Controversy at Brooklyn Church Heats Up as Sidener Preaches
The Rev. Dr. Herman S. Sidener officiated his first service at the Protestant Episcopal Church of the Holy Trinity in Brooklyn amid long held strife. Ousted rector Rev. William Howard Melish attended both services with his wife and son as parish factions clashed with a pro Melish vestry head presenting Sidener with a demand that he leave.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York
Herman S. Sidener
Protestant Episcopal Church of the Holy
Parish split over pulpit dispute ends with ouster ruling
The Long Island church feud centers on Rev. Melish and his opponents who accuse left wing ties. Dr. Sidener was installed rector in 1956 and upheld by courts, while the Court of Appeals refused to stay Melish’s ouster, allowing residence for the family during the appeal. The case hinges on vestry quorum when Sidener was chosen. The article also notes Cognac aging and the sun as largest consumer.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Fering
Sidener
Alex Munsell
Mr. Melish
James P. DeWolfe
Long Island
State Supreme Court
Brooklyn
Court of Appeals
Melish
High Court
Bar
Also Mentioned on This Page
Cameron Beadle
The
Sun
MAIN
Bette
Mee
Kroger
Kroger Bread
Avers Kroger
Jumbo Heads
Robinson’s
RCA Whirlpool
Robinson
Meat Keeper
RCA
Kroger’s