Butler controversy and political taunts over Butler and Ames
A volley of satirical and critical commentary targets Benjamin Butler and Massachusetts politics. The column traces Butler’s shifting party allegiance, his record as governor, and alleged ties to reform rhetoric, while contrasting Democratic and Republican loyalties, praising or lampooning supporters, and questioning his fitness and motives amid a tense political moment. It references Ames, Tarbox, and Marsh within a broader critique of party loyalty and reform claims.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Ohio
Olio
American Board of Foreign Missions
Mission Park
Williamstown
Missionary Society
Mark Hopkins
Williams College
Hopkins
United States
Chapin
Beloit
Baltimore
England
John Brown
Tennyson
Chicago
New York
Cincinnati Commercial Gazette
Bickory
Boston Post
Gov. Butler
Post
Daily
Butler
Democratic Party
Republican Party
Charleston
Jefferson Davis
Congress
Constitution
Thad
Stevens
Thompson
Tarbox
Kelly
Judge
Massachusetts
Ben Butler
Republican Party of Saints
Greenback
Benjamin
Seward
Maj
Jack Downing
Marsh
Ames
Mr. Butler
Mr. Beard
Tewksbury
Hancock
Adams
Sandwich
Wendell Phillips
Phillips
Mr. Phillips
Tremont Temple
Washington
Jefferson
Daily Advertiser
Music Hall
Commonwealth of Massachusetts
Gen. Butler
Simmons
Democrats
Saints
Woodbury
Tilden
Gov. Robinson
Dan Butler
Mahone
Hurd
Randall
Carlisle
Butler and Simmons
Old Commonwealth of Massachusetts
D. D. Kelly
East
Boston
Also Mentioned on This Page
Boston Po
R. B. Hayes
Fremont
The
Toronto Globe
Lord Lorne
Order of the Knight of the Garter
Balmoral
House of Lords
China
Joss
Elberton New South
Georgia
Times
Joseph E. Brown
D. W. Voorhees
Indiana
Supreme Court
Thurman
Senate
Edmunds
Transcript
Obie
Ohie
Judge Hoadly
Durbin Ward
Barre
Cincinnati
Cleveland
Foraker
Hoadly
Beecher
Brooklyn
Herr
Yellow Jack
Havana
Cox
Brown
Lorne
John Swinton
Wendell
Lowell
Arabi Pasha
Ceylon
Arkansas
Neal Dow
Detroit Free Press
Anthony
Marquis of Lansdowne
Canada
Quebec
Lorne and
Louise
Hartford Post
Pittsburg
New York Commercial Advertiser
Vanderbilt
Associated Press
Philadelphia
Boston Transcript
Indianapolis
Diplomatic Corps
Lionel Sackville West
Lafayette Park
New Orleans
Senor Barco
Haytien
Aristarchi Bey
Smith
Navy
Bob Ingersoll
John Sherman
Gen. Sherman
Allison, Pendleton
Don Cameron
Meat
Pennsylvania Avenue
Robeson
Beck
Blackburn
House
Ivy City
Dren
Rae Aleee
WM. H. Zinn
P.S
Madras
Fiks
Washington Street
Russia
France
Belgium
Ireland
Pain
Holland
Portugal
Denmark
Germany
Italy
Egypt
Venezuela
Brazil
Japan
Austria
Hotels
Grand Centennial Organ
D. Leavitt
Imperial German
Adams House
A. K. Lorving’s
Washington St
Oliver Ditson & Co
Eemerson Piano Co
Tremont Street
Hall & Whipple, Proprietors
Young's Hotel
Globe Theatre
John Stetson
Fifth Avenue Theatre CO
Augustin Daly
Sara Jewett
Annie Russell
Georgia Tyler
Jizzie McCall
May Syme
Marion Russell
Jane Russell
Messrs
Herbert Kelsey
George Parkes
Walter Reynolds
Kawin Varney
Harry Brown
J. @. McDonald
N. D. Jones
Tommy Russell
Boston Theatre
Jalma
Chas.Gaylor
Falmouth
Mass
F. Dimmich
Tremont House
Tremont and
Beacon Streets
