Privilege Question Defeated in House After Frothingham Substitute
The Privilege Question raised by the senate message related to a Republican article was disposed of in the house yesterday. The committee's answer was rejected and a substitute by Mr Frothingham of Charlestown was adopted. Senator Hillard, who pushed the matter, attended the debate and admitted Frothingham's arguments against the committee report were correct.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Congress
House
Committee of Elections
Hugh N. Smith
New Mexico
Smith
Rio Grande
Texas
House of Representatives
A. W. Babbett
Desert
Mormon Territory
Crawford
Galphin
Messrs Bart
Grinnellwig
Featherston
Gentry
Disney
King
McLanahan
Dem
Conrad
Jackson
Geeorgia
New Orleans
New York
Paviion Hotel
Louisiana Bakery
Orleans Mills
Brazos
Roma
Laredo
Nicol
Porpoise
Benj
Sands
Hampton Roads
Porto Prava
St. Thomas
John Wallace
Charles H. Knapp
Commodore Goring
Franklin
Faroay
Arrex
Tremont Street Medical School
Vineyard Sennd
Nantucket
Hoar
Concord
Griswold
Greenfield
Waenerty
Caleb Rice
Abuvet Pest
Senate
Earle
Worcester
Messrs
Frethingham
Boutwell
Wilson
Mc Earle
Frothingham
Mmeten
Frothingh
Charlestown
Natick
Messrs Griswold
Branning
Trronghem
Messrs Hoar
Eliot
Boston
Springfield Medical School
South Cove Corporation
Seunth
We. Wright
Corliss
Wightman
Messrs Welson
Kimball
Appord
Dorchester
Jones
Russell
Gifford
Dexbury
Bancroft
Lowell
Norwich and Worcester Railroad Company
Massachusetts
Messrs Wightman
Farle
Enfield
Republican
Hillard
Also Mentioned on This Page
Oregon
Latest Telegraph News
California
SER
Empire City
Waiparsieo
Egetee
San Franciece
Panama
San Franisco
Mar
General Conde
Econdary
Alto
San Diego
San Alas
Cty
Mexicon
Pacific
Cohomneston
Emery
San Francisco
Sh P Palaouth
Mazatian
Atrolee
Fae VY
Dateo Francieno
Deta
Gor Ue Tolaes
Sacraments
San Joaquin
San Francesco
Gtrita
Sth
Dan Prancisco
Manpova
Morteles
Mariposa
Stanishane
Legestate
Tus
Gov
T Hornett
Pehouwary
Deseret
Mexico
General Assembly
Chief Justice and Associates
Sacramento
Hawkins’ Bar
Geo. W. Blanchard
Jona BE. Connett
Newport
Hellespont
Jeremiah Moulton, Jr
Bangor
Herricks
Magnolia
New Hampshire
Cooder
Booch
Falmouth
Wechusett Valley
Elbridge Haynes
Sudbury
Mass
Revere Hotel
Joel Augustus Viies
Lexington
Frederick H. Mitchell
Nautaket
Manila
Montevideo
Guayaquil
Diego Neva
Qouitoos
Liberia
J. J. Roberts
Davis
Wasnachusetts
Treasury
York State
Albenny
Albany
Adams Bank
North Adams
Barnstable Bank
Joseph B. Brown
Charleston
Mobile
Galveston
Pewtry
U. S. Commissioner's Court
Connecticut
United States
Pacific Railroad
J.C. Fremont
Mississippi
Wm. B. Ogden
Milnois
Professor Webster
Governor Briggs
Medical College
Webster
Albro
Cambridge
