Winnipeg Free Press (Newspaper) - March 29, 2015, Winnipeg, Manitoba C M Y K PAGE A10
POLL
Will the
closure of
Future Shop
affect your
shopping?
Previous polls:
Are you in favour of relocating
Winnipeg’s rail yards and lines?
Yes. It would free up land and
reduce the risk of accidents. 61%
No. Too expensive and
complicated. 33%
Don’t know. 6%
Has your opinion of Jets goalie
Ondrej Pavelec changed given his
latest winning streak?
Nope, I’ve always been a fan
of his. 45%
Nope, I’ll never be a fan of his. 13%
Yes, he has won me over with this
last stretch of goaltending. 42%
Do you think Doug McNeil is the right
choice for CAO?
Yes, he has lots of experience. 15%
Yes, I like that he wants city hall
to be more transparent. 15%
No, I don’t agree with his ideas. 12%
I’m not sure, I don’t know much
about him. 58%
Do you agree with the appointment of
Janice Filmon as the next lieutenantgovernor
of Manitoba?
Yes. 54%
No. 46%
Should the city be using malathion
against mosquitoes?
Yes. 67%
No. 33%
OPINION WINNIPEG FREE PRESS, MONDAY, APRIL 21, 2014
A 10
Winnipeg Free Press
Sunday, March 29, 2015
winnipegfreepress. com
Vote online at
winnipegfreepress. com
R EADERS were deeply divided when the City
of Winnipeg said it will review its use of
malathion to kill mosquitoes after a United
Nations study classified the chemical as probably
carcinogenic.
The denizens of Wolseley must be ecstatic at this
report.
— mr. spelchek
I wonder how the workers applying malathion for
the benefit of Winnipeggers feel about risking their
lives through exposure to a probable carcinogen in
order to save the rest of us a few mosquito bites.
— Spence Furby
Let’s put all this into perspective.
Yes, malathion is a harmful chemical, but the
risk from this chemical is minimized by controlling
usage through ultra- low- volume fogging that
results in a very small amount of exposure.
— Facts_ and_ Logic
I don’t worry about this for myself, as I am in my
60s, but I do think that for the sake of our children
and grandchildren we need to stop exposing them
to these toxins, even if there is only a small chance
they are carcinogenic. The intended effects of these
insecticides are only temporary, but the unintended
consequences on human health and the environment
may last for lifetimes.
— xwdman
Pretty much anything is deadly in big enough
quantities. The study in question was focused on
agricultural workers involved in the application
of malathion — so, frequent, prolonged exposure
to very large quantities and concentrations. It’s a
huge leap to suggest the amount of exposure from
occasional fogging is also dangerous. And you
should note the scientists have not made that leap,
only readers have.
— squonk
I don’t like mosquitoes, and I like cancer even
less. The city’s policy on using malathion attempts
to strike a balance between those who oppose the
use of this pesticide for health and ecological reasons
and those who believe it is the only effective
way of reducing mosquito populations. It’s only
used when the trap counts get very high, and Winnipeggers
have the choice of opting out.
However, considering it is ‘ probably’ a carcinogen,
I hope the City of Winnipeg devotes more
resources to eradicating mosquitoes the natural
way, through biological means and safer alternatives
to sprays that poison beneficial insects and
may harm birds and other wildlife as well as the
human population.
— 23698142
Great, more ammo for the buffer- zone fanatics.
— Ceedger
Please take a step back and think. A very harmful
chemical is sprayed while we sleep.
— Winnipeg: Canada’s Best City
It looks like the city could be exposed to legal
suits if it continues to spray.
— trb22
If only money- squandering politicians were effective
against mosquitoes.
— Woofers
Study’s finding sparks debate on malathion
Y OUNG men and women from inner- city
Winnipeg made their neighbourhood
proud Monday night. Six youths who
grew up playing basketball at the Spence
Neighbourhood Association brought home
championship banners.
