Winnipeg Free Press (Newspaper) - August 30, 2015, Winnipeg, Manitoba C M Y K PAGE A6
A 6 WINNIPEG FREE PRESS, SUNDAY, AUGUST 30, 2015 WORLD winnipegfreepress. com
H AVANA — Julio Hernandez
is a telecommunications
engineer, but like
almost anyone else in
Cuba who wants to get on the Internet,
to do so he must crouch on a
dusty street corner with his laptop,
inhaling car exhaust and enduring
sweltering heat. That privilege costs
him US$ 2 an hour, expensive in a
nation where the average state- paid
salary is US$ 20 a month.
The Internet is essential for business,
finance, communications and
information, but today hasn’t dawned
in Cuba, which still has some of the
worst Internet access in the world.
It’s restricted to a few workplaces and
fewer than four per cent of homes, including
those of senior officials, foreign executives,
members of the media, doctors and artists.
It’s unavailable on the country’s 1991- vintage
2G mobile- phone network.
President Raúl Castro’s government
recognizes the problem but faces a dilemma:
how to expand Internet access to boost its
economy and satisfy its population while
maintaining control of information. Cuban
officials say at least 50 per cent of the population
will have residential Internet service
and 60 per cent will have mobile phones by
2020, without saying how they’ll achieve that.
“ It’s stupid how much they’ve delayed the
inevitable,” said Carlos Alzugaray, a former
Cuban ambassador to the European Union
and professor at the University of Havana.
“ Meanwhile, we’re losing ground — we’re in
the Stone Age.”
The Internet was used by 30 per cent of
Cuba’s population in 2014, according to the
International Telecommunication Union,
compared with 57 per cent in its ally Venezuela
and 87 per cent in the United States.
Key government ministries, joint ventures,
universities and hospitals have Internet access,
but using it is a slow trip back in time
with a dial- up modem. Forget about streaming
video or downloading or uploading large
files.
For the lucky few with access at work or
home, email and an intranet of approved sites
downloaded to local servers is as good as it
gets. A file that would take four minutes, 10
seconds to download in Cuba would be instantaneous
in most North American homes and
workplaces.
Broadband service is restricted to top
tourist hotels, select business centres and
approved media outlets.
That’s slowly starting to change. State- run
cyber cafés opened two years ago, charging
US$ 4.50 an hour. Last month, the state telecom
monopoly Etecsa created 35 broadband
Wi- Fi hot spots across the island, where the
public can surf the web, as Hernandez does.
It’s not as fast as broadband in the U. S., but
it’s a huge improvement.
“ Before this, we had nothing,” said Ramon
Mazon, a pizzeria worker who travelled 25
kilometres to an outdoor hot spot in central
Havana for a video chat with relatives in the
U. S.
“ In this day and age, we should have access
to Internet a few hours a day, just like we
have food ration cards.”
Thanks to new regulations issued by U. S.
President Barack Obama as part of his push
to normalize relations with Cuba, U. S. companies
— from IT giants such as Google Inc.
to mobile phone providers AT& T and Verizon
Communications — could help lift Cuba out
of the Internet Stone Age.
But it’s not clear the Castro government
wants a lift from them, at that might risk
ceding some control and influence to American
companies.
In the rare broadband Wi- Fi oases — the
lobbies of top tourist hotels — tech- savvy
young Cubans discreetly surf on their
phones, circumventing log- on fees as high
as US$ 17 an hour at one Spanish chain hotel.
They share Wi- Fi connections or use apps
to tap into servers overseas. They’re doing
what’s needed to “ resolver” — overcome the
barriers to online access in Cuba.
Etecsa is testing 3G and 4G cellphone
service that could provide Internet access,
although there’s been no indication of who
could get it.
The Castro government has long blamed
the U. S. trade embargo for “ blockading”
Cuba, condemning it to being a technology
backwater. That barrier disappeared in January,
when Obama made it legal for U. S. telecommunications
companies to do business in
Cuba — from erecting mobile phone towers
and positioning satellites to laying fibre- optic
cable and selling iPhones.
