Judge's charge outlines insanity and reasonable doubt standards
The instruction emphasizes that the victim's character does not excuse crime, that sanity is presumed, and that the defense bears the burden of proving insanity. It covers admissibility of testimony, expert limits, and the jury's duty to decide guilt or degrees of murder or manslaughter based on evidence beyond reasonable doubt.
Thaw Murder Trial Enters Final Stage With Jerome Address
New York April 10 District Attorney Jerome delivered a powerful closing to the Thaw trial in which he argued for conviction in the Stanford White murder case. He urged jurors to base verdict on evidence not sympathy, detailing premeditation and the crime’s cold-blooded nature while defending White’s character against Evelyn Nesbit’s testimony.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York
Harry K. Thaw
Stanford White
Pittsburger
Jerome
Thaw
Mr. Delmas
Harvard
Mr. Jerome
Commonwealth
Europe
James Clinch Smith
Truxton Beale
Smith
Pacific Slope
Mr. Smith
Mr. Jerome Here
Apostle of God
Dr. Evans
Chicago Haymarket
St. George
Evelyn Thaw
Evelyn
Angel Child
White
Lfe
Twentyfourth Street
Florodora
Twenty-fourth Street
Hell
Stanford
Florodora Chorus
Evelyn Nesbit
Garland
Angel
Barrymore
City of
Thaw Jury Deliberates Far From Verdict in Court
New York April 12 jury in the Thaw case continues to deliberate with no verdict after 53 hours. Justice Fitzgerald ordered a luncheon recess and noonday repast as jurors stay focused on the four possible outcomes murder in first degree second degree manslaughter or insanity acquittal. Crowds gathered around the courts and Tombs with Evelyn Nesbit Thaw and Thaw family seen, police guarding the mobbed entrance.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
New York
Justice Fitzgerald
Criminal Courts
Evelyn Nesbit Thaw
Thaw
Haw
Harry K. Thaw
Pink
Fitzgerald
Jerome
Court of Appeals
Messrs. McClure
Olney
Court House
McClusky
Thawe
New York State Supreme Court
New York County
Conn
Matteawan
Jury still deadlocked after Thaw trial night
After thirty-eight hours in captivity, the twelve jurors in the Thaw case returned to the court and continued debate and balloting. Crowds gathered around the courthouse as speculation swirled over a nine to three split and potential bail actions.
Jerome Thaw and wife in jail corridor scene
In a Tombs prison corridor, Jerome Thaw confronts the bail question while a young woman, distressed, sobs as Commissioner Coggey observes the Saturday inspection. Mrs Thaw is escorted away and denies plans to leave the city.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Thaw
Coggey
Judge Heaton and Possible Bench Vacancy Spark City Interest
The Sentinel reports growing talk of Judge Owen H. Heaton possibly leaving the Superior Court for a financial post as president of the Citizens' Trust Company. Republican attorneys, including Sol A. Wood, R. B. Dretbelbiss, and H. G. Keegan, are viewed as potential substitutes, though Heaton and his friends urge patience. Heaton declines to discuss actions, noting no formal offer and recent salary increase to 4500.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
the Sentinel
Owen H. Heaton
Citizens’ Trust Company
Superior Cours
Heaton
Sol. A. Wood
R. B. Dretbelbiss
H. G. Keegan
Judge Heaton
Trust Company
Willing Workers Aid Hart Family After Fire Loss
The Willing Workers on the south side start a fund to help Elmer Hart and family after a Saturday fire destroyed their home and belongings. They seek 200 to 250 dollars to cover moving and renovating a house. donations accepted at First National Bank or with C. R. Willson at Commercial Bank. The family has no income or insurance and is being supported by neighbors.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
South Side
Elmer Hart
Hart
First National Bank
C. R. Willson
Commercial Bank
Indiana Insurance firms get policy extension to June first
State Auditor Billheimer extended the period for Indiana insurers to write special contract policies to June 1 this year. The move affects many companies that had sought extra time to issue these policies.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
the Sentinel
Indianapolis
Ind
Billheimer
Indiana
Marriage Licenses United In Garrett Sunday
George J. Knott 23 a machinist wed Tena C. Lauer 24. Chalmer Bowman 22 a farmer wed Sarah EB Whitney 23. Elmer C. Jackson 27 an engineer wed Mary Etta Turner 25 a stenographer. Frances A. McWhirt a teacher in Angola schools wed George W. McConnell of Angola in Garrett.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
George J. Knott
Tena C. Lauer
Chalmer Bowman
Sarah EB. Whitney
Elmer C. Jackson
Mary Etta Turner
Frances A. McWhirt
Angola
George W. McConnell
Garrett
Also Mentioned on This Page
Riddles
Thans al
Josiah Thaw
Countess of
Yarmouth
Carnegie
Edward Thaw
New York State
Misissippi
Atlantic Seaboard
Cambridge
Educed
Stanford ‘White
William Thaw
Normons
Edward
Josiah
JURY
Dreier & Bro