Judge Moore, at the Sheppar ton General Sessions this morn ing dismissed an appeal by Frank Joyce, half caste aborig inal against a sentence of nine months goal when he was con victed in the Shepparton court on March 15 of assault by kicking. Lorraine Ruby Nelson gave evidence of Joyce assaulting her on March 1 while she was asleep and kicking her in the leg breaking a bone. A long list of prior convictions was read out against Joyce. Mr P. W. Wel tham, who prosecuted for the Crown, pointed out Joyce had spent more time in goal than out] since 1946.