Silas Carney & CO
Sherburne
Nantucket
Thomas EH. Soule, Jr
jyloTushSty
Boston & Bangor Steamship GO
Bass Harbor
Southwest Harbor
Bar Harbor
Mt. Desert
Sullivan
Poston
Henry Morrison
Deer Isle
Bluehill
Surry
Elsworth
Lewiston
Castine
Sedgwick
Milbridge
Frtay
Jonesport
Machiasport
Bangor
A.M
Rockland
Ellsworth
Millbridge
J. Littlefield
T. Calvin Austin
Je’ Hf
St. Andrews
Shediac
Newcastle
Bathurst
N.B
Digby
Annapolis
Kentville
Wiiew
Yarmouth
Halifax
Truro
Pictou
Glasgow
Summerside
Charlottetown
W.H. Kilby
Agemt
Ang and
Mrs. W
J. J. Florence
Boston Museum
R. M. Field
Gilbert
Museum Fine Arts
Howard Atheneum
Rich & Harris
Proprietors
Congress Square
Portland
TuThly J.W. Robinson & Son
Province
Vince
Na Eeres ST
Tremont
Broadway
Wees
Family
Eve Cornwell
Ocl 1t&TuchStones
Perry House
Sqr
Newport
Western Union Ee
G. H. Kingman
Melville Boll&e
George L. Day
Lee Central
Hnox & Com Ka
William Weeks
Kennebec River
Richmond
Gardiner
Hallowell
Augusta
Bath
Return
Star OF the East
Jason Collins
Central Wharf
Rop
Ayne
Vienna
Fairfield Waterville
Oakland
Liberty
H. H. Hyde
Apiatt
Whiprerall
Bellevue Avenue
S. H. Gilmore
Berhley
H. I
Spencer H. Gilmore
Kilton
Millit
Spencer and
Whitefield Streets
South Avenue
Harvard Station
N. Y
Dorchester
Samuel B. Pierce
Ocl
Pear Street
Carpenter
Boylston Museum
Lothrop
Mercial
New York City
Piacé
Pg Stree
Setzit
City Hall
City Hall Avenue
Hoston
Fred J. Chash
Sherman House
Summer St
Ingalls & Hatch
Vine
Tufts
Corey Streets
Charlestown
Navy Yard
Igs Street
F. C. Dallas
Ocket Brecord
B. Gay
H. B. Wilmot
Peat
Schubert Club
Reeves’ Band
R. H. Mohr
First Regiment
North Carolina
Sn Handel & Haydn Society
Marlin Luther
Emily Winant
Theo
J. Toedt
Clarenche
Elizabeth C. Hamlin
Hope Glenn
Charles K. Adams
John F. Winch
Berline Osgood
Smily Winant
St. Paul
Mme
Eugenie Pappenheim
Jennette M. Noyes
Myron W. Whif
Iuavas
Bernhard Listemann
Carl Zerrahn
B. J. Lang
E. B. Hagar
Mystic Park
Boston and
Lawrence
Era Park
North
GEO
A. Ayer, Sec. and
Treas. B. Y. M. D. Union
Boylston ST
Union Gymnasium
D. A. Sargent
F. C. Lister
Union Rooms
Boylston Street
WM. H. Baldwin
W. B. Clarke
Buog Theatre
H. Hastings
Charles Wyndham
And
Complete Comedy Company
Lancers
Grand
Horticultural Hall
S.M.F
Associated Virginis & the
Carolinas
Atlantic Coast Line
Baltimore, Norfolk and Washington Steamship Line
Virginia
Louisian
C. Ya Tiawanes Bi
Wasungawa
Potomac
B. Ca
Alexandria
Norfolk
Tennessee
Florida
Alabama
Mississippi
Tarponce
Gaither
Mthc
Coa Line
Seaboard Air 8
Waldo A. Pearce
Ms Teen
Se Waml
E. Sampson
Mallory
Texas & Florida
Galveston
Colorado
Sampasas
State OF Texas
Texas
San Francisco
California
Southern Pacific A. BR
City OF San Antonio
Mt Sal Force
Fernandina
Fla
Scierito Della Aussianina
Gaille
Floride
Wes
Seth Sprague
Old State House
O. H. En Feiver
East River
Newark
Boston & Philadelphia Steamship Line
Wenday
Rday
Seramar Spartan
Roman
Long Wharf
Savannan
Iumington
B. Sampson
India Wharf
Landing York
Pier 11
Canites
H. M. Whitney
Morgan
Louisiana and Texas Railroad and Steamship Co
Morgan Line
North River
Algiers
Mobile
Mississippi River
Southern Pacific R.R
Arizona
Edward E. Currier