In the past several months, U. S. companies
have made quiet visits, assessing the market
and weighing opportunities, though none has
yet made a deal with the government.
A team from Google visited in June and
suggested it could provide antennas to bring
high- speed connections to 70 per cent of
homes within three years at little to no cost
to Cuba, according to journalist Fernando
Ravsberg, who writes the blog Cartas Desde
Cuba ( Letters from Cuba.)
The idea has been met by questions from
the Cuban government, suspicious Google
may have ties to the U. S. State Department
and fearful the U. S. could use the technology
to spy on Cuba or scheme for regime change,
according to Cuban officials who asked not
to be identified. Google spokeswoman Niki
Christoff declined to comment.
Harold Cardenas, co- founder of the blog
La Joven Cuba ( Young Cuba), said he wants
an open Internet as soon as possible, but he
understands why his government may be
hesitant to make deals with U. S. companies.
“ If you were in a dispute with your neighbour
for 50 years and now you’re friends, it’s
a little risky to give your neighbour access
to your whole garden, because you might
be fighting again tomorrow,” he said. “ A
country’s telecommunications is a matter of
national security.”
At the same time, Cardenas added: “ The
government has to give Internet to the people
or it’s going to lose the hearts and minds of
Cuban youth. And that’s already happening.”
Cuba may turn to China for an answer.
A document was leaked last month that
purports to be Etecsa’s plan to build residential
broadband using Chinese telecommunications
companies ZTE Corp. and Huawei
Technologies Co. rather than American
companies.
Critics say the Castro government is
slow- rolling broadband to restrict access to
information. Cuba blocks pornography and
anti- Castro websites, but there are fewer
firewalls than there are in China.
Websites including those of Yahoo, the
State Department and blogs such as Cartas
Desde Cuba and La Joven Cuba, which
sometimes are critical of the government,
were easily accessible this month to those
who could reach the Internet. Cubans can
travel freely now and have access to foreign
television via memory sticks sold widely on
the black market.
“ To open or not open the Internet is a
silly argument because Cuban censors have
already lost control of the information people
have,” Ravsberg said.
— Bloomberg News
By Indira A. R. Lakshmanan
‘ To open or not open the Internet is a silly argument
because Cuban censors have already lost control of the information people have’
— journalist Fernando Ravsberg
Tangled web
Cuba stuck in the past when it comes to Internet access
DESMOND BOYLAN / THE ASSOCIATED PRESS FILES
A youth uses his smartphone in Havana this summer. Despite recently launched Wi- Fi hot spots, Cuba has some of the worst web access in the world.
NEW ORLEANS — Residents of Mississippi and
Louisiana marked the 10th anniversary of hurricane
Katrina on Saturday by ringing church bells,
laying wreaths and celebrating the resiliency of a
region still recovering from a disaster that killed
more than 1,800 people and caused US$ 151 billion
in damage.
Addressing dignitaries at New Orleans’ memorial
to the unclaimed and unidentified dead, Mayor
Mitch Landrieu spoke of the dark days after the
monstrous storm and how the city’s residents
leaned on each other for support.
“ We saved each other,” the mayor said. “ New
Orleans will be unbowed and unbroken.”
In Mississippi, churches along coastal Hancock
County tolled their bells in unison Saturday morning
to mark the 10th anniversary of the day Katrina
made landfall in the state.
Eloise Allen, 80, wept softly into a tissue and
leaned against her rusting Oldsmobile as bells
chimed at Our Lady of the Gulf Catholic Church
just across a two- lane street from a sun- drenched
beach at Bay St. Louis.
She said her home, farther inland, was damaged
but livable. Her daughter lost her home in nearby
Waveland. Many of her friends and neighbours
suffered similarly.
“ I feel guilty,” she said. “ I didn’t go through
what all the other people did.”
In Biloxi, Miss., clergy and community leaders
gathered at a newly built baseball park for a memorial
to Katrina’s victims and later that evening
the park was to host a concert celebrating the recovery.
During a prayer service at a seaside park in
Gulfport, former Mississippi governor Haley
Barbour praised volunteers who worked on the
Katrina recovery. He said more than 954,000 volunteers
came from around the country to Mississippi
in the first five years after the storm, and
many were motivated by faith.