William E. Brockway
Hudson, N. Y
New Haven
U. S. Supreme Court
J. B. Robb
Bayley
Idtbrook
New England Railroad Express
Bedford Street
Colman
Board of Health
Simmons & Co
Oak Hall
Simmons
Ann Street
Great One Price Store
Quincy Hall
Sounholtz
Tremont Row
William Bogle
Washington Street
Barnard
Jacob H. Savage
Susan L
Kent
Dr Gannett
Patrick Grant
Charlotte Bordman
Henry G. Rice
Baldwin C. Ticknor
Helen M
James Read
Frank William
B. F
Charlotte M. Leavens
Lucy Susanna
Peter
Sarah H. Low
School Street
Thomas Burnham
Chelsea
Philip Peak, Jr
Bedford
Susanna Belcher
Portland
Elizabeth Stevens
Samuel Stevens
Gloucester
St. John
N. B
L. R. Darrow
New Brunswick
Commercial
North River
Merchants’ Exchange Books
Messina
Martha Allen
Queenstown
Havana
Parana
Telegraph
Mies Warer
R&s
Marine Journal
Port OF
Scitmate
Manson
Gibraltar
Lon
A Hayford
Frankfort
Gooding
Lawrence
Mayo
Baltimore
Marine
Brown
Newburyport
Elizabeth Davidson
Kelly
Delaware City
Squantum
Crocker
Liverpool
Martin
Townsend
Richardson
Anglo American
Howard
I Bng
Choctaw
Kendrick
Lombard & Hall
Pearl
Harding
Philadelphia
Rice & Thaxter
Catherine Wilcox
Nickerson
York
Leigh
Salem
Helen Maria
President Roads
Geo Richarson
Sch
Auantic
Provincetown
Sophia Wallker
Palermo
Wisweill
William
Vicinity
Jno Dunlap
Port Royal
Port Royal, Ja
Bath
L Houghton
A Houghton
Messrs Larrabee & Alien
East Machias
George & William
Haskell
Albert
Pendleton
Sophroma
Torrey
Splendid
Hooper
St Lawrence
Kellar
Carroll
Robinson
Thomaston
Machiasport
Arbrig Relief
Brown, Mill- Suth
Aurora
Brow
Ben Rea
Ancona
Griffin
Bostone
Idg
Bryro
Bryant
Sullivan
Mrch
Rebecca
Polly
Butler
Coral
Grant
Swiftsure
Banker
C. Sch
Tuckerman
Portsmouth
Coffin’s Beach
Essex River
Harf Railroad Iron
J W Emery
Portamouth
Mr. Smith
JK Pickering
Oxford & Moses
Empire
Robert Morrin
Neweacastle
Moses
Gulf Stream
Knight Heads
Matanzas
Broark Creamore
Pernambuco
Hatteras
Caudions
Mary Jane
Chandler
Wilmington
Brilliant
Relief
Napoleon
Savannah
Bed Coquette
Harriet Newell
Belfast
Singapore
Sinp Minstrel
Bassett
Cape Palmas
Lowder
Bnd
Gaboon River
Monrovia
Delaware
Forsyth
Sierra Leone
Leeward Coast
Buenos Ayres
Prairie
Upton
Orleans
Agnes
Sherman
Disg
Chatonia Wright
Raffle
Jast Ar
Active
Foxwell
Ldg
Lydian Ann
Garwood
Elizabeth
Snow
Isabelita Hyne
Ruo Janeiro
Oriole
Stump
Bathurst
Abigail
Maracaibo
Mara
Park
San Juan
Central America
Eudora
Shaw
Unc
Rawson
Leighton
Chagre
N York
Vera Cruz
Tit
Radovich
N Orleans
Torcelio
Atwood
Tabasco
Kingston
Tyringham
Howes
Imogene
Benedict
Mayaguez
St Jago
Cuba
Circus Co
Lizzie, Smith
Matland
Cienfuegos
Hope
Fanny
Walsh
Africa
Carlotta
Gerard
Guadaloupe
Une
J Marshall
Loud
Just Ar
Nenvitas
Topaz
Brookfield
Newbern
Arstrom
Reed
Guayama
Barks
Sagua la Grande
Harriet
