THE EDITOR: Sir—The Journal of the Over-Seas League with its immense circulation is read the world over, and contribu tions to the same are taken to be authentic, great care should therefore be taken by those who contribute arti cles for publication. In the Coronation Number (January, 1937) of this Journal appears an article under the caption “Local Customs in Jamaica by Mrs. Lucie-Smith (pre sumably of Jamaica). This article states ‘Jamaica has changed but little in the last 100 years, and many of the quaint customs and superstitions still survive.” One hundred years send us back to the days of slavery. Can Mrs. Lucie- Smith be serious when she writes that Jamaica has changed but little since then in customs and superstition? She writes of the present, but is it keeping to facts when she states “The ‘John Canoe’ procession is still held annual ly in Jamaica and goes from house to house, dancing and demanding largesses”; and that “John Canoe” and “Horse-head” go hand in hand? As a custom this has for very many years ceased to exist. “Annancy stories” (fables) are still told, but to definitely state “the Negroes are all terrified of ‘duppies’ which, of course, are ghosts—these are supposed to inhabit cotton trees and come out to sit on the branches at night, so that no self-respecting person will pass un der one after dusk, nor will he chop up a cotton tree for firewood for fear that the homeless ‘duppies’ should haunt him ever after’—is extremely far fetched, and is in fact ridiculous. A further statement of this lady is, “Another bugbear used for frighten ing naughty children is the ‘rolling calf’ who is suppor to roam the roads at night, dragging his chain after him, his eyes shining like fire, who will surely chase any evil-doers who may be abroad.” . . I have from time to time visited every town and every village of any size or importance in Jamaica and my knowledge of the people is appreciable, and I am convinced that not one in ten