Will Moderation Moderate A Prohibition Era Query
A fragmentary opinion piece questions whether moderation can curb extremism amid a debate on a large moderating act. It contrasts calls for moderation with activists critiquing prohibition era policies and hints at evaluating moderation through historical experience and rhetoric.
Legal Beer Would Mean Better Hotels
Prohibition has drained hotel revenue and damaged services. The Beer and Wine League of Manitoba argues legal beer and light wines would raise hotel standards, create jobs and wages, and expand public revenue while countering bootleggers. Quebec shows such policy is feasible and promotes temperance.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Manitoba
Beer and Wine League of Manitoba
Prohibition Reform Examined in Manitoba Debate
H. P. Reed argues for the Moderation Bill and private sale while criticizing the government liquor commission. He cites lax permit controls, potential direct sales, and aggressive advertising by distillers as risks. He urges voters to choose freedom and true temperance in the upcoming referendum.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Ehell
Dominion
Commission
British Columbia
A. E. Cooke
Vancouver
Manitoba
Dominion House
Manitoba Free Press
Geo. Black
M.P
Yukon
Liquor Control Board
Lieuver Control Board
Manitoba Commission
Russell Temperance Campaign Committee
Middie
Middleton
Middlton
Jimmy
H. P. Reed
Prohibition case weakened by actual experience
In a June 11 1923 letter from Russell Manitoba to The Banner editor, Middleton contends that prohibition would collapse if crimes and hunger linked to alcohol are not prevented. The writer argues actual enforcement shows these issues persist or worsen, undercutting the prohibition argument.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Russell, Man
The
Banner
Middleton
Law
F. C. Middleton
Zed
Prohibition Debate Calls Church to Lead or Yield
A letter to The Banner argues the Manitoba Temperance Act depends on public support, condemns moral suasion alone, and urges churches to cultivate consent while the state enforces the law. It cautions history shows church overreach harms Christianity and warns against coercive governance.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Middleton
Manitoba
England
Canada
Letter on Prohibition and League Bill Influence
A reader argues beekeepers and distillers will back the League and predicts a large bootlegger turnout against prohibition. The writer contends the League bill’s defeat would boost illegal business and thanks the recipient for publishing the letter.
MENTIONED IN THIS ARTICLE
Talderdash
E. & McQuarril
Also Mentioned on This Page
Main St. Russell
Joseph McIntyre
Safety Deposit Boxes
McNutt
R. C. Jamieson
P. R. Fleming
J. Mitchell
Quebec
Beer and Wine League of
Pacific Coast
Canadian Rockies
Jasmer Park Lodge
Jasper National Park
Mt. Robson Park
Prince Rupert
Eastern
Toronto
Niagara
Thousand Islands
Cuaint Cid
St. Lawrence
Maritime Provinces
Quisian
W. Sianielea
Madini
Agini
Canadian National Railways
Shellmouth, Man
McLaren & Sons
Draymen
House
Russell
R. T. Ricou
J. S. Warrington
W. J. Bates Ee
Main St
An An
Westbourne St
Ravssell
R. T. W. Shaw
Wilson
Glen
Attorneys-at-Law
Notaries Public
Angusville
Binscorth
Rossburn
Pratt & Lauman
Bite
Lirtle and Foxwarren
Lawrence C. Boulton
United Grain Growers’ Securities Ltd
J. Roy Sypher
E. S. McQuarrie
Shellmouth
C. C. Graham
D. D
L. D
H. C. Hodgson
Curry Building
Post Office
Winnipeg
Herbert Frank Payne
Miniota Farmers’ Mutual
Cheapest Insurance Co
A. S. Wallace
Army and Navy
Smellie
Main Street
V. Smith
J. Maher
Tecretary
C.F
E. Yoxall
Oddfellows’ Hall
Lodge Queen of the West No
I. O. O. F. Hall
W. Fenton
W. Pres
H. J. Pettitt
Watrous
Saskatoon
Wainwright
Edmonton
Mt. Robson
Prince George
Kitwanga
Terrace
Victoria
C. G. Curdt
Ontario Veterinary College
Royal Society of Veterinary Surgeons of Toronto
Queen’s Hotel
A. E. Page
Ont. Vet. College
Toronto University
Gibson’ House
Mountain Avenue
Miniota Farmer’s Mutual Firm Insurance Company
Walter Hemgroff
Alfred Clee
Frene
the Sun Life Assufrance Co. OF
R. W. Elswood
P. O. Box
Crystal Rebekah Lodge No
Jean Houston, N. G
Hall
Mary Glen R
W. J. Quinlan
Dist
Pass
IO. O. F. Hall
W. W. W. Wilson, Ww. M
B. D.ucas
E. Beamis Worthy