W. Street
Bogert & Morgan
General Mail
Pier
NEW Orls
Cromwell S
Ty Cumuow
Knickerbocker
F. Kemble
Pier 9
Princi
J. M. Magna
Cunard Steamship Company, Steamships
Liverpool
Queenstown
Cork Harbor
Batavia
Parthia
Pavonia
Scythia
Servia
Gallia
Coordin
Great Britain and Ireland
State Street
Myiti P
Allan Royal Mail
Britain
Londonderry
Sardin
L & AL
Les V. Casey
Broad Street
Ibertan
Lincoln
Ren Ove
Halifax, Port Hawkesbury, Pictou and
Carrell and Worcester
Nickerson
Congressmea
N. S
Port Hawkes
Piictou
Wincaser
Iruro
New Glasgow
Antigonish
H. G. Nickerson
A. Pew Sampson
V. Nickerson & CO
Nova Scotia S. 8S. CO
Yarmouth and
Bon Snies
St. John
New Brunswick
T Wharf
Dirby
F.L. Clements
118 Wharf
Eicsenne
Neenstown
Britannic
Republic
Celtic
L. Bartlett & Co
State St
Cor
Broad St
Wetherby
Boston City
York City
Synxrham City
Newcastle City
Hipon City
New
London City
Lincoln City
Calcutta City
J. B. Brigham & CO
Central Street
Navigazione Generale Italiana
Secieta
Riunite Florio E Rubattino
Mediterranean
Ss. S. Independente
S.S. Washington
Gibraltar
Marseilles
Genoa
Naples
Aden
Bombay
Singapore
Calcutta
Far East
Adriatic
Black Sea
Orient
Stimson & CO
Milk Street
Royal Mail
Netherlands
Sussex Street
Jersey City
Rotterdam
Amsterdam
F.S. Stimson & CO
Monarch
London
Railroads
Fall Riverline
Old Colony
Fall River
Him
Bristol
Washington and
State Streets
H. Palmer
J.R. Kendrick
Stonington
New York West
A. A
New England
R. R
Baaltimore
Aldderail
Hartford
Suniaya
Pullman
Providence
Valley Falls
Putnam
Willimantic and Harteford
Manchester
Rockville
Uoun
Danbury
Brewsters
New Briteinmand
Waterbury
Norwich
Danielsonville
New London
Everton
Intermedieee
Pt., Ae
Zee Aan
OLD Colony Railroad
New T Sd
Iver Ce
Fail River
Taunton
Bridgewater
Gris Taunton
Ater
Central Station
Dean Street
North Easton
Ton Randolph
South Abington
Brockton
Abington
Duxbury
Easterwater
South Weymouth
South Duxbury
Marshfield
Scituate
Cohasset
Bham
Hingham
Aio
New Bedford
Braintree
Uincy
Wollaston Heights
Atlantic
Neponset
Harrison Square
Siam
Milton
West Quincy
East Milton
Miattapam
Nepornset
Get
Milton Lower Millis
Oakluffs
Cape Cod
Provincetown
Wood’s Hall
Barnstable Yarmouth
Hyamasis
Mattapoisett
Northern Division
Marlboro
Clinton
Leominster
Fitchburg
Fall River Line
Briazewater
South Braine Tree and Way
South Braintree
J. R. Kandrick
Boston and Maine Railroad
Montreal
Gorham
Sanger
WN. B
Eastport
Calais
St.John
N. B
M. S
Alorming
Maine Central
Grand Trunk Railways
Alton Bay
Rochester
Farmington
N. H
Buckland
Camden
Belfast
Bucksport
Southwest
Bar Harbors
Mount Desert
Concord
N. Hi
Hennebunk
Biddeford
Saco
Old Orchard Beach
Old Orchard
Great Falls
Spa
Dover
Exeter
Mierrimac
Haverhill
Georgetown
North Andover
North Lawrence
South Lawrence
Andover
Waminton
Arta
Wakefield
Genie Depot
Danvers
Mu Seoub
J.bir
UDP
F-Ku
Sys
Malden
Medford
Reading and Way
Maents
Kor Lawrence
Bdover
At Falls
Het Haverhill
Bam
Law‘Sant
Avian Px
Reading
Wednesdaf Rasen
Washingtonm
Age Square
Wie
Merritt, Jr
A. Bird St
Mt. Bowdoin
An & AK
Teese
Mp Bene
Harvard
Nous
Aan
Cbee V.tyv
Vv DW
Mattapan
River Street
Myst Tre Park
Edie
Rendville
Dale
B.xu
Kim Wood
Ellis
Norwood