Martha
Leslie
Rhoderick Dhu
Freeman
Wig Cargo
Roman
Eliza
Merrill
Ketch Commerce
Soubiates
Schs Advance
New England
Leet
Providence
Maria
Weymouth
Watson, Clough
Guttemberg, Wooster
Bristol
Wm Nichols
Parritt
Wm Henry
Franklinc
Busy
Surgens
Schs
Bentley
Roanoke
Wood
Jenny Lind
Coombs
Bucksport
O’brien
Peterson
Philad
Acklam
Miller
Whaers
Jane Hawes
Young
North Atlantic
Newfiedford
St George Hawes
Pacific Ocean
Brock Island
Vineyard Sound
Sag Harbor
Fortescue Harbor
Straits of Magellan
Garland
N Bedford
Hong Kong
Envoy
Walker
New Bedford
Yellow Sea
Loundon
Dee
Jas Caskie
Stieglitz
Holley
Smithfield
Alexandria
Josephine
Burt
St George
Newfoundland
Mary Pleasants
Tortugas
Eugenia
New Orléans
Silas Holmes
Berry
Duncan
Gilchrist
Atlantic
John Tunis
Crane
St Johns
Norfolk
Sarah L Bryan
Sdis
Cordelia
Cookson
Long Island
Helen Miranda
Greley
Wim Stevens
Shute
Caspian
Matthews
L Brooks
Mayhew
A Gale
Pattershall
Ellen
Ryan
Profit
Crowell
Cohasset
Frederick
Waterman
A Weld
Brier
Smalley
Peytona
Gilman
H McLeod
Stanly
Orizawa
Hinds
Perkins
Rappahannock
Volant
Newcastle
Del
Charles
Field
Boult
Thomas
Pamlico
Finney
Holmes’s Hole
Tarpaulin Cove
Selah
Atkins
Icis Alhambra
Bullock
Zephyr
Crockett
Taunton
Ar 2d
Phillips
Matilda
Larry
Ann Denman
Perry
Rhode Island
Fairchild
Oneco
Rhodes
Sea Serpent
Fairfield
Emporium
Tangier
Excel
Jeroleman
Gobee
Suffolk
St Lucar
Collamer
Vineyard
Foster
Calderwood
East Thomaston
Emnly Briggs
Hudson
Emblem
Racket
Hartford
Earl
Norwich
Mount Vernon
Drinkwater
Tancolnville
Tigress
Uncas
Latham
Joshua Bates
Stoddard
Canton
Devonshire
Hovey
London
St Louis
Bunker
Anna Rich
Burwell
Braziliero
Marsh
Creamore
Kemp
Mopang
Clark
Thales
Pinkham
Yankee Blade
Bradstreet
Apalachicola
Jeddo
Eldridge
J Watson
Currier
Jobes
L Jones
Tyler
Peconic
Halleck
Icis Hound
Roeper
Leghorn
Lysander
Powers
Enterprise
Boyd
Central Africa
Dorcas
Tikiol
Coquette
Auld
True Blue
Cerwath
Arecibo
Friend
Harrington
Carnatic
Devereux
Scott Dyer
Strickland
Hartley
Revere
Sarah Ann
Sarah Sheafe
Hurlburt
Esmeralda
McMenus
Southerner
T J Southard
Bishop
Brunette
McGrath
Alvarado
Gonbid
Satilio River
Baldwin
Johnson
Emily
Halifax
Cid
Spicer
Cleopatra
Naguabo
Bloomfield
Kershaw
St John’s
Mahony
Carver
Fredericksburg
Switzerland
Nicholas Ist
James Drake
Star Republic
Nenaphar
Hf Turner
Planter
Angeline
Geo A Hepley
Rebm
Vandyke
Minesota
Veacock
Rio Janeiro
Jerome
Willard
David K Aikin
Kenney
Port Au Prince
Folian
Jordan
Huntress
Taylor
Ponce
Rainbow
Emmerson
Dixon
Triumph
Mason
Madeira
Harriman
Cardenas
Elizabeth J
Gallagher
William Henry
May
Fall River
Morris
P Lotland
Hallett
Antigua
Hamlet
EP Grande
Norton
Brooklyn
Vesta
Tomin
Provident
C L Hulse
Dayton
Monterey
Cooley
Susquehanna
Maron
Fir
Baltimo&k B
