Now that the Candidates Chess Tournament in Cur acao is Over, it is time to discuss in some detail just what happened there. Remember that the winner has won the right to face Mikhail Botvinnik for the chess cham pionship of the world. Of the eight masters participa ting, four were Jewish: Bobby Fischer of the United States and Ewfim Geller, Victor Kerchnoi and Mikhail Tal of the Soviet Union. The winner? Tigran Petrosian, the Armenian from Russia. He scored 17% points, out of a possible 27. Geller and Paul Keres, also of Russia, had 17 points, and Fischer 14. Kerchnoi made 1314. Tal, the shocker of the tournament took sick, retired before the entire business ended, and made only 7 points. Fischer got off to a bad start, losing three times in his first four games. He ended up with 8 wins, 7 losses and 12 drawn games. He lost to Geller twice, to Kerchnoi twice, to Pal Benko (U.S.), to Keres and to Petrosian. Petrosian, who is 33, was the only grandmaster who went through the tournament without the loss of a single game. He won 8 and drew 19. Keres, the sentimental favorite, lost to Fischer in an early round and, because he is an older player and was tired at the end, he also lost to Benko. These de feats cost him the right to meet Botvinnik. There were some reports that the Russians, when they faced one another, tried to draw and did not go all out to win; that they all worked hard to beat the out siders, Fischer in particular. Perhaps. But Fischer was erratic at the outset and never could make up for his poor start. He won from every opponent, except Petro sian. This all means that, next year, Petrosian, not Fischer (who had been the favorite) will meet Botvinnik. Then there will be ‘another long, drawn-out series to deter mine the next challenger. In effect, then, Fischer won’t have a chance to challenge for the championship until he is out of his teens. He will not, as he thought he would, be a very young title-holder. He is not, as he likes to believe, the best player in the world. If he loses his arrogance, it may improve his game. On the other hand, his confidence may be badly shaken. Look what happened to Tal. He won the title from Botvinnik and then, when he lost to Botvinnik, he seemed to lose his brilliant form, and came in last in the recent tourna ment. The future is uncertain for him—and for Fischer as well.