Cam
Iee
Walpole
Highland Lalke
Franklin
Nincttosene
Ebster
South Hetdwoe
D. 1865
Heturn
inrensamiWay
Artler
A. 2
Wnaay
Norwood Centre
Anqwut PT Npn
West
Thins Cave Homa
Vie
T. Albans
So. Tee
J. Cotten
Lake Memphremagog
Sherbrooke
Boston Air Line
Passamusic
South Eastern
Sealesteen Bocceapa Lowel HH
Debot
Gueenapeeen
St. Anes
Night Express
Poliman
Ae Ua
Morea
Ceenoee
Undaye
Boston i Picketa
Washin
Folsom Sn
N.P. Lovering, Jr
Raymond
Agen Eastern Railroad
Causeway Street
Friend Street
Ial
St. 1
Provinces
al! Rail
Sax
Het
Halax
Sam
Mit
Posert
Riday
Ecemer Mackinapert
Waterville
Gem
Sun
Biddeford and
North Conway
Wolfercorp
Mochester
Great Bulls
Srover
Portsmouth
Greenland
Rye Beach
R.m. Sun. Sam
Tew
Rot
Dhag Nort
Hampton
Seach
Sam. T. North
Kepawich
Sun Sam
Wen
Hockport and Gloucester Branch
Het. Hockport
U. Beverly
Bun
Genie Lawrence
Bet
Pere
Ea Dann
Teshody
Salem
Marblehead
Swampscott Branch
Waett
Wee
Srn
Chelsea
West Veerett
Saugus
Werett
Bhu
Vere
Ore
la Saugus Branda
Daverten
Aoe
D. Ve ‘Sanbomn
Trama
Fitchbure
Hoosago Tunnel
Trey
Ag Ce
Syracuse
N. WY
St. Louis
York Central
Wabash
Erie
Pacific Express
New Yo Central
Canad& Southern Ailroads
Gardner
Baldwinville
Athol
Orange
Mileler’s Fails
Greenfield
Shelburne Falls
North Adams
Royaliston
Erving
Montaguce
Ont
Mitceh D . Wachusett
Otter River
East Deerfield
Westminster
Asa
Yarmheam
Aitchburg
West Deerfield
Zoar
Bardwells
Charlemont
Hloosac Tunnel
Turners Falls
Rweig
Brattieboroa
Oy Wenrece
Yaeh
Perell
Itchburg
Vane
Winchendon
Heene
Belleations
Cheshire
Sataf
Worcester
Nashua
Framinghar
Ame
Grarin Ae
Worsterwall
Ayer
T. ON
Boston & Lowell Railroad
Con- Cone
Peterboro
Sru
Sone
Aon
Keene
Asntelot
Asntelot ,At 7.80 Am;3 Pu. Mek Wryer 15 Am; 2.25 Px. Wilton and Milfo
Washwua
Billerica
North Billerica
Uand, Jand
Ant Ooh Lawrence
W.hi
West Medford
Prison Station
Fom
Bedford
Lexington
Arlington
Northern Toniy
UNDAY
Moston
Nowels
War Stations
Milford
Wilton
Ford
Ertoas
Ams
New Bedam
Arrney Tae
A. A. Folsom
Aeroa
Oston
Lower
White River
Southt
Passumpsic
Fisherine
Lebanon
White River Junction
Claremont
Hills
Hillsboro
M. Depot
Northern
R. RK
C. BK. RB
Todd
Concomd
B. L
Chester
Joncord
N. A
M. Seay
B. Chamberian
Roe Aeureds Moord
Walt 7
Hiver B.B
K. Turner
Aton
South Acton
Centraboro
Stere
Hoa
Thas Staim
OHN Adams, Gen. Co
Gold Colony
NH. K
Northerm
Ge Gee
Pepe Lee
Ows
Bostem _idol depot
Saays
Hams
Airboro
Fayville
So’ South
Ace
Clinton, Leominster and
Fitch
Te Ees
Weet ‘Eriin
Bessemila Sru
Pratt's van
Bodice
St . Ami
Old
Ae Washington
Jd. BR
Kendmick
Geo Gen 1
Bostosg -Arber
Pitchburo
Cheshire Railroad
Ae Soo
de Dry
Sereatoga
Winona
Fitewilliam
Iroy
Westiereland
Bellows Falls
Rutland
Burlington
Saratoga
St. Albans
Bt. Johns
Dellows
Cheshire R. R
P.M
Ogdensburg
R. M
Stewar Hay R. Keone
Bhentano
Great Southern
Savannah
Grea
A. Dew
Lampbon
Metropolm Steamship Co
Charles
Te Bostom
W.Y
Flo
Ashington
City OF Columbus
Gate City
DE W Sampson
Peu
Ae Ae
This is just the beginning! Our collection holds over 300 years of history, including rare newspapers, obituaries, marriage records, birth records, and so much more—most of which you won’t find anywhere else!