Abolished Amendment case questions constitutional adoption
The court examines whether a 1882 amendment banning alcoholic beverages was constitutionally agreed to by the eighteenth general assembly and ratified by voters. It finds the enrolled joint resolution does not prove proper two‑house adoption and that journals show insufficient alignment with constitutional requirements, thus the amendment is not part of the constitution.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Lyr
Eral
Petr H. Bov Bovis
Wmn
Miner Ad
Ments Bills
Block and Wright, Cummins & For
Appelles
Sanyers
Eighteenth General Assembly
General Assembly
State
Lode
House
Senate
A. T. McCancer
The
Bowe
Jane
Ous
Bar
Cooley
Les Ee
Missouri
Addite
State of
Nevada
Swift
Kid
Secretary of State
New York
Indiana
Cass
Spangler
Jacoby
Fila
the People
Stame
Miller
Martin
Burr
Ross
Ark
the State
Platt
James Va. Hutchinson
Ala
Moody Ve State
Smithe Vra Garth
Arkansas
Board of Supervisors
Henan
Minn
Southwark Bank
Commonwealth
Pa. St
Justions
N. Rt
N. H
Mahoney
Mich
Berry
Oa Company
Ind
Osburn Va Stanley
Appellent
Ilinois
Statte
Cnr Jadtee
Secretary of
Hous
Geo Journala
Yen A
Eee Wit Ee
Haynes
N. W
House of the
House Journal
Kansas
Howard County
Areaa
Ip Taden
Tte
Cateeniaa
Judicaary
Journal of
Union
Pm Senate
Iowa
Lowa
Geneal Assembly
Ouncel
Ip Titie
Purose
Monway
Hen Way
Hemenway
Geners Assembly
Ware Otis Pai
Foowa Herald
Igeath General Assembly
Gous
Constiage
Nineral Assembly
di Fereenth
Carraan
Whak
S. Foward
Park
Platina
Hegina
Amd
Department OF
Y HR
Dissent on Jurisdiction and Consti tutional Amendment
The piece analyzes whether legislative determinations on the eighteenth and nineteenth assemblies bind courts and citizens. It contrasts judicial reviews of jurisdiction with acts that may be erroneous but not void and discusses publication, notice, and procedural requirements for amending the Iowa constitution under Article 10. The argument centers on whether the liquor ban amendment became operative and binding.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Nineteenth Assembly
Shankas
Loffer
Iowa
Cooper Va
Sunderland
Baker
Chapline
Bonsal
Isett
Marrow
Weed
Ballinger
Tarbell
Pursley
Baker Va. Cha
Eighteenth
Goon Assembly
Senate
General Assembly
Duncombe
Npoe
Hinetecats
Brad Bing
Betts Va
Pick
Maston
Mott
Wheat
Hayden Va. Young
Johna
Ee Ae
Wend
X Watkins
Primlez
City of
Ryan Ve. Varga
Ryan Va. Varga
Also Mentioned on This Page
Kaidgers
M. Een
Ellion
Ani
J. Ammi
Coursonaire
Sherman Ve
Pagborn Ve. Oung
Go. Ve
Brown
Nossa
Netion
Urther
Eee
Ely Bente Gebeeneseee
Gpirton
Jeudgh Breck
TNR Try
Shawhan
Cogper Va
Shee Wm
Quinton
Ryan
Varga
West Va
Macklot
Davenport
Ian Mek
Young
I Johns
Bindsall