Making Spence Street sports history,
youths from the neighbourhood played for
championship teams at the Manitoba varsity
high school basketball finals, for Oak Park
and Sisler high schools. And last weekend,
youths from Spence won the AAA junior
varsity girls championship, playing for the
University of Winnipeg Collegiate.
The Spence Neighbourhood Association’s
barrier- free sports programming is helping
create winners.
The most valuable players of both the
AAAA girls and boys provincial champions
played their first league basketball games
through the Spence programs: Kyanna
Pingue- Giles of the Sisler Spartans and
William Sesay of the Oak Park Raiders. The
same can be said for the MVP of the AAA
junior varsity girls final, Alicia Dunsford,
of the U of W Collegiate and her all- star
twin sister, Rachelle Dunsford. Likewise for
Sisler all- star Kyia Pingue- Giles ( Kyanna’s
twin) and Liyanah Serapio, a Team Manitoba
player and starter for Sisler.
More than 300 inner- city youths participate
in the association’s programs, which
eliminate barriers for youth in sports. All get
to play sports, be part of a team and build
healthy relationships with coaches and adult
mentors.
The success of these student athletes,
supported by strong, loving families, is what
happens when we invest in inner- city youth.
Athletes in the program are supported by the
U of W, the Spence Neighbourhood Association,
the Boys and Girls Clubs of Winnipeg
and the Immigrant and Refugee Community
Organization of Manitoba. Together, these
groups help provide uniforms, transportation
to games, quality coaching and healthy
snacks. Family and mentors supported these
youth as they developed as athletes, moving
on to elite teams and competition. It was a
community effort.
Providing recreation to inner- city youth
requires a no- barrier approach. Fundraising
by the neighbourhood association helps cover
league fees, transportation, a co- ordinator
for the teams and the committed investment
of volunteer coaches and mentors.
Strategic investment in youth takes time
to reap rewards: We drove these kids to
basketball games for the first time back in
2008- 2009.
However, there is work to be done so all
young people have a chance to fully participate.
Winnipeg’s child- poverty rate is the
third- highest among large cities in Canada,
behind Vancouver and St. John’s, World Vision’s
Poverty at Your Doorstep report states.
Economic circumstances should not determine
where you finish in life. Youths prove
to us they are more than willing to take
advantage of opportunities to excel, where
they are supported.
How many other youths have the same
kind of talent that could drive our city
forward but remain stifled by barriers to
participating in school, good housing and
adequate mental- health supports? How many
artists, athletes, doctors, researchers, executives
and lawyers are we missing out on,
who could raise our collective achievement
to new heights? Supporting young people so
they can realize their dreams starts with
community- based programs that are close to
home.
More needs to be done to support youths.
Once these elite athletes started playing at
the high school level, many had to leave their
immediate neighbourhood, often by bus, in
the darkness of Winnipeg winters, to attend
schools with high- level sports. One pair of
siblings earned scholarships to the U of W
Collegiate.
For all Winnipeg youths to excel and
drive our city forward, we need to provide
resources to support these same high- quality
relationships and opportunities in sports,
arts and education in every neighbourhood.
This means adequate funding at the city,
provincial and federal levels.
This is our collective challenge. If these
young all- stars are brave enough to learn
and to grow, we should be brave enough to
provide the supports required to realize their
dreams.
Jamil Mahmood, executive director of the
Spence Neighbourhood Association, and Nick
Tanchuk, a former sports co- ordinator at the
association, are research affiliates at the Canadian
Centre for Policy Alternatives- Manitoba.
By Jamil Mahood and Nick Tanchuck
Neighbourhood program breaks down barriers
JOHN WOODS / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS FILES
Kyanna Pingue- Giles of the Sisler Spartans makes a basket against the Oak Park Raiders on Monday.
A_ 10_ Mar- 29- 15_ FP_ 01. indd A10 3/ 28/ 15 6: 50: 12 PM