Malice in Blunderland as Guinier Nomination Falls
Washington faced a rare Clinton retreat as Lani Guinier withdrew under heavy criticism. The president cited her writings as the reason, though aides had warned of trouble early. Critics say poor preparation and centrist positioning doomed the nomination and could affect future judicial picks.
Guinier Nomination Sparks Hearings Debate in Senate
Senator Harris Wofford urged giving Justice Department nominee Lani Guinier a chance to defend her views though he disagreed with some voting rights opinions. Senator Arlen Specter said hearings should have occurred before the Judiciary Committee. Clinton abandoned the nomination amid criticism over Guinier's minority rights writings. Wofford had praised Guinier as a superb choice but later noted disagreements with some of her hypotheses on voting guarantees.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Washington
Clinton
Lani Guinier
Justice Department
White House
Guinier
Senate Judiciary Committee
Chamber
U.S
Harris Wofford
Senate
Pennsylvania
Arlen Specter
University of Pennsylvania
Judiciary Committee
Justice de
Wofford
Department
David Stone
Guiniers Law Journal
Guinier nomination sparks civil rights debate in Washington
Voices in Washington react to Lani Guinier's nomination to head the Justice Department civil rights division. Critics say she does not fit a mainstream type. Senator Breaux blasts it as a stupid move that would hurt the president's standing in the civil rights community. Mary Frances Berry questions the fit with mainstream views.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Washington
Lani Guinier
Justice Department Civil Rights Division
John Breaux
D-La
Mary Frances Berry
U.S. Commission On Civil Rights
Writings on legal issues by Lani Guinier excerpts
Excerpts discuss minority representation and single member districts, arguing for proportionality to balance majority power with minority rights. Guinier critiques majority rule in racially divided societies and proposes a non majoritarian principle to enhance fairness, self government, and deliberation, referencing Cardozo and Boston Review material from 1992.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Lani Guinier
Boston Review
No Two Seats and the Elusive Quest in Governance
Fragmentary text argues that racism blocks minority inclusion in governing coalitions, framing a permanent white majority. Mentions Sapp and seniors, but overall unclear context and incomplete statements.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Rac- Sapp
Rasiority
Haga
Also Mentioned on This Page
Eer Sant
Prez
Congressional
Jackson
Georgia
Claibourne Darden
Darden
Mlh. Saltz
Dr. Saltz
M.H. Saltz
THE
Saltz Dental Center
Ashvinkumar H. Dhruva
D.D.S
Ash
William D. Graham
D.M.D
Ave
States
Chester
PA & DE Blue Shield
Specter
Ad Orgy Civil Rights Division
Murphy Body
Foreign & Domestic Service AT
Pai
Murphy Ae Ee