New Braunfels Herald Zeitung (Newspaper) - April 24, 2011, New Braunfels, Texas
State boards: Appoint? Elect? More? Less? On Herald-Zeitung.com
Dave McNeely has covered Texas fjolitics and government
1 he search never seems to end to find the perfect administrative structure for the state’s boards and commissions to oversee some of the state’s activities.
Here’s just a few of the changes being discussed:
• Rep. Burt Solomons, R-Carrollton, is talking about increasing the size of the 15-member vState Board of Education, because each member represents twice as many people as a state senator.
• There’s a move on to reduce the board of the Texas Department of Transportation from five appointed members to a single commissioner, to provide buck-stops-here accountability.
• lhe Sunset Advisory Commission has endorsed reducing the three-member elective Texas Railroad Commission to a single commissioner.
Some want to elect the commissioner, while others want the job filled by gubernatorial appointment, subject to approval by two-thirds of the Texas Senate.
A problem with three-member commissions is that they can run afoul of the Texas Open Meetings law. If two commissioners are in the restroom at the same time, that’s a quorum, and thus should be an open meeting.
That was one reason TxDOT’s commission was increased from three members to five a few years ago - so that two commissioners could have a conversation without violating the law. Another reason was to allow more regional representation.
The Railroad Commission, you may know, no longer regulates railroads. It regulates the oil and gas industry.
In politics, it has often provided an opportune launching pad to seek another statewide office. It provides a podium
and a reason to move around the state, and it’s a good place to raise money.
Its six-year term also can allow its members to run for another office without risking their seat on the commission.
That was the successful route followed by Democrat John Sharp to win the office of state comptroller in 1990. Republican Carole Keeton Strayhom did the same thing in 1998.
Other Railroad Commission members who have sought other offices include Democrat Buddy Temple for governor in 1982; Republican Kent Hance for governor in 1990; Democrat Bob Krueger for U.S. Senate in 1993; and Republican Barry Williamson for attorney general in 1998. ITiey all lost.
The recognition that the commission can be a bullpen for other offices is underlined in the current political cycle. TWo of the three Railroad Commission members - Republicans Michael Williams and Elizabeth Ames Jones - are seeking the U.S. Senate seat that Republican Kay Bailey Hutchison says she won’t run for again in 2012.
As for the State Board of Education, the state’s school oversight structure has traveled a winding path over the last century or so.
It’s gone from a single state superintendent of schools appointed by the governor, to an elected superintendent (including the first woman ever to hold statewide elective office - Annie Webb Blanton, elected in 1918), to an elected state board of education which chose the commissioner, replaced by an appointed board, back to an elected board, all the way to, in the mid-1990s, having the governor directly select the education com
And now, the governor gets to designate which of the board members will be its chair - though the Texas Senate has turned thumbs down on one of Gov. Rick Perry’s choices, and may turn down another.
The State Board of Education has been problematic ever since it was created. It was born of the Gilmer-Aikin school reforms of the late 1940s, to wire around a single elected commissioner of education.
The recommendation from the study group was a nine-member appointed board. But rural legislators feared big-city domination. So, to give better geographical representation of ideas from around the state, they called for electing one member from each of the state’s congressional districts.
In the 1950s, that made for a 21 -member board. By the next revamping of Texas education in 1984, Texas had gained six more members of Congress, making for a cumbersome 27-member board.
The board was reduced to 15 members appointed by the governor from individual districts. To appease legislators who thought the board should be elected, the reformers agreed to have the board revert to elective after four years.
But then-Lt. Gov. Bill Hobby and others thought the appointive board was preferable. The Legislature authorized a 1987 referendum to keep the board appointive, but it failed. Voters endorsed the return to an elective board by a 53-47 ratio, with unhappy teachers’ groups providing much of the oomph behind the effort.
Legislators probably aren’t real likely to make the 15-member board bigger. Some would like to abolish it altogether.
But, just as the tide goes out, and then comes back in, the rearrangements of agencies, boards and commissions, and how many members are chosen and how, and who’s in charge, likely will continue as well.Most popular stories:
Obituary: fames Edward Goodbread III
Selma police arrest man wanted in New Braunfels
DPS: Woman dies after driving in the Guadalupe
City Attorney Alan Wayland resigns by mutual agreement Motorcyclist dies in collision near Startzville over weekendMost commented stories:
Commissioners hear high-speed rail debate in night session
City Attorney Alan Wayland resigns by mutual agreement
Letter to the editor: Tourist dollars have more pull than the average resident
Editorial: Manners missing at Monday council meeting
Letter to the editor: GOP plan looks, feels like forced health care rationing
Online voices: The conversation continues 24/7
Several online waders commented on the editorial “Manners missing at Monday's meeting”: Ionizer wrote: Show them your anger in the ballot box. If they won’t be responsive to the public whom elected them, make them pay. Vote them out. That is how honest, responsive,
government is formed. Ilum up the heat during the next election. Vote! Will somebody please run against these people? People walk miles in other countries for the right to vote for more than one person.