“ They thought it was God’s command to try to
help people in need,” Barbour said.
Katrina’s force caused a massive storm surge
that scoured the Mississippi coast, pushed boats
far inland and wiped houses off the map, leaving
only concrete front steps to nowhere.
Glitzy casinos and condominium towers have
been rebuilt. But overgrown lots and empty slabs
speak to the slow recovery in some communities.
In New Orleans, wide- scale failures of the levee
system on Aug. 29, 2005, left 80 per cent of the city
under water.
New Orleans has framed the 10th anniversary
as a showcase designed to demonstrate to the
world how far the city has come. In a series of
events in the week leading up to the anniversary,
the city has held lectures, given tours of the levee
improvements and released a resiliency plan. U. S.
President Barack Obama and former president
George W. Bush both visited the city.
Many parts of the city have rebounded phenomenally
while many residents — particularly in the
black community — still struggle.
In New Orleans’ Lower Ninth Ward, residents
and community activists gathered Saturday at the
levee where water broke through and submerged
the neighbourhood.
After several speeches, a parade snaked through
the neighbourhood while music played from boom
boxes and people sold water from ice chests under
the hot sun.
Wilmington Sims watched the parade from his
front porch. He helped build the porch before Katrina,
then had to re- do the work after flooding
from the levee break damaged the first floor.
He said the outpouring of support was “ uplifting”
but many people still need help and the Lower
Ninth Ward needs economic development.
In the evening, former president Bill Clinton
was to headline a free concert and prayer servicecelebration
in New Orleans.
— The Associated Press
Bells toll
decade after
Katrina’s
wrath
By Rebecca Santana and Kevin McGill
KECSKEMET, Hungary — Four men
suspected of being involved in the
deaths of 71 refugees found in a truck
in Austria were placed under preliminary
arrest Saturday.
The preliminary arrests will be in
place until the suspects are indicted
or Sept. 29, at the latest, said Ferenc
Bicskei, president of the Kecskemet
Court.
The court agreed with prosecutors
that the severity of the crime and the
risk the suspects would flee justified
their arrest. Bicskei said the four suspects
appealed the decision, saying
they had not committed any crimes.
The three Bulgarian suspects are
aged 29, 30 and 50, officials said,
while the fourth suspect — an Afghan
— is 28 years old.
The refrigerated truck with the
dead refugees was found Thursday in
the safety lane of the main highway
from Budapest to Vienna. The suspects
were detained later that day in
southern Hungary, near the border
with Serbia, where Hungary is building
a four- metre fence.
Hungary said Saturday it had completed
the first phase of construction
— three coils of razor wire stretched
along the 174- kilometre boundary.
The case is being heard in Kecskemet,
in central Hungary, because
the truck set off from that city before
picking up the refugees near the
border with Serbia, Gabor Schmidt,
a spokesman for the Bacs- Kiskun
county chief prosecution office, told
reporters before the hearings.
Schmidt said Hungarian authorities
are investigating the suspects’ involvement
in the trafficking aspects
of the case, while their suspected connection
to the deaths of the refugees
is being investigated by Austrian authorities.
He said the prosecution strongly
suspects the four men co- operated
in the transportation of the victims
from Hungary to Austria, adding human
smuggling carries a sentence of
between two and 16 years in prison.
The four handcuffed men were
taken into the court building through
a side entrance.
The defence lawyers were not
present and will be notified of the
court decisions, court spokesman Szabolcs
Sarkozy said.
It wasn’t clear how long the bodies
had been inside the truck, but police
believe the victims might have been
dead by the time the truck crossed
into Austria overnight Wednesday.
It’s believed they suffocated.
— The Associated Press
4 suspects
arrested
for human
smuggling
ROGELIO V. SOLIS / THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
April Moore ( left) of Gulfport, Miss., cries after
thanking Anne Warren for praying for her.
A_ 06_ Aug- 30- 15_ FP_ 01. indd A6 8/ 29/ 15 11: 45: 37 PM