LIMITED TIME ONLY

GET 50% OFF

For New & Returning
Customers

Claim Your 50% Off
Black Friday

Article clipped from Seattle Star

Prominent Tacoma Lawyer Says Hanford Slept on Befich While Juror Left Court Room—“Cocktail” Evidence Cor roborated by Two Witnesses—Hanford’s Son Calls Wit ness Vile Name After He Testified He Saw Judge Drunk en Street. Testimony by G@uvnor Teats, prominent Tacoma attorney, that it is necessary to have a mighty good case before Hanford where a poor man is conceived in a damage suit, testimony corroborating the “Judge Hanford cocktail” evidence by George Jacobs, the real estate man, and testimony by John C. Whitlock, a lawyer, which led young E. M. Han ford, the judge's son, to call him a foul name, and to cause Whitlock to make @ move as though to strike him, were the startling develop ments in the Hanford investigation this morning. JUROR WENT OUT WHILE JUDGE SLEPT Teats, who is a member of the legislature, and who has practiced in Washington for about 26 years, testified that he saw Judge Hanford go sound asleep during the trial of a case at Tacoma, that a juror went out of the courtroom and stayed out for about five minutes without the judge knowing it. This was the only occasion, he said, when he knew positively that the judge was asleep. At other times, he said, he thought the judge was asleep, but he seemed to be able to follow the test on cross-examination. Attorney Hughes, for Hanford, attempted to get Tears to say that Judge Hanford was fair toward poor litigants. STRONG CASE NECESSARY FOR POOR MAN Teats emphatically asserted in answer to this: “You've got to have a mighty good case to get by the court.” The witness said that until a reform instituted a few years ago by the circuit court of appeals, which eliminated the possibility of whole sale non-sults by the lower court, “it was a pretty hard proposition to be up against Judge Hanford where a poor litigant was concerned... Asked if he himself was not fairly successful in Judge Hanford’s court, Teats replied: “Yes, but I wouldn't take a case into ‘his court without it being a dead cinch.” , Preceding Teats, several bartenders were called to testify ing their knowledge of the “Hanford cocktail.” William the Mecca saloon said he was not sure that he had heard of it before the congressional hearing was started. Fred W. Powell of the Saratoga bar said he did not hear of it until three or four days ago. W. E. Kayes, another bartender, testified to the same effect. SUBSTANTIATE “COCKTAIL” EVIDENCE W. J. Kerrigan, the real estate man, with whom Jacobs made the bet that a “Hanford cocktail,” when ordered at any one of nine would bring forth a dry martini with an onion it it, and not an olive, testified that he lost the bet; that they went into the Rathskeller, or dered a “Hanford cocktail” and got a martini with an onion without fur ther questions being asked. Clarence Holden, automobile man, testified to the same effect. He accompanied the bettors to the Rathskeller on that occasion. Jack Widner, the bartender at the Rathskeller who served them, tes tified this morning that he gave the usual kind of martini; that he al ways put an onion in it instead of an olive. Attorney Hughes for Hanford attempted to prove by the cross-ex amination of Kerrigan and Holden that Jacobs always took an onion himself in his dry martini, and that Kerrigan simply “fell” for an easy bet. SAW HANFORD DRUNK ON STREET John C. Whitlock, who has been practicing law here for 20 years, testified that he had seen Judge Hanford drunk on Second avenue one afternoon this year. He described the judge as walking “unsteadily.” The judge's complexion indicated that he was under the influence of liquor, he said. He watched him for half a block, Whitlock said. Answering a question by the committee directly, Whitlock said: I will say the judge was somewhat intoxicated.” CALLS WHITLOCK VISE NAME In cross-examination, Whitlock testified that he always found Judge Hanford “fair and upright” in legal matters he had before him. When Whitlock got off the stand, young E. M. Hanford crossed him and called him a vile name. Whitlock, who is an old man, made a move to strike him, and barely touched his face. Young Hanford immediately walked out of the courtroom. Representative McCoy recalled Whitlock and the lat ter testified to what happened. William H. Gorham, an attorney who had previously given character testimony in behalf of Hanford, was then called and he identified the “young man” to whom Whitlock re ferred as “Ned Hanford, Judge Hanford’s son,” Dr. H. EB. Allen, John P. Hartman, attorney for the Northern Pa cific, and Alex M. Winston, of Spokane, gave character testimony in favor of Judge Hanford this morning.
Newspaper Details

Seattle Star

Seattle, Washington, US

Tue, Jul 16, 1912

Page 1

Full Page
Clipped by
Profile Icon
Anonymous

USA 17 Nov 2026