Look what’s going on in the Middle East. They are dying for this right. We are giving it away.
LINEUP FOR TODAY'S NEWS SHOWS
■ ABC's "This Week"
(KSAT San Antonio 8 a.m.
— Evangelist Franklin Graham; the Rev. AI Sharpton; Richard Land of the Southern Baptist Convention; Eboo Patel, founder of Interfaith Youth Lieberman Core; Tim Keller, pastor of Redeemer Presbyterian Church in New York City.
■ NBC's "Meet the Press" —(KENS 5 8 a.m.) Sens. Kent Conrad, D-N.D., and Tom Coburn, R-Okla. Plouffe
■ CBS' "Face the Nation"
(WOAI 8 a.m.) — Sens. Chris Coons, D-Del.; Richard Blumenthal, D-Conn.; and Mark Kirk, R-lll; Reps. Tim Griffin, R-
Ark., and Joe Walsh, R-lll. ■ CNN's "State of the Union" (9-10 a.m. and noon to 1 p.m.) — Sens. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C.; Joe Lieberman, independent of Connecticut; Michael Bennet, D-Colo.; Lamar Alexander, R-Tenn.; former Undersecretary of State Nicholas Burns; retired Gen. George Joulwan, a former top NATO commander in Europe; Randi Weingarten, president of the American Federation of Teachers.
Akidemy Korner & Learning Center Inc.
Come meet our New Director Ms. Lily and see our New Facility for aftercare & summer programs
NOW ENROLLING FOR 7AM-6PM CHILDCARE. INFANTS THRU PRE-K
Contact Ms. Lily (915) 203-0676 »Space is limitedDo you have a special child and need a church?
Autisum, Down Syndrome and other special needs.
Introducing a new special needs ministry. We would love to have you come and join us!
Ages 5-1 2
1895 S. Walnut Ave. New Braunfels,TX. 78130 (830) 630-4353
Jesus Loves All Children!
■ "Fox News Sunday" (WTTG 9 a.m.) — New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg; former Sen. Rick Santorum, R-Pa.
TRUMP SKIPPED PRIMARY VOTING 21 YEARS
NEW YORK (AP) — Donald Trump says he’s considering running in the primary for the Republican presidential nomination, but the real estate mogul didn’t vote in primary elections for more than two decades, according to the New York City Board of Elections.
The possible GOP candidate voted in a primary election in the 1989 New York City mayor’s race—when Rudy Giuliani beat businessman Ronald Lauder—then didn’t vote in a primary for 21 years, board spokeswoman Valerie Vazquez said Saturday. The report on lYump’s voting record initially appeared on TV station NY1 a day earlier. Records also show Trump skipped the 2002 general election, when Republican incumbent Gov. George Pataki
ENROLLING NOW f OR SUMMER!
defeated Democrat H. Carl McCall, Vazquez said. But Trump told the station he’s voted in every general election.
“You’re going to pay a big price because you’re wrong,” he told the station. “I have records that I voted and so does the Board of Elections ... I signed in at every election.”
His lawyer, Michael Cohen, said Trump could not be reached for comment.
The lawyer also said he could not confirm which party Trump belonged to in previous years.
SEE SCHEDULE ONLINE @
Sfie/t/tts Su/eet Sfiobbe
Wedding season is here!
Come by to get custom cakes and cupcakes for Weddings, Graduation & Special events!
10% off all Mothers Day orders
1190 W. SAN ANTONIO STREET« NEW BRAUNFELS, TX 78130
20 Î f Second
When: Friday, May 6, 2011
Where: New Braunfels Civic Center Kongresshalle 380 S. Seguin Avenue, New Braunfels, TX 78130
Community Co-Chairs: Barry & Cindy Williams
Special Recognition: Pinnacle Club Charter Members
Individual Tickets: $100
Attire: Black Tie Optional
Gala Sponsorships Available
Contact: Ann Whitis, Director of Marketing 830/625-6291, ext. 234 [email protected]
Community Co-Chairs Cindy and Barry Williams
Legacy Benefactor Sponsors: • h* Mantuamwnmm
631 Lakaviaw Blvd., New Braunfels, TX 78130 830/825-6291 830.608-0469 fax www.edanhlll.org
Entertainment: Jazz, Blues and Diamonds
Net proceeds from tbi» event will support programming to benefit our beloved residents, ^^jjjtm^nrejax-^ductible in accordance with IRS guidelines.