Hide Article Text (OCR)
esedn a ory, aniear-ownany.ringimb-lent ear-3 intoryluceasreenovienta-Ad-thcnt-8 Ofsinglavetioniast-ime,leentheitchand tant the and m tithe Incendsbyra-irre-ivel-ght-■oadandffer-d of ,’ital la— and :and izis.ieen, *t;est-rge, as tide-Ger-ired . theandfourharp : Or-it 71lark142JURIST IS FIRM IKFACE Of CRITHISMJudge Coleman Refusesto Grant Papers toEnemy AliensBaltimore, June 13 (^—Federal Judge William C. Coleman, who lias consistently declined to grant final citizenship papers to enemy aliens, who left Germany after Hitler came to power, stood Arm today despite criticism that he was “arbitrary and in conflict with other courts.Baltimore City Solicitor Simon Sobeloff, who represented a number of enemy aliens seeking naturalization, criticized Judge Coleman during the case of Rabbi Simon Schwab of Baltimore, who left Germany In 1936. Final action was postponed on the rabbi’s application.Judge Coleman said his policy did not Imply any unworthiness among those before him, but said too many enemy aliens had been admitted to citizenship and that some of them had been proven guilty of subversive activity.The naturalization laws, he continued, do not require granting of citizenship hut say it may be granted. Judge Coleman remarked that in these times it was impossible to make such investigations of applicants as he considered desirable.Sobeloff replied that Earl G. Harrison, U. S. Commissioner of Immigration, was in court and ready to testify in favor of today’s applicants. Sobeloff also asserted thatStoSBait McCor Price today 54S sti and cl 13.3 pregula The the 12 in cas ing gc than t riod u based.A 51of the«■charts OPA a by Me1 lationMAI(visedtake i and £ funds.Mrs not ta Then, Martij cal dibrothsArmy all the JammissioT. Ri2,000 other judges in the United IofficeiStates had taken a view in direct conflict with that of Judge Coleman while only one other agreed with him.Judge Coleman’s rejoinder was an Insistence that they proceed, to the next case—that of Dr. William Henry Buschke and his wife, Marie. Dr. Buschke, a research worker at the Johns Hopkins Hospital, said he had been in this country ten years.Sobeloff argued that to deny them citizenship would he to set up a policy in conflict with the will of Congress and the established practice of the Office of Immigration.Judge Coleman disagreed, ruling that the same conclusions applied as in Rabbi Schwab’s case and ordering final action deferred.In this instance, the court remarked that “while it may be a hardship on these people and while it may be that every one of them isentitled to citizenship, if this rule prevents any person who is not entitled to citizenship from becoming a citizen, then the policy is justified.He added that it had been said he had denied full citizenship even to men bearing arms for the U. S., then commented that the Army and Navy could be deceived, as well as the immigration authorities.at thehim i. ence ' Nor been Well wastT straiWheethe pisaid hFedagentsLeonobtairFarm'WoWas ter Jo for th pitch basebt ers an Wichi The war b Has) ing or to pa: a resagreec
Newspaper Details
Hagerstown Morning Herald
Hagerstown, Maryland, US
Wed, Jun 14, 1944
Page 2
Full Page
Clipped by
Anonymous
USA 24 May 2019
Other Publications Near Hagerstown, Maryland
Hagers Town Mail
Hagerstown Morning News
Hagerstown Odd Fellow
Hagers Town Torch Light and Public Advertiser
Hagerstown Torch Light
