Plea bargain nets killer life sentenceBy Lynn DeBruinTribune writer__A judge on Wednesday spared a Mesa man from a death sentence, citing the prosecution's decision to offer a sweetheart deal to a co-defendant who admitted knowing the murder would occur.Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Maurice Portley sentenced Darrell “Pete” Paxton to life in prison for the 1991 murder of 18-year-old Eric Edwards.He must serve at least 25 years before becoming eligible for parole.The sentence brought mixed reactions from the victim’s parents.“I would like to know he will never ever get out of jail. That’s not going to happen now,” said Debbi Edwards. “The death penalty would have (accomplished that). But I really don’t know how I feel about the death penalty.”Testimony by Josh Smaulding, ir accordance with his plea, was critical in convicting Paxton of the Dec. 4, 1991, shooting. On Wednesday, the deal was the only thing that saved Paxton, who has denied he was the shooter.“The state was aware that (Smaulding) admitted to a polygraph examiner on Dec. 19,1991, that he knew the murder would occur, did nothing to stop it and profited by it,” Portley said.But instead of trying to have Smaulding testify consistent with that, Portley said, prosecutors merely charged him with theft and hindering prosecution and allowed him to plead to lesser offenses unrelated to the case.The plea netted Smaulding, who was 17 at the time of the shooting, three years probation. He went to prison for two years only after violating probation.Portley said that factor outweighed the cruel, heinous nature of the crime.County Attorney Rick Romley took issue with Portley’s finding and indicated prosecutors would file an objection, claiming it does not comply with current law.Romley also defended the deal given Smaulding.“But for the cooperation of Joshua Smaulding, the case in all likelihood would have never been solved, and the victim’s body might never have been discovered, and the killer might have gone free,” Romley said in a written statement.Smaulding testified that Paxton without warning fired through the driver’s seat of Edwards’ car while Edwards was driving them around that morning. He said Paxton then reached around and pumped five more shots into Edwards’ side.