Ar 3d
Edmund Dwight
Zion
Reynolds
Keston
Elizabeth Felton
Richmond
Virginia
Roush
Farnham
Thetis
Derby
Combahee
White
Jacob Raymond
Bourne
Adela
West, Indies
D Godfrey
Bng
Harmony
George J Jones
Maria Theresa
Brandywine
Merryman
Rollerson
Chase
Alfonso
Barcelona
En Orleans
Palmetto
Amelia
Alexander Parker
Rosa Maria
Abbott
Stanley
St Kitts
Independence
Ron
Rattan Island
Attakapas
Rosalinda
Simpson
Wessacum
Che Ottoman
Harrison
Cozzens
Cassandra
Gall Gowenbang
Oowere
Ingersoll
Margaret
Ape
More
Oyane
Loveland
Pitt
St Pierre
Mart
Bella del Mar Auld
Chagres
Adame Gray
Schneidau
Henry
Haker
Bliss
Ariosto
Fabens
Scotland
Percy
Octavia
Madden
Delma
Higgins
Nashua
Mortimer
Creed
Frisbie
Cornelia
Manchester
Sheffield
Lewis
Iwase
Cairo
Loring
Sultana
Raubert Walsh
Kelloch
Drag
Hopkins
Milam
Alton
Milford
Sea Avenger
Yucatan
Florida
Gardner
Valparaiso
Talcahuana
Ann
Savage
Carthage
Ropes
Ruth
Stevens
Bazaar
Lovett
Hence
South America
Sowle
de Dee
Flavio
Jenkins
Baylies
Edgartown
Lang
Carter Braxton
Lane
Christiana
Patterson
Beverly
J S Cabot
Tracy
Mary M Wood
Julius Pringle
Buchanan
New London
Akbar
Worth
Hadley
Barques Canton
Almeda
Mystic
Arco Iris
Colburn
St Cathrines
Juno
Cook
Port Praya
Cape de Verds
Friendship
Stott
Royce
Antares
Pearson
Susan Drew
Drew
Harriet Rockwell
Hawes
Calumet
Hubbard
Stonington
St Catharines
Herrick
Redding & CO
State Street
Bulwer
Ned Allen
David Hannay
J. L. Tyson
M.D. Hunt
Merchants
Shakspeare
Angel World
London Lancet
Blackwood
Edinburg
Hume
England
Harper’s
Milman
Gibbon
Rome
Lynch
River Jordan
Dead Sea
The
Farmers’ Guide
Henry Stevens
Democratic Review
Lord Byron
Mahommet
Washington Irving
Campbell
Granville Mears
Water Street
Broad
March Retual Life
NSC
Merchants & Tract Mechanics
Jus
Connecticut Company
Hartford, Ct
James Goodwin
Ebenezer Frowenr
Guy R. Pruevrs
J. B. Grecerson
M. D
Han
Cock Street
DL Aighnets
John Oavis
Merchants’ Bann Building
State St. Boston
East Boston
Tcs
East Boston Company
Cna Kilby
Albert Bowker
Samuel O. Mead
Joshua Bates, Jr
Thomas Cahill
Washington St
WM. Alline
I'R Fourier
Boston Union of Associationists
Charves Fourier
Cocuttuate Harty
Crosby & Nichols
Wsm&tut
Massachusetts Charitable Fire Society
Mechanics Mutua Fire Inc. Company
Enoch Hobart
S&weefun Recording Sec
W. T. G. Morton
Icp
American Sentinel
W.N. Fernald
Washingtonian Hall
Bromfield St
Boston Museum
Conde
Adelbert
J A Smith Cupidon
iMr Warren
Museu
Vational Theatre
Brney Williams
B Williams
Dolly
Malvina
Medley
ODEON
Lyceum
Miss McKinson
MR Crouta
Miss Dawes
Howard Athenaium
Wilde
Mozart
Don Giovanni
Don Gianni
Signor
Beneventano Laporen
Sanquirico Donnarina
Signorina Traffi Donnafloria
Signorima
Amalia Patti Donnattavio
Forti
Il Commendatore
Strini Masset
