford County
Talisaferro County
W. Y. Edwards
Campbell County
B. E. Wilkerson
Paulding County
Alonzo Ferr
Chattanoochee County
R. L Barbaree
Meriwether County
J. B. Jarrell
Rockdale County
W. L. King
Atlanta
Quitman County
Marshall County
W. P. Hastings