Dissenting Justices Clash Over Porto Rico Tariffs
The dissenting justices challenge the majority ruling on Porto Rico duties, arguing that without congressional incorporation the island remains foreign to the United States for tariff purposes. They warn that treating acquired territories as colonial under tax laws undermines constitutional limits and could shift power away from the written Constitution.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Congress
United States
Porto Rico
Circuit Court
Southern District of New York
Marshall
Taney
Fuller
Foraker
Porto Fico
Dissenting Opinion in the De Lima Case
Justice McKenna leads a dissent arguing Porto Rico’s tariff status depends on the treaty and the evolving relation to the United States not automatic incorporation. He cites Rice and Fleming vs Page and notes duties may apply under executive and legislative authority during transition from military occupation to treaty implementation.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Taney
Scott
Congress
Louisiana
District of Columbia
United States
Washington
Justice Brown
Downes
Justice White
Shiras
McKenna United
Brown
Marshall
Republic
Missouri
Maryland
Pennsylvania
Justice Harlan
Porto Rico
Spain
Justice Harlan Aain
Justice McKenna
de Lima
White
Justine McKenna
Ve. Rice
Fleming
Page
Dieta
Executive
Legislative Department
Fleming Vs. Page
Legislative
California
Gray
Goetz
Crossman
United States Court of the Southern District of New York
Hawaii
Board of General Appraisers
General Miles
McKenna
Porto Ric
Armstrong
Porto Ricco
Dooley
Bryan comments on decision as republicans and democrats gain support
Lincoln Neb May 27 Mr Bryan notes the decision seems to uphold Republican and Democratic positions in parts and reserves full judgment until he reads the text He expresses hope that the constitution will follow the flag.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Lincoln
Neb
Bryan
Supreme Court rules Porto Rico to New York vessels in coasting trade
The Supreme Court on May 27 decided the new Haus case, ruling that ships sailing between Porto Rico and New York are engaged in the coasting trade.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Washington
The
Supremeourt Today
New Haus
Porto Rico
New York
Also Mentioned on This Page
Texas
Paris
Power of
Courts of Justice
Justice Gray
Harlan
Brewer
Peckham
William Johnson
Livingston
Todd
Duvall
Story
Territories
Loughbrough
Blake
Storey
Butte
Montana
the Star
Mark
Star
Emery
Mr. Bryan
This is just the beginning! Our collection holds over 300 years of history, including rare newspapers, obituaries, marriage records, birth records, and so much more—most of which you won’t find anywhere else!