ers, John Haynes, form the attorney general's office, John Brandon, state auditor, have declined to recommend commuta tion of sentence. Pete B. Jar man, secretary of state and third board member, has filed no report in the case because of ill ness. Haynes and Brandon differed on the clemency plea of . Willie Williams, Mobile, sentenced to death as a ringleader in a gasoline station holdup and gun fight with police. Brandon recommended commutation, Haynes did not. Both recommended clemency for Frank Porter, a negro from Mo bile, facing the death penalty for murder.