Signor Novelli Zerling
Signorina Bertucca
Boston Theatre
Federal St
Rates Family
Leade
Mons
Eugene Fenelon
Ravel
Is TaPestt
Versailles
Wm. T. Cook
Court Street
Paris
New York Fashion
W. H. Beebe & Co
Icg
Wm. FT. Cook
isTuTh&s4w
Bombazines
Milk Street
UNI
Bay State
Rich Paris
Mantillas
Visites & Sacks
Bombazines, Alpaccas, &C
Isfs&tutf
FHUE
Boston Philharmonic Society
Cpiue
Max Maretzer
Bear Kreutzer
Rossini
Signor Novelli
Verdi
Otello
Guidi
Novelli
Donizetti
Lucrezia Borgia
Signorina Truffi
Beneventano
Fingle
Ernani
Lucrezia Borgis
Max Maretzek
Linda
Eee Maretzek
Maretzek
Don Pagnale
Signor Sanquirico
Trio—Don Giovanni
Signorina Traffi
Signorina Amalia Patti
Signor Guidi
Ono—Barbiere
Signora Rossi Corsi
Tremont
Albion Hotel
J. F. Marsh
Wah Ba
Hatter
Franklin Avenue
Fine Beaver
Gentlemen’s Fine Cloth
Charles A. Huckins
Stuethtf ml
L. B. Haskell
West Street
Handel and Haydn Society
Melodeon
Signorina Perrini
Signor Novilli
Fics
Joseph
Oakes, Sec
Insurance
Lipe Insurance Company
Ansvat
Iserey
Robert L. Patterson
Macknety Lewis
Grover
Thomas R. Segur
Henry McParlan
William M. Simps
Robert 4
Joel W. Condit
Vic Ben S. C. Miller
S. Lewis
Seth Low
Edward Anthony
Andrew & Snelling
Randal Green
Isaac H. Frothingham
Pleasun
Tflon
Stephen Fairbanks
Robert G. Shaw
Kinsha H. Allen
Charles G. Loring
Chas. W. Cartwright
Boston 4
Fon
WEAL
Messrs Tolneen, Sewall & Co
Win
PD. Coolidge
Bay
Frederick TV
Iay
Charles Brooks
Peter C. Jones
Cloutuside
Uumpiereys Storer
Mob
Winter Street
Er Eee
J. B. Princeh
Acenr
J.B. A. Sprague
Mil isTue
Sita
MTNA
Surance Compantles
Conn
J. H W. Ward & CO
Kiley and
Landall My. Streets
HVE Franklin Health Assurance Company
Boston Capital
Europe
Merchants’ Exchange
Sherman Leland
H. AL S. Dearborn
Stevnen Bates
Ths& Tadm
Reliable Life Assurance
National Loan Fund Life Assurance Society
Great Britain
Othe
Boston Board of Directors
G. M. Thacher
Esa
Franklin Dexter
Benjamin Seaver
Israel Whitney
Edmund A. Grattan
Brigham
Wmn
Elliott
Sea
Elliott & Greig’s
Doane Street
State St
Ths& Ty F
Insurance Company
Thomas ©. Smith
Samuel Tenny
Granrce Homen
Sam Jal
Marine Insurance
HE Hope Insurance Company
State St. Samuel Quincy
Avegastus Lovett
Sissy 12
Mgarine and Fire Insurance
Augusta (Ga
Paghe & Banks, Agents
Kilby St
Harles River Wharf Corporation
Jeremiah Colburn
Barry
Duchesse de
Passage DU Saumon
S. M. Peyser & CO
Atkinson ST
Amorwy Hall
BURR
Niagara
ST. Lawrence
Saguenay
Harbor of Buffalo
Niagara Falls
Hamilton
Toronto
Thousand Islands
Ogdensburg
Prescott
Grand Rapids
Montreal
Citadel
Quebec
Montmorenci Falls
Great Gulf
Saguenay River
Gliddon
Nile
Egypt
Nubia
Grerce R. Guppon
Horticultural Hall
Garden OF Eden
John A. Whipple
David Brewster
John Herschel
Daguerre
Ballard & Prince
Broomfield Street
Brussels
Haines, Webster & Co., Commission Merchants
Dealers IN Exchange & Bullion
Sacramento City
Joseph A. Haines
George E. Webster
WM. H. Stevens
Reed, Wade & Co
Loring, Fiske & Co
I W
F. H. Whittemore & Co
Seignette & Co
N. C. Bly & Co
M. Lienau
Hiram Grimes
C. Davis, Esq
GEO. N. Shaw & Co., General Commission Merchants
Gro. N. Shaw
Cyrus W. Jones
Rob
T. G. Shaw
Middlesex
S. F. Lawrence
Augustus Lerned
Dana & Cass
Thomas Sumner
Patrick Loan
Somerville
Dana & Conn
Samuel Slocomb
Elisha Livermore
Jonton
Messrs Dana & Cone
Asa F. Lawrence
James A. Abbott
Cis
ENE & Oakes, Lion Merchants
Samuel H. Greene
Oakes
Cushing Stetson
Henry Gardner
Reed & Wainwright
I Cunninghams & Cobb
Barclay & Livingston
Maitland, Phelps & Co
Allen & Ae
Jolman, Hutton & Co
H. Greene
Ene Ikne & Co
Central Wharf
Commonwealth OF Massachusetts
Aalek Stetson
Rhodc DA Thayer
Braintree
Roxbury
Boston Post
Leland
Hudson River
Walcott & Slade
Broadstreet
James Freeland
Wicapee Company
Fishkill Landing
Davidson
Alph One
Eee
Caraway
Bell Caraway Seed
Homer & Sprague
India Wheel
Aaron Claflin & CO
Commission Merchants
Ann ST
1 & Sprague
India
WM. B. Reynolds & CO
Pearl Street
Robinson, Wiggin & CO
India St. Ab
Gardiner G. Hubbard
Thorndike’s
State and
Congress Streets
Copissm
Miss Rathbone
Offee
Sape Haytien and Gonaives Coffee
Commercial Wharf
Baker & Morrill
Commercial St. A6
Pata
Henry Pettes & Co
Summer Street
Chambers, &c
Isceptt
Broad Street
Winship & Co
Brighton
TudéeSow
Walp, Tenny & CO
Sarpet Hall
Waine
Haymarket Square
John Doggett &Co
Tapestry Velvet
Isws& Mow
Nonantum
Newton Corner
State of Massachusetts
Massachusetts Block
Court Square
Lovell & CQ
India St
Chamberlin
Alline
King Oak Hill
North Weymouth
Morre! Allen
Pembroke
Blagden
Milton
NOK
Ewton, Eaton & C O
Dorrance, Newton & CO
Newton, Eaton & CO
Oliver B. Dorrance
W. Newton
Milo
WM. 8. Eaton, Geo
H. Jones
Pynece
N. England
MO. H. Pearson & CO
Long Wharf
I. D. Richards & Sons
Elm St
Istt
Brookine
Iscott A. Cotting
LE RK
Mercantile Business
Periodical Depot
T. Wiley, Jr
Harpers’ Publications
Fowler & Well
Hollick
Graham’s, Godey’s
Sartain
Flmnat
Try and City
1Sti Fetridge & CO
Ombard & Whitmore
Lewis Wharf
Schr
Mary Eliza
Jen Benen
Malaga
Gp & Beals
Chambers
Milk
Atkinson Street
Heidsieck
Champagne
France
Messrs Renauld & Francois
Foster & Taylor
Ws& Mom
South Market Street
Harrison Fay
Duffield
Seccomb
Taylor Isiw A2 & CO
Hancock Fire
Curtis, Bouve & CO
Glasgow
Islw
Mi5
Richards & Sons
Elm Street
Tog
Fishers & Chapin
Oe S
Hie
This is just the beginning! Our collection holds over 300 years of history, including rare newspapers, obituaries, marriage records, birth records, and so much more—most of which you won’t find anywhere else!